What are the differential diagnoses, proposed investigations, treatment options, and potential risks for a patient presenting with a 2-year history of progressively enlarging right parotid swelling without pain or skin changes?

Parotid Swelling: Differential Diagnosis, Investigation, and Management

Differential Diagnoses (2 marks)

For a painless, progressively enlarging parotid mass over 2 years, the two most likely diagnoses are pleomorphic adenoma (benign) and low-grade mucoepidermoid carcinoma (malignant). 1

• Pleomorphic adenoma is the most common benign parotid tumor (60-70% of all parotid tumors), typically presenting as a slowly progressive, painless swelling in patients aged 30-50 years with female predominance 2, 1
• Low-grade mucoepidermoid carcinoma is the most common malignant parotid tumor and can present identically to benign lesions with slow, painless growth over years, making clinical distinction difficult 1

The absence of pain, skin changes, or facial nerve dysfunction does not exclude malignancy, as low-grade salivary cancers behave similarly to benign tumors in their clinical presentation 1

---

Proposed Investigations (1 mark)

The two essential investigations are: (1) MRI neck with and without IV contrast, and (2) ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB). 1

Investigation Details:

• MRI neck with and without IV contrast is the preferred initial imaging modality because it provides comprehensive assessment of deep lobe involvement, perineural tumor spread, temporal bone extension, and superior soft tissue characterization to distinguish tumor from normal parotid tissue 1

• Ultrasound-guided FNAB should be performed to obtain tissue diagnosis using the Milan System for Reporting Salivary Gland Cytopathology, which categorizes lesions by risk of malignancy and guides surgical planning 1, 3

  • Note that false-negative rates can reach 20%, so negative cytology does not exclude malignancy 1
  • Intraoperative frozen section (99% accuracy for identifying neoplastic lesions) serves as a useful adjunct during surgery if preoperative diagnosis remains uncertain 1

---

Treatment Based on Provisional Diagnosis (1 mark)

Surgical excision via superficial parotidectomy with facial nerve preservation is the definitive treatment for both benign and low-grade malignant parotid tumors. 1

Surgical Approach Algorithm:

• For pleomorphic adenoma (benign): Perform partial superficial parotidectomy with complete tumor excision and adequate margins to prevent recurrence 1

• For T1-T2 low-grade malignancy: Perform partial superficial parotidectomy for appropriately located superficial tumors, as complete excision with even narrow margins (≤2-5mm) achieves excellent locoregional control (90-100% at 5+ years) without need for additional parotid tissue removal 1

• Facial nerve preservation is paramount in both scenarios unless there is direct tumor invasion, as decisions causing major harm (facial nerve sacrifice) should not be based on indeterminate preoperative findings alone 1

---

Two Common Risks of Parotid Surgery (1 mark)

The two most significant complications are: (1) facial nerve injury/paralysis, and (2) Frey's syndrome (gustatory sweating). 1

Risk Details:

• Facial nerve injury is the most feared complication, ranging from temporary weakness to permanent paralysis, occurring because the facial nerve courses through the parotid gland and must be carefully dissected and preserved during surgery 1

  • Risk increases with extent of parotidectomy (superficial vs. total) and tumor proximity to nerve branches 1

• Frey's syndrome (auriculotemporal syndrome) develops in a significant proportion of patients post-parotidectomy, manifesting as gustatory sweating and flushing over the parotid region during eating due to aberrant reinnervation of severed parasympathetic nerve fibers to cutaneous sweat glands 1

Additional Common Complications:

• Salivary fistula formation
• Greater auricular nerve injury causing numbness of the earlobe
• Hematoma/seroma formation
• Tumor recurrence (especially with inadequate margins in pleomorphic adenoma)