Blood Pressure Targets and Mortality in Elderly Hemodialysis Patients with Diabetes and Cardiovascular Disease
Critical Evidence Gap for Dialysis Patients
There is no established blood pressure target for patients on maintenance hemodialysis, as major guidelines explicitly refrain from making recommendations due to insufficient evidence. 1
- The 2012 KDIGO guideline and the 2017 ACC/AHA guideline do not recommend specific BP goals for patients receiving maintenance dialysis due to lack of evidence from randomized controlled trials. 1
- The 2010 KDIGO controversies conference on BP in dialysis patients highlighted that optimal BP assessment and treatment targets remain unresolved, with no consensus on diagnosis or treatment algorithms. 1
- Most observational data from dialysis populations show a "U" or "J"-shaped relationship between blood pressure and mortality, complicating target selection. 1
Historical Context: The 2005 K/DOQI Recommendation
The 2005 K/DOQI guideline made a grade C recommendation (expert opinion-based) for:
- Predialysis BP target: <140/90 mmHg
- Postdialysis BP target: <130/80 mmHg
However, this recommendation acknowledged the complete lack of evidence supporting any specific BP threshold for initiating or titrating antihypertensive medications. 1
Why Standard Targets Don't Apply to Dialysis Patients
Evidence from Non-Dialysis Populations Cannot Be Extrapolated
The major trials establishing BP targets specifically excluded dialysis patients:
ACCORD BP (diabetes-specific): Targeted SBP <120 mmHg vs. 130-140 mmHg in diabetic patients with cardiovascular disease, but excluded dialysis patients. The trial showed no benefit in the primary composite endpoint (nonfatal MI, nonfatal stroke, CVD death), though stroke risk was reduced 41% with intensive control. 1
SPRINT (non-diabetic): Showed intensive SBP <120 mmHg reduced mortality by 27% and cardiovascular events by 25%, but explicitly excluded patients with diabetes and dialysis patients. 1
ADVANCE: Used fixed-dose perindopril/indapamide achieving mean BP 136/73 mmHg, reducing death from any cause by 14% and CVD death by 18%, but excluded dialysis patients. 1
Unique Pathophysiology in Dialysis Patients
- Dialysis patients have cardiomyopathy and multiple comorbid conditions that fundamentally alter the BP-mortality relationship. 1
- There is poor correlation between dialysis clinic BP measurements and mean interdialytic BP assessed by 44-hour ambulatory monitoring, making accurate BP assessment challenging. 1
- The absence of normal nocturnal BP decrease is common in dialysis patients and may indicate more severe disease. 2
Practical Approach in the Absence of Evidence
Conservative Target Based on Observational Data
Given the U-shaped mortality curve in dialysis populations, a reasonable approach is:
- Predialysis BP: 130-150/70-80 mmHg
- Postdialysis BP: 120-140/65-75 mmHg
This conservative range avoids both the risks of hypoperfusion (particularly cerebral and cardiac) and uncontrolled hypertension. 1, 3
Critical Safety Thresholds
Avoid the following, as they may increase mortality:
- Systolic BP <120 mmHg: May compromise perfusion in patients with impaired autoregulation and existing cardiovascular disease. 4, 3
- Diastolic BP <70 mmHg: Associated with increased cardiovascular risk and may compromise cerebral perfusion, particularly critical in elderly patients. 4, 3, 2
Monitoring Strategy
- Measure standing BP at each visit to detect orthostatic hypotension, which increases fall risk and mortality. 3, 2
- Consider home BP monitoring or ambulatory BP monitoring during interdialytic periods, as clinic measurements correlate poorly with true BP burden. 1
- Monitor for symptoms of hypoperfusion: new or worsening cognitive decline, dizziness, falls, syncope, or angina. 3
Pharmacological Considerations
First-Line Therapy
RAAS blockers (ACE inhibitors or ARBs) remain first-line therapy even in dialysis patients with diabetes and cardiovascular disease, particularly if residual proteinuria exists. 1, 4, 2
- The LIFE study showed losartan reduced stroke by 25% and cardiovascular death by 11% compared to atenolol in hypertensive patients with left ventricular hypertrophy, achieving mean BP 143/76 mmHg. 5
- The RENAAL study in type 2 diabetic nephropathy showed losartan reduced ESRD by 29% and doubling of serum creatinine by 25%, achieving mean BP 143/76 mmHg. 5
Combination Therapy
- Combination of RAAS blocker with calcium channel blocker or thiazide/thiazide-like diuretic is typically required. 4, 2
- Avoid combining ACE inhibitor with ARB, as this increases harm without additional benefit. 1
Titration Approach
- Start with low doses and titrate slowly, allowing at least 4 weeks between adjustments to observe full response and avoid overly aggressive lowering. 3, 2
- Simplify regimens with once-daily dosing and single-pill combinations when possible to improve adherence. 2
Key Pitfalls to Avoid
Do not aggressively target SBP <120 mmHg based on SPRINT results, as dialysis patients were excluded and have fundamentally different hemodynamics. 1, 4
Do not allow diastolic BP to fall below 70 mmHg, even if systolic BP remains elevated, as this may increase mortality. 4, 3, 2
Do not rely solely on predialysis or postdialysis clinic measurements, as these correlate poorly with true BP burden. 1
Do not ignore symptoms of hypoperfusion in pursuit of numerical targets, as quality of life and functional status are paramount in this population. 3
The Bottom Line for Clinical Practice
In elderly hemodialysis patients with diabetes and cardiovascular disease, aim for predialysis BP 130-150/70-80 mmHg and postdialysis BP 120-140/65-75 mmHg, prioritizing avoidance of hypoperfusion over aggressive lowering. 1, 4, 3
This conservative approach acknowledges:
- The complete absence of randomized trial evidence in dialysis populations 1
- The U-shaped mortality curve observed in dialysis cohorts 1
- The high burden of comorbidity and frailty in elderly dialysis patients 1, 3
- The primacy of quality of life and functional status over numerical targets 3
If current BP is within this range and the patient is asymptomatic, no intensification of therapy is needed. 3 If symptoms of hypoperfusion develop, reduce antihypertensive therapy regardless of BP readings. 3