What are the guidelines for chest tube placement in an adult patient with pneumothorax?

Chest Tube Placement Guidelines for Pneumothorax

Direct Answer

For primary spontaneous pneumothorax, attempt simple aspiration first if the pneumothorax is >2 cm and symptomatic; insert a chest tube only if aspiration fails. For secondary pneumothorax, insert a chest tube immediately for any pneumothorax >2 cm or in patients with significant underlying lung disease, and always insert a chest tube in mechanically ventilated patients regardless of size. 1

---

Primary Spontaneous Pneumothorax

Initial Management Strategy

• Simple aspiration is the first-line intervention for all primary pneumothoraces requiring treatment, before considering chest tube insertion 1
• If aspiration fails to re-expand the lung, proceed to chest tube insertion 1
• Re-aspiration can be attempted if initial aspiration is unsuccessful 2

Size-Based Criteria

• Pneumothoraces >2 cm from the chest wall on chest radiograph warrant intervention 1
• Smaller pneumothoraces (<2 cm) in symptomatic patients may still require aspiration 2

---

Secondary Spontaneous Pneumothorax

Immediate Chest Tube Indications

Insert a chest tube immediately (without attempting aspiration first) for: 1

• Any secondary pneumothorax >2 cm from the chest wall
• Any pneumothorax in patients with COPD or significant underlying lung disease (these patients are less likely to respond to aspiration and more likely to require tube drainage) 1
• All mechanically ventilated patients with pneumothorax, regardless of size 1, 3

Exceptions Where Observation May Be Appropriate

• Pneumothoraces <1 cm in asymptomatic patients 1
• Isolated apical pneumothoraces in asymptomatic patients 1

---

Cystic Fibrosis Patients (Special Population)

Large Pneumothorax

• Always place a chest tube for large pneumothorax in CF patients 2, 1
• Clinical stability does not change this recommendation 2

Small Pneumothorax

• Place chest tube only if clinically unstable (tachypnea, hypoxemia, hemodynamic compromise) 2
• If clinically stable with small pneumothorax, close outpatient observation is acceptable 2
• Pain from chest tube may outweigh benefits in stable patients with small pneumothorax 2

---

Tension Pneumothorax (Emergency)

Immediate Intervention Required

• Insert a cannula immediately into the second intercostal space, mid-clavicular line, before obtaining imaging 2
• Use a cannula at least 4.5 cm long (standard 3 cm cannulas are inadequate in 57% of patients) 2
• Leave the cannula in place until a functioning chest tube is positioned and bubbling is confirmed 2
• Suspect tension pneumothorax in any mechanically ventilated patient who suddenly deteriorates 2

---

Chest Tube Selection and Technique

Tube Size

• Use small-bore tubes (10-14F) initially for most pneumothoraces 2, 1, 4
• Large-bore tubes (20-24F) offer no advantage over small tubes for pneumothorax 1
• Consider large-bore tubes (24-28F) only for mechanically ventilated patients with anticipated large air leaks or bronchopleural fistula 3

Insertion Technique

• Use imaging guidance (ultrasound preferred, or CT) for tube placement 1
• Use blunt dissection for tubes >24F or Seldinger technique for smaller tubes 4
• Never use trocar technique due to high risk of organ injury 5, 4
• Insert at the 4th or 5th intercostal space in the mid- or anterior-axillary line 5

---

Drainage System Management

Initial Setup

• Connect to water seal (gravity) drainage initially without suction for most patients 1, 3
• Do not apply suction immediately after tube insertion 2

When to Apply Suction

Apply suction immediately only in these specific circumstances: 1, 3

• Patient is mechanically ventilated
• Large pneumothorax with clinical instability
• Anticipated bronchopleural fistula with large air leak

Suction Parameters

• If suction is needed after 48 hours for persistent air leak or failure to re-expand, use high-volume, low-pressure systems (-10 to -20 cm H₂O) 2, 1, 3

---

Critical Safety Rules

Never Clamp the Chest Tube

• Never clamp a bubbling chest tube—this can convert a simple pneumothorax into tension pneumothorax 3
• Even non-bubbling tubes should not be routinely clamped in ventilated patients 3
• Drain-clamping test before tube withdrawal is generally not advocated 4

---

Referral Criteria

When to Refer to Respiratory Specialist

Refer within 48 hours if: 2, 1, 3

• Pneumothorax fails to respond to treatment within 48 hours
• Persistent air leak exceeding 48 hours duration
• Complex drain management needed (suction adjustment, drain repositioning)

Where to Manage

• Patients requiring suction should only be managed on specialized lung units with experienced medical and nursing staff 2, 3

---

Chest Tube Removal Criteria

Remove chest tube only after confirming ALL of the following: 1

• No air leak present
• Complete pneumothorax resolution on chest radiograph
• Discontinuation of any suction
• Repeat chest radiograph 5-12 hours after last evidence of air leak
• Wait 24 hours after bubbling stops before removal 1
• Ensure adequate analgesia before removal 1

---

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not routinely insert chest tubes for primary pneumothorax without attempting aspiration first—this leads to approximately 7,000 unnecessary chest drain insertions annually in the UK 2
• Do not use high-pressure, high-volume suction systems—these can cause air stealing, hypoxemia, or perpetuate persistent air leaks 2
• Do not remove chest tube prematurely in ventilated patients—ensure complete resolution and cessation of air leak 3
• Do not forget full aseptic technique—empyema occurs in 1-6% of cases 3