ECG Axis Interpretation: Right Axis Deviation with Positive QRS in Leads I-III
No, you cannot have right axis deviation when QRS complexes are positive in leads I, II, and III. The pattern you describe—positive QRS in leads I, II, III, aVL, and aVF with negative QRS in aVR—represents a normal axis (approximately +30° to +90°), not right axis deviation. 1
Understanding the QRS Axis
The QRS axis is determined by the net direction of ventricular depolarization in the frontal plane. Here's how to interpret your specific pattern:
Your Described Pattern Indicates Normal Axis
- Positive QRS in lead I means the axis is between -90° and +90° 1
- Positive QRS in lead II means the axis is between -30° and +150° 1
- Positive QRS in both leads I and II together localizes the axis to the normal range of approximately 0° to +90° 1
- Positive QRS in aVF confirms the axis is inferior (positive), typically between 0° and +180° 1
- Positive QRS in aVL with positive lead I further supports a normal leftward axis 1
Definition of Right Axis Deviation
Right axis deviation requires the QRS axis to be ≥+90°, and the American College of Cardiology states this finding is required for diagnosis of right ventricular overload in nearly all cases. 1
The key ECG features of right axis deviation include:
- Lead I must show a predominantly negative QRS complex (more S wave than R wave) 1
- Lead aVF remains positive (as the axis shifts rightward beyond +90°) 1
- Lead II typically remains positive but may become equiphasic as axis approaches +90° 1
- Lead III becomes strongly positive with tall R waves 1
Common Pitfall: Lead Misplacement
Your described pattern could theoretically result from lead misplacement, which is a critical consideration:
- Transposition of left and right arm leads produces inversion of lead I with a switch of leads II and III, and aVR and aVL switch positions while aVF remains unaltered 2
- This creates a false appearance of right axis deviation when the actual axis is normal 2
- A clue to lead misplacement is important discordance between lead I and V6—normally these leads show similar P-wave and QRS morphology 2
- The American Heart Association recommends that medical personnel receive training on lead-switch recognition, and ECG machines should incorporate lead-switch detection algorithms 2
Clinical Algorithm for Axis Determination
To accurately determine if right axis deviation is present:
- Verify lead placement first—check that lead I morphology matches V6 2
- Examine lead I: If predominantly positive (R > S), axis is between -90° and +90° 1
- Examine lead aVF: If positive, axis is between 0° and +180° 1
- If both lead I and aVF are positive, the axis is normal (0° to +90°)—right axis deviation is excluded 1
- For right axis deviation to exist, lead I must be predominantly negative (S > R) while aVF remains positive 1
Age-Specific Considerations
The definition of right axis deviation varies by age:
- Adults: Right axis deviation is ≥+90°, with moderate RAD at +90° to +120° and marked RAD at +120° to +180° 3
- Neonates: Normal axis ranges from +30° to +190°, so what appears as right axis deviation in adults may be normal 3
- Ages 1 month to 1 year: Normal axis is +10° to +120° 3
- Ages 1 to 5 years: Normal axis is +5° to +100° 3
Never apply adult criteria to pediatric patients, as this leads to false-positive diagnoses of right axis deviation. 3