What are the differences in symptoms between chronic migraines, dizziness, and Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension (IIH)?

Symptom Differences Between Chronic Migraine, Dizziness, and Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension

While chronic migraine and IIH share overlapping headache features that can be clinically indistinguishable, IIH is distinguished by specific symptoms of elevated intracranial pressure—particularly pulsatile tinnitus, transient visual obscurations, and papilledema—that are absent in primary chronic migraine. 1, 2

Chronic Migraine Symptoms

Headache Characteristics:

• Moderate to severe pain that is typically throbbing in quality 1
• Occurs 15 or more days per month for at least 3 months 3
• Associated with photophobia, phonophobia, nausea, and movement intolerance 1

Key Distinguishing Features:

• No symptoms of elevated intracranial pressure 2
• No papilledema on examination 1
• Normal CSF opening pressure (typically <25 cm H₂O) 4

Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension Symptoms

Headache Characteristics:

• Progressively more severe and frequent headache pattern 1, 4
• Headache phenotype is highly variable and may mimic migraine in 68% of IIH patients 1
• The headache alone is indistinguishable from migraine 2

Pathognomonic Symptoms of Elevated ICP:

• Pulsatile tinnitus (whooshing sound synchronous with pulse)—a critical distinguishing feature 1, 5
• Transient visual obscurations (unilateral or bilateral darkening of vision lasting seconds) 1, 4
• Visual blurring 1, 4
• Horizontal diplopia (typically from sixth nerve palsy) 1, 4

Additional Symptoms:

• Dizziness 1, 5
• Neck pain 1, 5
• Back pain 1, 5
• Cognitive disturbances 1, 5
• Radicular pain 1, 5

Critical Physical Finding:

• Papilledema is the hallmark finding that distinguishes IIH from chronic migraine 4, 5
• IIH without papilledema exists but is rare and diagnostically challenging 4, 5

Dizziness in Both Conditions

In Chronic Migraine:

• Dizziness may occur as part of vestibular migraine presentation 6
• Episodic vertigo can be present 6
• Positional vertigo may occur 6

In IIH:

• Dizziness is a recognized symptom of elevated intracranial pressure 1, 5
• Often presents with head fullness-pressure sensation 6
• May be accompanied by low-pitch pulsatile tinnitus, which is diagnostically important 6

Clinical Overlap and Diagnostic Pitfalls

Critical Overlap:

• Both conditions frequently coexist—increased ICP in patients with pre-existing migraine may present with migraine-like headaches and contribute to migraine chronification 3
• The headache characteristics alone cannot distinguish between the two conditions 2
• Obesity (BMI >30) is a significant risk factor for both chronic migraine and IIH, with BMI strongly correlated with CSF opening pressure 7

Diagnostic Algorithm:

• Step 1: Assess for symptoms of elevated ICP—specifically pulsatile tinnitus, transient visual obscurations, and visual changes 1, 2
• Step 2: Perform fundoscopic examination for papilledema 4, 5
• Step 3: If BMI >30 in chronic migraine patients, strongly consider lumbar puncture to rule out IIH without papilledema 7
• Step 4: MRI brain with venography within 24 hours to exclude secondary causes and assess for IIH imaging findings (empty sella, optic nerve sheath enlargement, posterior globe flattening) 4, 5
• Step 5: Lumbar puncture with opening pressure measurement in lateral decubitus position—pressure ≥25 cm H₂O confirms elevated ICP 4

Common Pitfall:

• Failing to recognize that 10% of chronic migraine patients may have elevated CSF opening pressure without papilledema, particularly in obese patients 7
• Assuming normal fundoscopy excludes IIH—IIH without papilledema occurs and requires LP for diagnosis 4, 7
• Missing the diagnostic significance of pulsatile tinnitus, which strongly suggests elevated ICP rather than primary migraine 1, 6