Expected pCO2 Calculation in Metabolic Acidosis
The expected pCO2 for this patient is approximately 26 mmHg, calculated using the simple formula: pCO2 = HCO3 + 15 (11 + 15 = 26 mmHg).
Clinical Context
This patient presents with:
- High anion gap metabolic acidosis (Anion gap = 144 - (113 + 11) = 20 mEq/L) 1
- Appropriate respiratory compensation (pH 7.38 with HCO3 11 mEq/L indicates chronic adaptation) 2
- Diabetic ketoacidosis (glucose 400 mg/dL with metabolic acidosis) 3
Calculation Methods for Expected pCO2
Primary Formula (Simplest and Most Accurate)
Use: pCO2 = HCO3 + 15
- This formula has been validated in hemodialysis patients with metabolic acidosis and shows the lowest prediction error (1.7 mmHg RMSE) 1
- For this patient: 11 + 15 = 26 mmHg expected pCO2 1
- This formula is interchangeable with the common practical rule but requires no calculations or assumptions 1
Alternative Validated Formulas
Winter's Formula: pCO2 = (1.5 × HCO3) + 8
- For this patient: (1.5 × 11) + 8 = 24.5 mmHg 1, 3
- This formula approximates the relationship between pCO2 and bicarbonate in metabolic acidosis 3
- However, it shows larger prediction errors compared to the simpler formula 1
Common Practical Rule: ΔpCO2 = 1.2 × ΔHCO3
- Reduction in pCO2 equals 1.2 times the reduction in bicarbonate from normal (24 mEq/L) 1, 4
- For this patient: 1.2 × (24 - 11) = 15.6 mmHg reduction from baseline 40 mmHg = 24.4 mmHg 1
- Shows same low error as the simple formula (1.7 mmHg) but requires more computation 1
Fulop's Rule: pCO2 = two digits after pH decimal point
- For pH 7.38, expected pCO2 would be 38 mmHg 3
- This rule works best for pH 7.10-7.37 in diabetic ketoacidosis 3
- This formula is associated with large prediction errors and should be avoided 1
Determining Appropriate Compensation
Expected pCO2 reference range = calculated value ± 3.4 mmHg (2 × RMSE)
- For this patient: 26 ± 3.4 = 22.6 to 29.4 mmHg 1
- If measured pCO2 falls outside this range, suspect a superimposed respiratory acid-base disorder 1
- pCO2 higher than expected suggests concurrent respiratory acidosis 1
- pCO2 lower than expected suggests concurrent respiratory alkalosis 1
Critical Clinical Pitfalls
Do not confuse this with chronic respiratory acidosis:
- A pH >7.35 with elevated pCO2 and HCO3 indicates chronic respiratory compensation, not metabolic acidosis 2
- This patient's pH 7.38 with LOW HCO3 (11 mEq/L) confirms metabolic acidosis, not respiratory pathology 2
Avoid using Fulop's rule in this pH range:
- Fulop's rule becomes unreliable above pH 7.10-7.15 and would significantly overestimate expected pCO2 in this case 1, 3
Remember this is diabetic ketoacidosis: