Treatment of Black Tarry Stools (Melena)
Black tarry stools indicate upper gastrointestinal bleeding requiring immediate hemodynamic assessment, aggressive resuscitation, and urgent upper endoscopy as the primary diagnostic and therapeutic intervention. 1, 2
Immediate Initial Management
Hemodynamic Assessment and Resuscitation
- Establish two large-bore IV lines immediately in the anticubital fossae and begin aggressive fluid resuscitation with normal saline while assessing hemodynamic stability. 1
- Calculate the shock index (heart rate divided by systolic blood pressure)—a value >1 indicates active bleeding and predicts need for hospital-based intervention. 1, 2
- Infuse 1-2 liters of normal saline initially in hemodynamically compromised patients; add plasma expanders if shock persists after 2 liters. 1
- Check orthostatic vital signs in stable patients, as orthostatic hypotension indicates significant blood loss requiring ICU admission. 1
Blood Product Management
- Use restrictive transfusion thresholds: maintain hemoglobin at 70 g/L with target of 70-90 g/L for clinically stable patients without cardiovascular disease. 1
- For patients with cardiovascular disease or massive bleeding, use a hemoglobin trigger of 80 g/L with target of 100 g/L. 1
- Perform blood typing and cross-matching immediately for severe bleeding. 2
- Measure hemoglobin/hematocrit and coagulation parameters to evaluate bleeding severity. 2
Diagnostic Approach
Upper GI Source Confirmation
- Perform upper endoscopy (esophagogastroduodenoscopy) immediately after adequate resuscitation if the patient has stabilized, as melena indicates digested blood from upper GI sources. 3, 4
- If the patient remains hemodynamically unstable despite resuscitation, perform CT angiography first before endoscopy. 3, 1, 2
- Do not place a nasogastric tube routinely—it does not reliably aid diagnosis, does not affect outcomes, and causes complications in up to one-third of patients. 3
Risk Factors for Upper GI Bleeding
- Look for history of peptic ulcer disease, portal hypertension, elevated blood urea/creatinine ratio, and use of antiplatelet drugs or anticoagulants. 3
- In older adults, consider peptic ulcer disease (50% of cases in Western populations) and esophageal varices (particularly in patients with cirrhosis). 5
Therapeutic Interventions
Endoscopic Management
- Upper endoscopy provides both diagnosis (97.5% diagnostic yield) and therapeutic capability through injection therapy, thermocoagulation, and mechanical devices. 5, 6
- For variceal bleeding, endoscopic band ligation should be performed with regular follow-up until eradication. 5
- For peptic ulcer bleeding, endoscopic hemostasis techniques include adrenaline injection, thermal coagulation, and mechanical clips. 7
Medical Management
- Interrupt warfarin immediately at presentation and reverse with prothrombin complex concentrate and vitamin K for unstable hemorrhage. 1
- For direct oral anticoagulants, interrupt immediately and administer specific reversal agents for life-threatening hemorrhage. 1
- Restart anticoagulation at 7 days after hemorrhage for patients with low thrombotic risk. 1
Advanced Interventions for Refractory Bleeding
- If endoscopy fails to control bleeding or cannot be performed, proceed to catheter angiography with embolization within 60 minutes in centers with 24/7 interventional radiology. 1
- Surgery is indicated only when hemodynamic instability persists despite aggressive resuscitation, blood transfusion requirement exceeds 6 units, or patient fails angiographic intervention. 1
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
- Do not assume lower GI source based solely on bright red blood—massive upper GI bleeding can present with bright red blood per rectum due to rapid transit. 3, 4
- Do not delay CT angiography in unstable patients—perform before endoscopy if patient cannot be stabilized. 2
- Do not delay intervention in patients requiring ≥4 units transfusion, as this population has 20% mortality risk. 2
Mortality Context
- Overall in-hospital mortality for upper GI bleeding is approximately 2-14%, with higher rates in elderly patients and those with significant comorbidities. 1, 8
- Mortality rises to 18% for inpatient-onset bleeding and 20% for patients requiring ≥4 units of red cells. 1
- Operative mortality for emergency surgery is 10%, emphasizing the importance of successful endoscopic or angiographic management. 1