What is the next step in managing a 22-year-old female with polyuria, polydipsia, low osmolality, and normal electrolytes, urea, and vital signs, with a history of depression and anxiety?

Water Deprivation Test is the Correct Next Step

The correct answer is C: Water deprivation test. This patient presents with classic polyuria-polydipsia syndrome with low plasma and urine osmolality, requiring formal diagnostic testing to differentiate between primary polydipsia, central diabetes insipidus, and nephrogenic diabetes insipidus 1, 2.

Clinical Presentation Analysis

This 22-year-old woman demonstrates:

• Severe polydipsia (12 liters/day) with polyuria
• Low urine AND plasma osmolality - a critical finding that indicates she is overhydrated at baseline 2
• Normal electrolytes, calcium, and glucose - ruling out diabetes mellitus, hypercalcemia, and renal dysfunction 3
• Normal vital signs - indicating she is maintaining adequate hydration through excessive water intake 4

The combination of low plasma osmolality with low urine osmolality is pathognomonic for either primary polydipsia or partial forms of diabetes insipidus where the patient compensates by drinking excessively 2, 5.

Why Water Deprivation Test is Essential

A water deprivation test is the gold standard diagnostic procedure for differentiating polyuria-polydipsia syndromes when initial osmolality measurements are equivocal 1, 5. The test works by:

• Removing the confounding variable of excessive water intake that dilutes both plasma and urine 5
• Allowing assessment of the kidney's concentrating ability under physiologic stress 1, 6
• Measuring plasma and urine osmolality serially during supervised dehydration 1, 5
• Following with desmopressin administration to differentiate central from nephrogenic diabetes insipidus 1, 6

The test is safe when performed at experienced centers with proper monitoring, even with overnight unsupervised periods, with over 90% of patients showing expected osmolality changes 1.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect

Option A: Referral for Cognitive Therapy

While her psychiatric history (depression/anxiety) might suggest psychogenic polydipsia, you cannot make this diagnosis without first excluding organic causes of diabetes insipidus 4. Primary polydipsia is a diagnosis of exclusion that requires water deprivation testing to confirm 1, 5.

Option B: Trial of Desmopressin

Desmopressin is contraindicated in patients with polydipsia and low plasma osmolality 7. The FDA label explicitly warns that desmopressin can cause life-threatening hyponatremia in patients with excessive fluid intake 7. You must first establish the diagnosis through water deprivation testing before considering treatment 4.

Option D: Normal Saline Infusion Test

This patient does not need saline infusion - she is already adequately hydrated (normal BP, normal electrolytes) 4. Normal saline would be dangerous in diabetes insipidus as it delivers a high sodium load to kidneys that cannot concentrate urine, potentially causing severe hypernatremia 8. Hypertonic saline testing is occasionally used as an alternative to water deprivation but is not the standard first-line approach 5.

Option E: Pituitary MRI

While pituitary imaging is important if central diabetes insipidus is confirmed (approximately 50% have identifiable structural causes), you must first establish the diagnosis biochemically 4. Ordering an MRI before confirming diabetes insipidus would be premature and potentially wasteful 4.

Diagnostic Algorithm

Step 1: Confirm 24-hour urine volume >3 liters with simultaneous measurement of serum and urine osmolality 2, 6

Step 2: If urine osmolality <150 mOsm/kg (water diuresis), proceed to water deprivation test 2, 6

Step 3: During water deprivation test:

• Monitor serum osmolality, urine osmolality, and weight hourly 1, 5
• Stop when serum osmolality >295-300 mOsm/kg or patient loses >3-5% body weight 1
• Measure plasma vasopressin (copeptin) if available 4, 5

Step 4: Administer desmopressin and measure urine osmolality response 1, 6:

• >50% increase = central diabetes insipidus 4
• <50% increase = nephrogenic diabetes insipidus 4
• Appropriate concentration achieved = primary polydipsia 1

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Never restrict water access without proper monitoring - this can cause life-threatening hypernatremic dehydration in true diabetes insipidus 4, 8
• Never start desmopressin empirically in patients with polydipsia and low osmolality - risk of severe hyponatremia 7
• Do not assume psychiatric cause without excluding organic disease - diabetes insipidus can develop even in patients with psychiatric history 4, 3
• Ensure serum glucose is checked to definitively rule out diabetes mellitus, though her normal fasting glucose already excludes this 4, 3