Blood Screening for Cancer Detection
Yes, blood screening tests for cancer exist, but they are currently limited to specific contexts: PSA testing for prostate cancer in high-risk individuals (particularly those with BRCA2 mutations or strong family history), and emerging multi-cancer early detection tests that are still under investigation and not yet part of standard screening guidelines. 1, 2
Established Blood-Based Cancer Screening
Prostate-Specific Antigen (PSA) Testing
PSA testing is the only widely established blood screening test for cancer detection, specifically for prostate cancer in defined high-risk populations. 1, 2
High-Risk Populations Warranting PSA Screening:
Men with BRCA2 mutations should begin PSA screening at age 40, as they have a 2-6 fold increased risk of aggressive prostate cancer with significantly reduced survival compared to non-carriers 3, 2
Men with BRCA1 mutations should consider PSA screening starting at age 40 3, 2
Men with other germline mutations (ATM, CHEK2, PALB2, mismatch repair genes) should begin screening at age 40 2
Men with a strong family history (brother, father, or multiple family members diagnosed before age 60) should begin screening at age 40-45 1
Men with a single first-degree relative diagnosed before age 60 should begin screening at age 45 1
Important Caveats About PSA Screening:
Baseline PSA value is a stronger predictive factor than family history or race alone 3, 2
BRCA2 carriers with PSA >3.0 ng/mL have significantly higher positive predictive value for detecting intermediate/high-grade cancer (2.4% vs 0.7%; P=.04) 3, 2
Screening intervals of 1-2 years are recommended rather than annual testing to reduce unnecessary biopsies while retaining 87-95% of life-years saved 1
Genetic Testing for Cancer Risk Assessment
Germline genetic testing is a form of blood screening that identifies inherited cancer susceptibility, though it detects risk rather than active cancer. 3, 2
Recommended Genetic Testing Scenarios:
Individuals with personal history of prostate cancer and ≥1 close blood relatives with breast cancer (age ≤50) or ovarian cancer, or ≥2 relatives with breast, pancreatic, or prostate cancer (Gleason ≥7) 3
Patients with pancreatic cancer should undergo universal genetic testing regardless of family history, as typical clinical factors poorly predict mutation carriers 3
Testing should include at minimum: BRCA1, BRCA2, ATM, CHEK2, PALB2, MLH1, MSH2, MSH6, PMS2 2
First-degree relatives of patients with pancreatic cancer may benefit from testing, though testing the affected patient is preferred 3
Emerging Multi-Cancer Early Detection Tests
Blood-based multi-cancer early detection tests are under investigation but are NOT currently recommended for routine screening. 4, 5
Current Status:
Multiple tests (CancerSEEK, Galleri, PanSeer) are in clinical trials showing high specificity in preliminary findings 5
These tests have potential to detect cancers for which no screening currently exists, which account for 71% of cancer deaths 4
However, it remains unclear if their use can reduce cancer mortality, and issues of cost-effectiveness, false-positives, and false-negatives remain unresolved 4
These tests are not yet validated for clinical use and should not be used outside of research protocols 5, 6
Traditional Tumor Biomarkers
Traditional tumor biomarkers have limited sensitivity and specificity for cancer screening in asymptomatic individuals. 7
Most tumor markers (CA-125, CEA, AFP, etc.) are used for monitoring known cancer rather than screening 7
The risk of overdiagnosis remains a particular concern, whereby lesions of no clinical consequence may be detected, creating difficult management decisions 7
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
Do not confuse somatic tumor sequencing with germline testing - somatic tests are not designed or validated for germline assessment 2
If germline mutation is suspected from tumor testing, refer for genetic counseling and dedicated germline testing 2
Do not screen with PSA in average-risk men without considering individual risk factors and shared decision-making 1
Do not use multi-cancer detection tests outside of clinical trials - they lack validation for clinical decision-making 4, 5