What is the differential diagnosis and management for low free thyroxine (free T4) and low free triiodothyronine (free T3) with a normal thyroid‑stimulating hormone (TSH)?

Low Free T4 and T3 with Normal TSH: Differential Diagnosis and Management

Primary Diagnostic Consideration

The combination of low free T4 and low free T3 with normal TSH most commonly indicates either nonthyroidal illness syndrome (euthyroid sick syndrome) or central hypothyroidism, and distinguishing between these two conditions is critical for appropriate management. 1, 2

---

Differential Diagnosis

1. Nonthyroidal Illness Syndrome (NTIS)

• Most common cause of this pattern in hospitalized or acutely ill patients 1, 3
• Results from altered peripheral thyroid hormone metabolism, decreased hepatic T3 production through type 1 5'-deiodinase inhibition, and altered serum protein binding 4
• TSH remains normal or low-normal despite low thyroid hormone levels 1, 5
• Severity correlates with illness severity—mortality inversely correlates with serum T4 concentration 4
• Key distinguishing feature: Elevated or normal reverse T3 (rT3) argues strongly against hypothyroidism 1

2. Central (Secondary/Tertiary) Hypothyroidism

• Caused by insufficient TSH stimulation from pituitary (secondary) or hypothalamic (tertiary) dysfunction 2
• Prevalence approximately 1 in 80,000 to 1 in 120,000 2
• Common etiologies in adults: Pituitary macroadenomas, pituitary surgery, cranial irradiation, or hypophysitis 2
• Most specific clinical features: Fatigue and peripheral edema 2
• TSH is normal to low-normal (inappropriately normal given low thyroid hormones) 2
• Critical distinction from NTIS: rT3 is typically low in central hypothyroidism but elevated in NTIS 1

3. Medication Effects

• Drugs affecting thyroid hormone metabolism (e.g., amiodarone, glucocorticoids, dopamine) can produce this pattern 6, 3
• Dopamine and high-dose glucocorticoids suppress TSH while lowering thyroid hormones 6

4. Recovery Phase from Thyroid Illness

• Delayed pituitary TSH recovery during or after treatment for hyperthyroidism 6
• Recovery phase from destructive thyroiditis 6

---

Diagnostic Algorithm

Step 1: Assess Clinical Context

• If acutely ill, hospitalized, or severely medically compromised: NTIS is most likely 1, 4
• If chronic symptoms (fatigue, peripheral edema) with history of pituitary disease, brain tumor, cranial irradiation, or pituitary surgery: Central hypothyroidism is most likely 2

Step 2: Measure Reverse T3 (rT3)

• Elevated or normal rT3: Strongly supports NTIS and argues against hypothyroidism 1
• Low rT3: Suggests central hypothyroidism 1

Step 3: Evaluate for Pituitary/Hypothalamic Disease

• If central hypothyroidism suspected, assess other pituitary hormones (cortisol, prolactin, gonadotropins) to identify panhypopituitarism 2
• Critical safety step: Rule out adrenal insufficiency before initiating thyroid hormone replacement, as starting levothyroxine before corticosteroids can precipitate life-threatening adrenal crisis 7

Step 4: Confirm with Advanced Testing

• TRH stimulation test: Confirms central hypothyroidism if TSH response is blunted or absent 2
• Free T4 by equilibrium dialysis: Most accurate method in setting of nonthyroidal illness 1, 5

---

Management

For Nonthyroidal Illness Syndrome (NTIS)

• No thyroid-specific treatment is indicated 8, 1
• Focus on treating the underlying systemic illness 8
• Studies demonstrate no discernible benefit of T4 treatment in NTIS patients 1
• Some studies show potential benefits of T3 in selected cases, but evidence is insufficient for routine use 1
• Repeat thyroid function tests (TSH and free T4) in 3-6 months after recovery to confirm normalization 8

For Central Hypothyroidism

• Initiate levothyroxine therapy titrated to improvement in symptoms and keeping free T4 in the upper limit of normal reference range 2
• Do NOT use TSH for monitoring—TSH is unreliable in central hypothyroidism 2
• Before starting levothyroxine: Rule out concurrent adrenal insufficiency by checking morning cortisol and ACTH 7
  • If adrenal insufficiency is present or suspected, start hydrocortisone at least 1 week before initiating levothyroxine 7
• Target free T4 in the upper half of the normal reference range 2
• Monitor free T4 (not TSH) every 6-8 weeks during dose titration 7

---

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Never start levothyroxine in suspected central hypothyroidism without first ruling out adrenal insufficiency—this can precipitate adrenal crisis 7
• Do not treat NTIS with thyroid hormone—it provides no benefit and may cause harm 1
• Do not rely on TSH alone to distinguish between NTIS and central hypothyroidism—both can have normal or low-normal TSH 1, 2, 5
• Do not use TSH to monitor treatment in central hypothyroidism—free T4 is the appropriate monitoring parameter 2
• Measure rT3 when the diagnosis is unclear—it is the single most useful test to differentiate NTIS (elevated rT3) from central hypothyroidism (low rT3) 1
• Avoid diagnosing hypothyroidism in acutely ill patients based solely on low thyroid hormones with normal TSH—wait until recovery and retest 1, 4