What is the proposed use of Buscopan (hyoscine butylbromide) and Metoclopramide in a patient with acute gastritis or gastroenteritis, particularly those with underlying conditions such as diabetes or impaired renal function, and when to use D5LR (5% dextrose in lactated Ringer's solution) versus Plain NSS (normal saline solution)?

Buscopan and Metoclopramide in Acute Gastritis/Gastroenteritis

Neither Buscopan (hyoscine butylbromide) nor metoclopramide should be used in acute gastritis or gastroenteritis, as they have no role in the management of these conditions and may worsen outcomes. 1

Why These Medications Are Inappropriate

Metoclopramide: Explicitly Contraindicated

• The American Gastroenterological Association explicitly recommends against metoclopramide in gastroenteritis (Grade D recommendation: fair evidence that it is ineffective or harms outweigh benefits). 1
• Metoclopramide is a prokinetic agent that increases gastrointestinal motility and accelerates transit, which is counterproductive in acute diarrheal illness where the goal is to reduce stool output, not accelerate it. 1
• The CDC guidelines emphasize that antimotility and antisecretory agents should not be used in acute gastroenteritis as they do not demonstrate effectiveness in reducing diarrhea volume or duration. 1
• Metoclopramide's only FDA-approved indication is for chronic gastroparesis (delayed gastric emptying), not acute gastroenteritis. 2

Buscopan (Hyoscine Butylbromide): Wrong Mechanism

• Buscopan is an anticholinergic antispasmodic that relaxes smooth muscle and is indicated for abdominal cramping and pain associated with gastrointestinal spasms. 3
• While it may reduce cramping sensations, it does not address the underlying pathophysiology of gastroenteritis (fluid and electrolyte losses, inflammation). 3
• Reliance on antispasmodic agents shifts the therapeutic focus away from appropriate fluid, electrolyte, and nutritional therapy in patients with acute gastroenteritis. 1

Correct Management of Acute Gastritis/Gastroenteritis

First-Line Treatment: Rehydration

• Oral rehydration solution (ORS) is the first-line therapy for mild to moderate dehydration in both children and adults. 4, 5
• For severe dehydration (≥10% fluid deficit), shock, altered mental status, or failure of ORS therapy, isotonic intravenous fluids such as lactated Ringer's or normal saline should be administered. 4, 5

Appropriate Adjunctive Medications (Once Adequately Hydrated)

• Ondansetron may be given to children >4 years and adolescents to facilitate oral rehydration when vomiting is significant. 4, 5
• Loperamide may be given to immunocompetent adults with acute watery diarrhea once adequately hydrated, but should never be given to children <18 years. 4, 1
• Probiotics may reduce symptom severity and duration in immunocompetent adults and children. 4, 5

---

D5LR versus Plain NSS: Fluid Selection Algorithm

For acute gastroenteritis, isotonic fluids (lactated Ringer's or normal saline) should be used for intravenous rehydration; D5LR is not recommended as it is hypotonic and inappropriate for volume resuscitation. 4, 5

When to Use Each Fluid Type

Lactated Ringer's (LR) or Normal Saline (NSS): First-Line for Severe Dehydration

• Both lactated Ringer's and normal saline are isotonic fluids recommended for severe dehydration, shock, or altered mental status in gastroenteritis. 4, 5
• Administer 20 mL/kg over 30 minutes for severe dehydration, continuing until pulse, perfusion, and mental status normalize. 5
• Lactated Ringer's is slightly preferred as it contains potassium and buffers (lactate) that help correct metabolic acidosis, which is common in severe dehydration. 4
• Normal saline is equally acceptable and may be preferred if there is concern about hyperkalemia (though rare in gastroenteritis). 4, 5

D5LR (5% Dextrose in Lactated Ringer's): Limited Role

• D5LR is a hypotonic solution (approximately 252 mOsm/L) that is inappropriate for initial volume resuscitation in severe dehydration. 4
• The dextrose component may be beneficial in specific circumstances:
  • Diabetic patients with hypoglycemia or those at risk of hypoglycemia during acute illness. (General medical knowledge)
  • Patients with ketonemia, where an initial course of intravenous hydration with dextrose may be needed to enable tolerance of oral rehydration. 4
  • Pediatric patients who have been fasting and are at risk of hypoglycemia. (General medical knowledge)

Plain NSS: When to Prefer Over Lactated Ringer's

• Normal saline should be used preferentially in patients with:
  • Impaired renal function with hyperkalemia risk (lactated Ringer's contains 4 mEq/L potassium). (General medical knowledge)
  • Severe metabolic alkalosis (lactated Ringer's is converted to bicarbonate). (General medical knowledge)
  • Traumatic brain injury or increased intracranial pressure (normal saline is slightly hypertonic at 308 mOsm/L). (General medical knowledge)

Clinical Decision Algorithm for Fluid Selection

Step 1: Assess Dehydration Severity

• Mild to moderate dehydration (3-9% fluid deficit): Use ORS, not IV fluids. 4, 5
• Severe dehydration (≥10% fluid deficit), shock, altered mental status: Proceed to IV fluids. 4, 5

Step 2: Select Initial IV Fluid

• Default choice: Lactated Ringer's (provides balanced electrolytes and buffers acidosis). 4, 5
• Alternative: Normal saline (if hyperkalemia, severe alkalosis, or head injury concerns). 4, 5
• Avoid D5LR for initial resuscitation (hypotonic and inadequate for volume expansion). 4

Step 3: Consider Dextrose Addition

• Add dextrose (switch to D5LR or D5NS) only if:
  • Patient is diabetic with documented hypoglycemia. (General medical knowledge)
  • Patient has ketonemia preventing oral intake. 4
  • Pediatric patient with prolonged fasting and risk of hypoglycemia. (General medical knowledge)

Step 4: Monitor and Adjust

• Continue IV rehydration until pulse, perfusion, and mental status normalize (typically 2-4 hours). 5
• Transition to ORS to replace remaining deficit once patient improves. 4, 5
• Replace ongoing losses with ORS until diarrhea and vomiting resolve. 4, 5

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not use D5LR as the initial resuscitation fluid in severe dehydration—it is hypotonic and will not adequately expand intravascular volume. 4
• Do not delay rehydration therapy while awaiting diagnostic testing—rehydration should be initiated promptly based on clinical assessment. 1
• Do not use sports drinks, apple juice, or soft drinks as rehydration solutions—they have inappropriate osmolarity and electrolyte composition. 1, 5
• Do not continue IV fluids longer than necessary—transition to ORS once the patient can tolerate oral intake to complete rehydration. 4, 5