What is the recommended management for a patient with generalized joint hypermobility who has a hip labral tear?

Management of Hip Labral Tear in Patients with Joint Hypermobility

Begin with conservative management including physical therapy focused on neuromuscular retraining and joint stabilization, as hypermobile patients require specific attention to muscular imbalance correction before considering surgical intervention. 1, 2

Understanding the Relationship Between Hypermobility and Labral Tears

Generalized joint hypermobility significantly increases the risk of hip labral pathology through several mechanisms:

• Capsular laxity from hypermobility predisposes to labral tears by allowing supraphysiologic hip motion that damages the capsuloligamentous structures and creates propensity for femoroacetabular impingement syndrome (FAIS). 3
• Hypermobile patients have altered joint biomechanics that can lead to repetitive microtrauma even when initially asymptomatic, eventually manifesting as labral injury. 1
• The Beighton score quantifies hypermobility severity and predicts complications—each 1-point increase correlates with 1.69 times increased odds of postoperative iliopsoas tendinitis after hip arthroscopy. 4

Initial Conservative Management (First-Line Approach)

Start all hypermobile patients with hip labral tears on conservative therapy for at least 6-8 weeks:

• NSAIDs for pain and inflammation control as recommended for labral pathology management. 5
• Neuromuscular retraining is the cornerstone for hypermobile patients, addressing muscular imbalance and soft-tissue compensation patterns. 1
• Physical therapy must emphasize joint stabilization rather than stretching, as hypermobile patients already have excessive range of motion. 1
• Diagnostic and therapeutic intra-articular corticosteroid injections can confirm the hip as pain source and provide temporary relief. 5

Critical Pitfall to Avoid

Do not focus therapy on increasing flexibility or range of motion in hypermobile patients—this worsens instability. Instead, prioritize strengthening and proprioceptive training. 1

Diagnostic Evaluation

MR arthrography is the gold standard for confirming labral tears and characterizing associated cartilage damage in hypermobile patients. 5, 6

• Direct MR arthrography with intra-articular gadolinium provides the most reliable visualization of acetabular labral tears and any concurrent chondral lesions. 5
• Plain radiographs assess joint space (>2 mm predicts better surgical outcomes) and rule out advanced osteoarthritis. 2
• Document Beighton score preoperatively as scores ≥4 indicate significantly increased risk of postoperative complications including iliopsoas tendinitis. 4

Surgical Decision-Making

Consider surgery only after failed conservative management, but recognize that hypermobile patients require modified surgical approach and have specific risk factors:

Indications for Surgery

• Persistent pain and functional limitation despite 6-8 weeks of appropriate conservative therapy. 5
• Joint space >2 mm on radiographs is an independent predictor of improved surgical outcomes. 2
• Adequate labral tissue (>7 mm) present for repair rather than debridement. 2

Surgical Technique Considerations for Hypermobile Patients

• Labral repair is superior to debridement in all patients, but especially critical in hypermobile individuals who need maximal preservation of stabilizing structures. 2
• Arthroscopic labral refixation restores the labral seal with the femoral head, which is essential for reducing acetabular cartilage compression and contact stress. 2
• Address concurrent chondral lesions appropriately: For delaminated cartilage <3 cm², perform debridement followed by microfracture; for lesions >3 cm², more complex management is required with limited evidence. 7, 5
• Capsular plication may be necessary in hypermobile patients to address underlying instability, though this must be balanced against creating excessive stiffness. 3

Negative Prognostic Factors

• Smoking and secondary gain issues are significant negative predictors of good outcomes. 8
• Symptoms >18 months duration paradoxically predict better outcomes, possibly reflecting patient selection. 8
• Beighton score ≥4 increases postoperative complication risk nearly 10-fold. 4

Expected Outcomes

Hypermobile patients can achieve good outcomes with appropriate management, but require realistic expectations:

• Overall 56-66% achieve good or excellent outcomes after hip arthroscopy for labral tears, with 84% returning to preoperative activity levels. 8
• Modified Harris Hip Score improves approximately 40% from baseline (56.8 to 80.4) at mean 4.8-year follow-up. 8
• Neither preoperative osteoarthritis nor intraoperative chondromalacia grade significantly predicts negative outcomes, suggesting surgery can help even with concurrent cartilage damage. 8
• Labral repair shows superior outcomes compared to debridement as an independent predictor of improvement. 2

Postoperative Management

Structured rehabilitation is mandatory and differs from standard protocols:

• Emphasize gradual strengthening and proprioceptive training rather than aggressive range of motion exercises. 5
• Monitor closely for iliopsoas tendinitis development, which occurs more frequently in hypermobile patients postoperatively. 4
• Regular follow-up to detect symptom recurrence or progression to osteoarthritis, as untreated labral pathology accelerates cartilage degeneration. 5, 2

When Conservative and Surgical Options Fail

Total hip arthroplasty becomes necessary in approximately 5.8% of patients after failed hip arthroscopy, typically in those with advanced cartilage damage or progressive osteoarthritis. 8