24-Hour Urine Calcium in Hyperparathyroidism
Normal 24-hour urine calcium excretion in adults is <250 mg/day (6.2 mmol/day) in females and <4 mg/kg/day (0.1 mmol/kg/day) for all adults, while primary hyperparathyroidism typically shows hypercalciuria (>250-300 mg/day), and familial hypocalciuric hypercalcemia characteristically demonstrates low urinary calcium (<100 mg/24hr or <2.5 mmol/24hr). 1
Normal Reference Ranges
24-hour urinary calcium excretion in healthy adults is typically <250 mg/day (6.2 mmol/day) in females and <4 mg/kg/day (0.1 mmol/kg/day) for all adults 1
The collection must be performed on a random diet with proper acidification to prevent calcium precipitation 1
Creatinine measurement is essential to verify collection completeness 1
Primary Hyperparathyroidism (PHPT) Pattern
Most PHPT patients demonstrate hypercalciuria due to the increased filtered calcium load from hypercalcemia 2:
Typical 24-hour urine calcium: >250-300 mg/day (>6.2-7.5 mmol/day) 2
Urine calcium >400 mg/day identifies patients at increased risk for kidney stones and bone complications, and serves as a surgical indication for parathyroidectomy 2
In one surgical series, median 24-hour urine calcium in PHPT was 8.3 mmol/24hr (range 5.6-11.2), significantly higher than FHH 3
Important Caveat
Vitamin D deficiency can suppress urine calcium excretion in PHPT patients, potentially masking hypercalciuria and creating diagnostic confusion 2
Ensure 25-hydroxyvitamin D ≥50 nmol/L (≥20 ng/mL) before interpreting urinary calcium results 2, 4
Familial Hypocalciuric Hypercalcemia (FHH) Pattern
FHH characteristically shows inappropriately low urinary calcium despite hypercalcemia 2:
Typical 24-hour urine calcium: <100 mg/day (<2.5 mmol/day) 5, 3
In genetically confirmed FHH, median 24-hour urine calcium was 3.2 mmol/24hr (range 2.1-6.1), markedly lower than PHPT 3
Mean urinary calcium excretion in FHH: 6.6 ± 5.4 mEq/day versus 14.8 ± 7.5 mEq/day in typical PHPT 6
Diagnostic Algorithm: PHPT vs FHH
Step 1: Calculate Calcium-to-Creatinine Clearance Ratio (CCCR)
CCCR is the preferred initial test to distinguish PHPT from FHH 2, 5, 4:
CCCR >0.02: Strongly suggests PHPT (proceed with standard PHPT evaluation) 5, 3
CCCR 0.01-0.02: Intermediate zone—obtain 24-hour urine calcium for additional data 5, 3
Step 2: When CCCR <0.01, Use Clinical Context to Exclude FHH
A CCCR <0.01 occurred in 17% of PHPT patients, so do not reflexively order genetic testing 7. Instead, FHH can be excluded by:
24-hour urine calcium >100 mg/day (>2.5 mmol/day): Rules out FHH with 95.2% negative predictive value 5, 7
Prior documented normocalcemia: FHH presents with lifelong hypercalcemia from infancy 7
Renal insufficiency (eGFR <60): Reduces calcium excretion independent of FHH 7
Absence of family history of hypercalcemia: FHH is autosomal dominant 7
Thiazide diuretic use: Lowers urinary calcium and can mimic FHH 7
Step 3: Genetic Testing for FHH
Order genetic testing (CASR, GNA11, AP2S1 genes) only when:
CCCR <0.01 AND 24-hour urine calcium <100 mg/day (<2.5 mmol/day) 5
Family history of hypercalcemia with failed parathyroid surgery 5
Young age at presentation with mild hypercalcemia 5
In practice, only 1-4% of patients with suspected PHPT require genetic testing when this algorithm is followed 7
Test Performance Characteristics
24-Hour Urine Calcium
Sensitivity for PHPT: 96% (using cut-off ≥2.5 mmol/24hr) 3
Specificity for FHH: 29.4% (using cut-off <2.5 mmol/24hr) 3
Negative predictive value for FHH: 95.2% when <2.5 mmol/24hr 5
CCCR
Specificity for FHH: 93% (using cut-off <0.02) 3
Sensitivity for PHPT: 47% (using cut-off >0.02) 3
At CCCR cut-off ≤0.015, negative predictive value for FHH is 100% 5
At CCCR cut-off ≤0.020, negative predictive value for FHH is 100% with positive predictive value of only 2.33% 5
Clinical Pitfalls to Avoid
Do not rely solely on 24-hour urine calcium to exclude FHH—it has poor specificity (29.4%) and will prompt unnecessary genetic testing in many PHPT patients 3
Do not order genetic testing when CCCR <0.01 without first checking 24-hour urine calcium and clinical context—this avoids unnecessary testing in 99% of cases 7
Always check vitamin D status before interpreting urinary calcium—deficiency suppresses calcium excretion and can make PHPT mimic FHH 2
Interpret CCCR in context of renal function—chronic kidney disease lowers urinary calcium independent of FHH 7
Use albumin-adjusted serum calcium when calculating CCCR, as 70.3% of UK clinicians do 4
Four-gland hyperplasia is more common when CCCR <0.01 (17% vs 4% when CCCR ≥0.01), but surgical outcomes remain equivalent 7