What are the differences in diagnosis and treatment between ileus paralysis and obstructive ileus in patients presenting with symptoms of ileus?

Distinguishing Paralytic Ileus from Mechanical Obstruction

CT abdomen with IV contrast is the definitive diagnostic test to differentiate paralytic ileus from mechanical small bowel obstruction, achieving 100% sensitivity and specificity, and should be obtained immediately rather than relying on clinical examination or plain radiographs. 1

Key Diagnostic Differences

Clinical Presentation

Mechanical Obstruction:

• Intermittent crampy central abdominal pain that comes in waves 2
• Earlier and more prominent nausea and vomiting (especially in small bowel obstruction) 2
• High-pitched or tinkling bowel sounds on examination 2
• Progressive abdominal distension (sudden onset in volvulus, gradual in malignancy) 2

Paralytic Ileus:

• Diffuse, constant abdominal discomfort rather than colicky pain 3
• Absent or hypoactive bowel sounds 2
• Generalized abdominal distension affecting both small and large bowel 4
• Associated with identifiable precipitating factors (postoperative state, medications, electrolyte abnormalities, inflammation) 2, 3

Imaging Characteristics

CT Findings - Mechanical Obstruction:

• Dilated bowel loops proximal to a distinct transition point 1
• Collapsed bowel distal to the obstruction 1
• Identifiable cause at the transition zone (adhesions, hernia, mass, stricture) 2
• Small bowel diameter >3 cm indicates significant obstruction 5
• May show closed-loop configuration, mesenteric edema, or signs of ischemia 2, 5

CT Findings - Paralytic Ileus:

• Diffuse dilatation of both small and large bowel without a transition point 1, 4
• No mechanical obstructing lesion identified 1
• Gas distributed throughout the entire gastrointestinal tract including rectum 4
• Absence of focal wall thickening or mass 1

Plain radiographs are unreliable with only 30-70% accuracy and can be misleading in 20-40% of cases, making them inadequate for definitive diagnosis. 2, 5

Ultrasound Findings (When Available)

Mechanical Obstruction:

• Dilated loops with vigorous "to-and-fro" or pendulum peristalsis proximal to obstruction 4
• Visible Kerckring folds in dilated jejunum 4
• Collapsed bowel distal to obstruction 4
• Pearlstring-like gas bubbles under ventral intestinal wall 4

Paralytic Ileus:

• Diffuse bowel dilatation without transition point 4
• Absent or markedly reduced peristalsis on real-time imaging 4
• Both small and large bowel affected 4

Management Approach Algorithm

Step 1: Immediate Diagnostic Workup

• Obtain CT abdomen/pelvis with IV contrast immediately (do NOT wait for plain films) 5, 1
• Draw labs: CBC, electrolytes (especially potassium and magnesium), BUN/creatinine, lactate, CRP 5
• Insert nasogastric tube for gastric decompression 5
• Make patient NPO and start IV crystalloid resuscitation 5

Step 2: CT Interpretation and Risk Stratification

High-Risk Features Requiring Urgent Surgery:

• Closed-loop obstruction 5
• Signs of ischemia: reduced/absent bowel wall enhancement, pneumatosis, mesenteric venous gas, mesenteric edema with ascites 2, 5
• Free intraperitoneal air suggesting perforation 5
• Complete high-grade obstruction with clinical deterioration 2

Mechanical Obstruction Without High-Risk Features:

• Continue conservative management: NPO, NG decompression, IV fluids 5
• After gastric decompression, administer 50-150 mL water-soluble contrast (Gastrografin) via NG tube 5
• Obtain abdominal X-ray at 24 hours to assess contrast progression (96% sensitivity, 98% specificity for predicting resolution) 5
• If no improvement by 48-72 hours, obtain repeat CT and surgical consultation 5

Paralytic Ileus:

• Conservative supportive management: bowel rest, NG decompression, IV fluids 5
• Aggressively correct electrolyte abnormalities, particularly potassium and magnesium 5
• Review and discontinue medications impairing peristalsis: opioids (consider supervised withdrawal if chronic use), anticholinergics, calcium channel blockers 2, 5
• Thoracic epidural analgesia reduces incidence of postoperative paralytic ileus if applicable 2

Step 3: Monitoring for Complications

Watch for deterioration requiring escalation:

• Development of peritoneal signs on examination 5
• Rising lactate or white blood cell count 5
• Worsening abdominal distension 5
• Failure to improve within 48-72 hours 5

If clinical deterioration occurs, obtain repeat CT immediately—do not delay, as ischemia can develop rapidly with 25% mortality. 2, 5

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not rely on clinical examination and plain films alone—they have only 19% sensitivity for distinguishing mechanical obstruction from ileus 1
• Do not administer oral contrast in high-grade complete obstruction before adequate gastric decompression and IV rehydration, as this risks aspiration pneumonia and hypovolemic shock 5
• Do not use positive oral contrast for diagnostic CT—the intraluminal fluid already present provides excellent natural contrast 5
• Do not order serial plain radiographs after CT has been obtained—they add no diagnostic value and waste time 5
• Do not assume paralytic ileus in postoperative patients—up to 20% may have unrecognized mechanical obstruction requiring surgery 1

Special Considerations

Postoperative Setting:

• Opioids exacerbate ileus in patients with intestinal overdistension 2
• Postoperative ileus is caused by pharmacological agents (anesthetics, opioids), neural mechanisms, and intestinal inflammation from surgical manipulation 2
• CT remains 100% effective in distinguishing postoperative ileus from mechanical obstruction 1

Severe Complications:

• Both mechanical obstruction and paralytic ileus can cause intra-abdominal hypertension (IAP >20-25 mmHg) leading to abdominal compartment syndrome with multiple organ dysfunction 6
• Prolonged ileus results in bacterial overgrowth, translocation, and systemic inflammatory response syndrome 6
• Decompressive laparotomy with temporary abdominal closure is required for abdominal compartment syndrome 6

Cancer Patients:

• Severe C. difficile colitis can present with paralytic ileus, toxic megacolon, or perforation 2
• Distinguishing mechanical from functional obstruction in peritoneal carcinomatosis is particularly challenging 7