Which oxygen delivery devices are appropriate for patients with mild, moderate, and severe hypoxemia, considering required flow rates, FiO₂ levels, airway protection, and the need for humidification or ventilatory support?

Oxygen Delivery Devices for Hypoxemia

Device Selection Based on Severity of Hypoxemia

For mild to moderate hypoxemia, use nasal cannulae at 1-6 L/min as first-line therapy; for severe hypoxemia requiring high FiO₂, use reservoir masks at 15 L/min initially; and for patients requiring precise FiO₂ control (especially those at risk of hypercapnia), use Venturi masks. 1

---

Mild Hypoxemia (SpO₂ 90-94%)

Nasal Cannulae (First-Line)

• Flow rate: 1-4 L/min delivers approximately 24-40% FiO₂ 1, 2
• Target saturation: 94-98% for most patients; 88-92% for those at risk of hypercapnic respiratory failure 1
• Advantages: Superior patient comfort, can be worn during meals and speech, no CO₂ rebreathing risk, lower cost 1, 3
• Key limitation: FiO₂ varies significantly between patients (e.g., 24-35% at 2 L/min) based on breathing pattern and respiratory rate 2, 3

Clinical Pitfall

Never assume a specific flow rate delivers a precise FiO₂—the same flow rate can produce widely different blood oxygen levels in different patients. 2 Always titrate based on pulse oximetry or arterial blood gas measurements. 3

---

Moderate Hypoxemia (SpO₂ 85-89%)

Nasal Cannulae at Higher Flow

• Flow rate: 4-6 L/min delivers approximately 40-50% FiO₂ 1, 2
• Adjust flow between 2-6 L/min to achieve target saturation 1
• Some patients may experience nasal discomfort above 4 L/min 2

Simple Face Mask (Alternative)

• Flow rate: 5-10 L/min delivers 40-60% FiO₂ 1, 3
• Critical safety rule: Flow rates below 5 L/min cause dangerous CO₂ rebreathing and increased inspiratory resistance 1, 3
• Less preferred than nasal cannulae due to patient discomfort and need for removal during meals 1

Venturi Masks (For Precise Control)

• Indications: Patients requiring exact FiO₂ delivery, particularly those at risk of hypercapnic respiratory failure (COPD, obesity hypoventilation) 1, 3
• Available concentrations: 24%, 28%, 31%, 35%, 40%, 60% oxygen 1
• Delivers constant FiO₂ with greater gas flow than simple face masks, reducing dilution by room air 1
• Special consideration: For patients with respiratory rate >30 breaths/min, increase flow rate above the minimum specified for the mask 1, 3
• Substitution option: For many patients, 24-28% Venturi masks can be replaced with nasal cannulae at 1-2 L/min to achieve the same target range 1

---

Severe Hypoxemia (SpO₂ <85% or Critical Illness)

High-Concentration Reservoir Mask (Initial Management)

• Flow rate: 15 L/min is the preferred means for delivering high-concentration oxygen to critically ill patients 1
• Delivers 60-90% FiO₂ 3
• Use until reliable pulse oximetry monitoring is established, then adjust downward to nasal cannulae or simple face mask to maintain target saturation 3

High-Flow Nasal Cannula (HFNC) - Preferred for Acute Hypoxemic Respiratory Failure

HFNC should be considered as a potentially superior alternative to reservoir mask treatment in patients with acute respiratory failure without hypercapnia. 1

Initial Settings

• Flow rate: Start at 40-50 L/min (range 35-60 L/min for adults), titrated to patient comfort and respiratory effort 1, 4
• Temperature: 34-37°C based on patient preference 4
• FiO₂: Titrate to achieve SpO₂ 94-98% (or 88-92% for hypercapnic risk patients) 4

Mechanisms of Benefit

• Provides airflows up to 60 L/min, matching inspiratory demands of dyspneic patients 1
• Delivers reliable FiO₂ up to 100% 1
• Generates low-level PEEP (~7 cmH₂O at 50 L/min) in upper airways, facilitating alveolar recruitment 1, 3
• Provides heated humidification, improving patient comfort and secretion clearance 1
• Reduces CO₂ washout of upper airways 1

Evidence for Clinical Outcomes

• Intubation: HFNC may reduce intubation rates (risk ratio 0.89,95% CI 0.77-1.02) 1
• Mortality: Similar short-term mortality compared to conventional oxygen therapy (risk ratio 0.99,95% CI 0.84-1.17) 1
• Patient comfort: Significantly reduces discomfort and dyspnea compared to reservoir masks 1
• Respiratory rate: Decreases by mean 2.25 breaths/min 1
• Oxygenation: Increases PaO₂ by mean 16.72 mmHg 1

Monitoring During HFNC

• Respiratory rate should decrease with effective therapy 4
• Assess work of breathing for accessory muscle use 4
• Continuous pulse oximetry monitoring 4
• Arterial blood gases when necessary to assess response 4

Flow Rate Adjustments

• Increase by 5-10 L/min for increased work of breathing 4
• Decrease by 5-10 L/min for patient discomfort 4
• Higher flows (50-60 L/min) provide greater PEEP effect and dead space washout 4

Common Pitfalls with HFNC

• Inadequate flow rate: Insufficient PEEP effect or dead space washout 4
• Excessive oxygen: Risk of oxygen toxicity 4
• Delayed escalation: Failure to intubate promptly when HFNC is insufficient leads to worse outcomes 4
• Poor interface fit: Air leaks reduce effectiveness 4

---

Special Populations and Considerations

Patients at Risk of Hypercapnic Respiratory Failure (COPD, Obesity Hypoventilation)

• Target saturation: 88-92% (not 94-98%) 1, 4
• Preferred devices: Venturi masks at 24% or 28%, or nasal cannulae at 1-2 L/min 1, 3
• Avoid: High-flow oxygen without precise control—can precipitate hypercapnia within 15 minutes at 6 L/min 2
• Maximum high-flow exposure: Limit to 6 minutes when precise FiO₂ control is unavailable 2
• HFNC consideration: May be attempted at 35-60 L/min if NIV not tolerated, but NIV should be considered first 4

Post-Extubation Support

• HFNC at 35-50 L/min is typically sufficient 4
• Conditional recommendation for HFNC following extubation (moderate certainty evidence) 5

Immunocompromised Patients

• HFNC is particularly beneficial due to lower risk of ventilator-associated complications like pneumonia 1

---

Humidification Requirements

When Humidification is NOT Required

• Low-flow oxygen (nasal cannulae or masks) 1
• Short-term use of high-flow oxygen 1
• Prehospital care 1

When Humidification IS Indicated

• High-flow oxygen systems used for >24 hours 1
• Patients reporting upper airway discomfort due to dryness 1
• Patients with tracheostomy or artificial airway (though can be managed without for short periods like ambulance journeys) 1
• Patients with viscous secretions causing difficulty with expectoration (can use nebulized normal saline) 1
• HFNC always includes heated humidification as part of the system 1

Humidification Device to Avoid

Bubble bottles (oxygen bubbling through water) should not be used—no evidence of clinical benefit but risk of infection. 1

---

Practical Algorithm for Device Selection

Step 1: Assess Hypercapnic Risk

• High risk (COPD, obesity hypoventilation, neuromuscular disease): Target SpO₂ 88-92%, use Venturi mask or low-flow nasal cannulae 1, 3
• Low risk: Target SpO₂ 94-98%, broader device options 1

Step 2: Determine Severity

• Mild (SpO₂ 90-94%): Nasal cannulae 1-4 L/min 1, 3
• Moderate (SpO₂ 85-89%): Nasal cannulae 4-6 L/min or simple face mask 5-10 L/min 1, 3
• Severe (SpO₂ <85%): Reservoir mask 15 L/min initially, then consider HFNC 1, 3

Step 3: Assess Need for Precise FiO₂

• Precise control needed: Venturi mask 1, 3
• Precise control not critical: Nasal cannulae preferred for comfort 1

Step 4: Consider HFNC for Acute Hypoxemic Respiratory Failure

• Indications: Moderate to severe hypoxemia without hypercapnia, post-extubation, immunocompromised patients 1, 5
• Start: 40-50 L/min, 37°C, titrate FiO₂ to target 4
• Monitor: Respiratory rate, work of breathing, comfort, SpO₂ 4

Step 5: Escalate if Inadequate Response

• Nasal cannulae → Simple face mask or Venturi mask → HFNC → NIV or intubation 3
• Do not delay intubation if patient deteriorates despite maximal noninvasive support 4

---

Key Safety Points

• Never use simple face masks below 5 L/min (CO₂ rebreathing risk) 1, 3
• Ensure correct wall outlet connection—oxygen tubing connected to compressed air outlets has caused adverse events 1
• HFNC is for acute care only, not home oxygen therapy 3
• Monitor for HFNC failure—prepare for intubation if respiratory distress worsens 4
• Adjust oxygen delivery during nebulizer treatments—maintain target saturation throughout 1