RTOG 79-20 Protocol for Locally Advanced Cervical Cancer
The RTOG 79-20 protocol delivered pelvic plus para-aortic extended-field irradiation at 44-45 Gy in 4.5-6.5 weeks using daily fractions of 1.6-1.8 Gy for 5 days per week, followed by intracavitary brachytherapy delivering 4000-5000 mg/h radium equivalent (or 30-40 Gy) to point A. 1
External Beam Radiotherapy Specifications
Dose and Fractionation
- The extended-field arm delivered 44-45 Gy to both the pelvis and para-aortic region over 4.5-6.5 weeks 1
- Daily fraction size was 1.6-1.8 Gy, administered 5 days per week 1
- The standard pelvic-only arm (control) delivered 40-50 Gy midplane pelvic dose using the same fractionation schedule 1
Treatment Fields
- Pelvic plus para-aortic irradiation extended the superior border to include para-aortic lymph nodes up to the renal vessels 1
- The upper limit of standard pelvic fields is at the L4-L5 junction, which can be lowered to L5-S1 for low-volume stage IB-IIA disease without nodal involvement 2
- Four-field technique is recommended over two-field arrangements 2
- Lateral field borders must always cover the nodal zones 2
- The inferior margin requires a minimum 4 cm safety margin below the lowest tumor level 2
Brachytherapy Component
Dose Prescription
- Total dose of 4000-5000 mg/h radium equivalent or 30-40 Gy to point A was delivered via intracavitary brachytherapy 1
- This brachytherapy dose was combined with external beam to achieve adequate central tumor control 1
- Low-dose-rate (LDR) brachytherapy was the standard technique during this era 2
Timing and Integration
- Brachytherapy was administered after completion of external beam radiotherapy 1
- The sequencing of external radiotherapy before brachytherapy does not affect results compared to alternating approaches 2
- Initial external radiotherapy at minimum 40 Gy allows tumor shrinkage for optimal intracavitary placement 2
Clinical Outcomes and Implications
Survival Benefits
- 10-year overall survival was 55% for pelvic plus para-aortic irradiation versus 44% for pelvic-only radiation (P=0.02) 1
- Disease-free survival was similar between arms (42% vs 40%), but the extended-field arm showed lower distant failure rates in complete responders (P=0.053) 1
- Better salvage rates for local failures occurred in the extended-field arm (25% vs 8%) 1
Toxicity Profile
- Cumulative incidence of grade 4-5 toxicities at 10 years was 8% in the extended-field arm versus 4% in pelvic-only arm (P=0.06) 1
- Death rate from radiotherapy complications was 2% (4/170 patients) in the extended-field arm versus 1% (1/167) in pelvic-only arm 1
- Prior abdominal surgery significantly increased complications: 11% grade 4-5 toxicity with para-aortic irradiation after surgery versus 2% in pelvic-only arm 1
- The risk of bowel complications is markedly elevated with para-aortic fields 2
Important Caveats
Patient Selection
- RTOG 79-20 enrolled patients with FIGO stage IIB, bulky IB (≥4 cm), or bulky IIA (≥4 cm) cervical carcinomas 1
- This protocol predates the concurrent chemoradiotherapy era, which is now standard of care 2
- Modern treatment for these stages uses concurrent cisplatin-based chemotherapy with radiotherapy, which has demonstrated superior outcomes 2
Contemporary Context
- Prophylactic para-aortic irradiation remains controversial, with benefit not clearly established and significantly increased bowel toxicity 2
- When para-aortic irradiation is used prophylactically, 45 Gy is the standard dose 2
- For proven para-aortic metastases (without distant disease), para-aortic radiotherapy is standard, though optimal dose remains undetermined 2