What are the indications, insertion technique, post‑placement management, adjustment criteria, and removal guidelines for a chest tube in an adult patient with normal coagulation and hemodynamic stability?

Chest Tube Insertion, Management, and Adjustment

Indications for Chest Tube Placement

Chest tube insertion is mandatory for unstable patients with pneumothorax of any size, characterized by respiratory rate ≥24 breaths/min, heart rate <60 or >120 beats/min, room air oxygen saturation ≤90%, inability to speak in full sentences, or abnormal blood pressure. 1, 2

Pneumothorax Indications

• Large pneumothorax (≥3 cm from chest wall) in clinically stable patients requires chest tube placement 1, 2
• All mechanically ventilated patients with pneumothorax require immediate drainage to prevent tension pneumothorax 1, 3
• Small pneumothorax (<3 cm) in stable patients: observation for 3-6 hours with repeat chest radiograph is appropriate; discharge if no progression 1

Pleural Effusion Indications

• Pleural fluid pH <7.20 is an absolute indication for immediate drainage in parapneumonic effusion or empyema 1
• Gross pus in pleural fluid mandates drainage regardless of pH 1
• Recurrent symptomatic malignant effusions require drainage with pleurodesis 4, 1
• Large effusions occupying >40% of hemithorax often require surgical intervention and drainage 1

Special Situations

• Systemic anthrax with pleural effusion: early aggressive drainage is recommended, as 83% of survivors received pleural drainage versus only 9% of non-survivors 1
• Hemothorax: chest tube placement is indicated for therapeutic drainage 5, 6

---

Chest Tube Size Selection

For unstable patients or those requiring mechanical ventilation with pneumothorax, use 24F-28F large-bore chest tubes to manage potentially large air leaks. 1, 2, 3

Size Algorithm by Clinical Scenario

Pneumothorax:

• Unstable or ventilated patients: 24F-28F 1, 2
• Stable patients with large pneumothorax: 16F-22F standard tubes 1, 2
• Stable patients, selected cases: small-bore catheters (≤14F) acceptable, though higher occlusion risk 1, 6
• Tubes >28F are generally unnecessary for pneumothorax 1

Pleural Effusion:

• Small-bore catheters (8-16F) achieve success rates comparable to large-bore tubes (84-97% success) 1, 6
• Malignant effusions for pleurodesis: 10-14F small-bore tubes are recommended as initial choice 4, 1

Hemothorax:

• 16-28F tubes preferred to reduce clot obstruction; pigtail catheters are not standard 1

---

Insertion Technique

Use an incisional approach with blunt dissection; never use a sharp metal trocar, as this significantly increases the risk of visceral organ injury, hemothorax, and pulmonary laceration. 1, 2, 7, 6

Step-by-Step Insertion

• Optimal insertion site: 4th or 5th intercostal space in mid- or anterior-axillary line 7
• For pleural effusion: position tube at the dependent portion (typically posterior basal area) 1
• Technique: blunt dissection for tubes >24F or Seldinger technique for smaller tubes 6
• Imaging guidance: use bedside ultrasonography or CT guidance when available 6
• Post-procedure: obtain chest radiograph to confirm tube position and lung re-expansion 1, 2

Critical Safety Points

• Full aseptic technique is mandatory to minimize empyema risk (occurs in 1-6% of cases) 1, 3
• Avoid trocar technique due to catastrophic organ injury risk 1, 2, 7

---

Drainage System Setup and Management

Connect all chest tubes to a water-seal drainage system positioned below the patient's chest level; add suction (-20 cm H₂O) when lung re-expansion is incomplete. 1

Drainage System Configuration

• Water-seal device (with or without suction) is the standard 1
• Suction pressure: -10 to -20 cm H₂O when needed 1, 3
• Heimlich valve may be used in selected cases 1
• Digital drainage systems provide automated quantitative monitoring and reduce need for follow-up chest radiographs (8.6% vs 20.2%, p<0.01) 1

When to Apply Suction

• Apply suction if lung fails to re-expand on water seal alone 1
• Continue suction until 24-hour output falls below 150 mL 1
• For persistent air leaks: consider alternating suction at night with water seal during day 8

---

Maintenance of Tube Patency

Maintain chest tube patency without breaking the sterile field; do not manually "milk" or "strip" the tube, as this creates excessive negative pressure and risks complications. 4, 1

Evidence-Based Patency Management

• Class I recommendation (Level B): maintain patency without breaking sterile field 4, 1
• Class IIIA recommendation (Level B): do not "milk," manually squeeze, or breach sterility to aspirate clots 4, 1
• Active-cleaning systems with internal guidewire loops can dissolve clots while preserving sterility 4, 1

Benefits of Active Clearance Technology

• Reduced re-exploration for bleeding by 72% (5.7% vs 1.6%, p=0.01) 1
• Reduced complete tube occlusion by 89% (2% vs 19%, p=0.01) 1
• Decreased drainage procedures for pleural effusions (8.1% vs 22%, p<0.001) 1
• Reduced postoperative atrial fibrillation (25% vs 37%, p=0.011) 1

---

Criteria for Chest Tube Removal

Remove the chest tube when 24-hour drainage is <150 mL, there is no air leak, and chest radiograph confirms complete lung re-expansion. 1

Removal Algorithm

1. Confirm cessation of air leak (tube stops bubbling) 1
2. Verify 24-hour output <150 mL 1
3. Clamp tube for approximately 4 hours after last documented air leak 1
4. Obtain repeat chest radiograph to confirm lung remains fully expanded 1
5. Remove tube if all criteria met 1

Common Pitfall to Avoid

• Do not clamp a bubbling chest tube, as this can convert simple pneumothorax into tension pneumothorax 1, 3
• Drain-clamping test before removal is generally not advocated in most current practice 6

---

Management of Persistent Air Leak

Observe for up to 4 days to allow spontaneous closure of bronchopleural fistula; if leak persists beyond 4 days, refer for thoracoscopic surgery. 1, 3

Stepwise Management

• Days 1-2: Continue water seal or low suction; monitor with serial chest radiographs 3
• Beyond 48 hours: Refer to respiratory physician for drain repositioning or suction adjustment 2, 3
• Days 4-7: Consider chemical pleurodesis if surgery contraindicated 1, 3
• Beyond 5-7 days: Surgical intervention (thoracoscopy or limited thoracotomy) is necessary 1, 2

Interventions NOT Recommended

• Do not place additional chest tube for persistent air leak 1
• Do not perform bronchoscopy solely to seal endobronchial leaks 1
• Chemical pleurodesis via chest tube is generally not recommended unless surgery contraindicated 1

---

Pleurodesis for Malignant Effusions

Talc is the most effective sclerosant for malignant pleural effusion pleurodesis, achieving 93% success rate (153/165 patients). 1

Pleurodesis Technique (Box 1 Protocol)

1. Insert small-bore tube (10-14F) 4, 1
2. Controlled evacuation of pleural fluid 4
3. Confirm full lung re-expansion with chest radiograph 4, 1
4. Administer premedication (narcotic analgesia) prior to pleurodesis 4, 1
5. Instill lidocaine solution (3 mg/kg; maximum 250 mg) followed by sclerosant in 50-100 mL sterile saline 4, 1
6. Clamp tube for 1 hour; consider patient rotation for talc slurry 4, 1
7. Reconnect to suction (-20 cm H₂O) 1
8. Remove tube within 12-72 hours if lung remains fully re-expanded and 24-hour output <150 mL 4, 1

Sclerosant Success Rates

Agent	Success Rate
Talc	93% [1]
Corynebacterium parvum	76% [1]
Doxycycline	72% [1]
Tetracycline	67% [1]
Bleomycin	54% [1]

Important Considerations

• Reduce or discontinue systemic corticosteroids when possible to improve sclerosant efficacy 1
• Pain is the most common adverse effect, especially with doxycycline; fever is also frequent 1
• Small-bore catheters (8-16F) achieve outcomes comparable to large tubes for pleurodesis 1

---

Hospitalization and Monitoring Requirements

All patients with chest tubes for pneumothorax or significant pleural effusion must be hospitalized on specialized respiratory or surgical units with experienced staff. 2, 3

Monitoring Parameters

• Respiratory rate, heart rate, blood pressure, oxygen saturation 3
• Serial chest radiographs to assess pneumothorax resolution and lung re-expansion 3
• 24-hour drainage output to guide removal timing 1
• Air leak assessment (bubbling in water seal chamber) 1

---

Special Considerations for Ventilated Patients

For mechanically ventilated patients with pneumothorax, insert a large-bore chest tube (24F-28F) immediately and never clamp the tube, even when non-bubbling, to prevent tension pneumothorax. 1, 3

Critical Safety Rules

• Never clamp a bubbling chest tube in ventilated patients 1, 3
• Even non-bubbling tubes should not routinely be clamped in ventilated patients 3
• Use high-volume, low-pressure suction systems (-10 to -20 cm H₂O) 3
• Management requires specialized lung units with experienced medical and nursing staff 3

---

Complications and Prevention

Common Complications

• Pain: more common with larger tubes 1
• Tube blockage: more common with small-bore tubes 1
• Empyema: occurs in 1-6% of cases; prevented by strict aseptic technique 1, 3

Serious Complications (Trocar-Related)

• Hemothorax, pulmonary laceration, organ injury in thoracic or abdominal cavity 1, 7
• Prevention: avoid trocar technique; use blunt dissection or Seldinger method 1, 7, 6

Re-expansion Pulmonary Edema

• Risk factor: rapid drainage of large effusions 4
• Prevention: limit initial drainage to 1-1.5 liters 4