What are the treatment options for an adult patient with Dupuytren's contracture in the hands?

Treatment for Dupuytren's Contracture in the Hands

For Dupuytren's contracture, collagenase clostridium histolyticum injection is the preferred first-line treatment for isolated metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joint contractures, while limited fasciectomy remains the gold standard for extensive disease involving both MCP and proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joints, offering the longest disease-free interval despite longer recovery. 1, 2, 3

Treatment Algorithm Based on Disease Severity

Mild to Moderate Contracture (MCP Joint Only)

Collagenase injection (Xiaflex 0.58 mg) should be your first choice, as it achieves 44.4% complete correction to 0-5° of normal extension and provides a mean 70.5% reduction in contracture degree with minimal downtime 3. This treatment:

• Requires up to 3 injections per cord, with cord disruption attempted 24 hours after injection using standardized finger extension 3
• Produces mean range of motion improvement of 35.4° 3
• Results in no tendon ruptures or systemic allergic reactions in clinical trials 3
• Achieves 50.7% success rate across all joint types in open-label extension studies 3

Needle aponeurotomy is an alternative minimally invasive option, particularly when combined with ultrasound guidance and local anesthetic injection, though evidence is limited to case reports showing dramatic symptom relief 4. This approach offers immediate results with minimal recovery time 1.

Extensive Disease (MCP + PIP Involvement)

Limited fasciectomy is the definitive treatment for contractures involving multiple joints, as 87.1% of hand surgeons recognize it provides the longest disease-free interval 2. This surgical approach:

• Requires lengthy postoperative rehabilitation but delivers durable results 1
• Is preferred by plastic surgeons over collagenase for young, working patients (plastic surgeons favor fasciectomy while orthopedic surgeons prefer collagenase in this scenario) 2
• Should be performed by experienced hand surgeons given the complexity and complication risk 5

Recurrent or Severe Contracture

Proceed directly to open fasciectomy rather than repeating minimally invasive procedures, as patients with severe or recurrent disease have higher complication rates regardless of treatment modality 5. Consider primary amputation only for uncorrectable contractures with significant necrosis, paresis, ischemic pain, or sepsis 6.

Critical Treatment Considerations

Patient Selection Factors

• Age and activity level matter: For young, working patients amenable to any option, 42.7% of surgeons use collagenase, though plastic and general surgeons lean toward fasciectomy 2
• Patient goals must drive decisions: Balance functional requirements, recovery time tolerance, and complication acceptance 5
• Contracture location is decisive: MCP-only disease favors collagenase; combined MCP-PIP disease favors fasciectomy 2

Complications to Anticipate

The most serious complications include 5:

• Digital nerve injury or postoperative neurapraxia
• Flexor tendon injury or rupture (one flexion pulley rupture reported with collagenase) 3
• Delayed wound healing or skin necrosis (primarily with surgical approaches)
• Contracture recurrence (no recurrence observed at 90 days post-collagenase in trials) 3
• Hematoma and infection (surgical complications)

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Do not use collagenase for PIP joint contractures as primary treatment when combined with MCP involvement—the success rate drops and fasciectomy provides superior long-term outcomes 2, 3.

Do not promise permanent correction with any modality—recurrence is inherent to Dupuytren's disease progression, though fasciectomy offers the longest disease-free interval 2, 5.

Patient education is paramount before any intervention—explicitly discuss that all treatments carry recurrence risk, and complications increase with disease severity 5.

Adjunctive Conservative Measures

While awaiting definitive treatment or for early disease, implement 7:

• Daily static stretching exercises when pain is minimal, holding terminal stretch for 10-30 seconds 7
• Superficial moist heat before exercises to improve effectiveness 7
• Appropriate orthotics to counteract deforming forces, though avoid prolonged use beyond necessary healing periods 7

Avoid benzodiazepines entirely during any recovery period, as they impair neurological recovery and cause excessive sedation 8, 7.