What is the appropriate management for an elderly patient with an acute osteoporotic displaced L1‑L2 compression fracture who has no neurologic deficit and appears stable on imaging?

Management of Acute L1 Compression Fracture with Displaced L1-L2 Tap Fractures

Immediate Neurological Assessment is Critical

For an elderly patient with an acute osteoporotic displaced L1-L2 compression fracture who has no neurologic deficit and appears stable on imaging, begin with 3 months of conservative medical management including analgesics and calcitonin, then proceed to vertebral augmentation (preferably kyphoplasty) if severe pain persists, vertebral height loss exceeds 20%, or pulmonary dysfunction develops. 1, 2

---

Initial Clinical Evaluation

Perform a focused neurological examination specifically assessing:

• Motor strength in lower extremities (any weakness mandates immediate surgical referral) 1, 2
• Sensory deficits in dermatomal distribution 1, 2
• Bowel and bladder function (dysfunction requires urgent decompression) 1, 2
• Rectal tone if any suspicion of cauda equina involvement 2

Screen for red-flag symptoms that suggest pathologic fracture:

• Unexplained weight loss, nocturnal pain, constitutional symptoms 1
• History of malignancy (requires contrast-enhanced MRI and possible biopsy) 1, 2
• Age >50 with first fracture 2
• Failure to improve with initial therapy 2

---

Imaging Protocol

Obtain MRI of the lumbar spine without contrast to:

• Confirm fracture acuity by identifying bone-marrow edema (typically resolves within 1-3 months) 3, 1, 2
• Exclude pathologic fracture from malignancy or infection 1, 2
• Assess for spinal cord compression or retropulsed bone fragments (their presence mandates surgical consultation) 1
• Evaluate posterior ligamentous complex integrity (disruption indicates instability) 4

Contrast-enhanced MRI is only indicated if malignancy, infection, or inflammation is suspected based on red-flag symptoms. 2, 5

---

Conservative Medical Management (First 3 Months)

Pain Control Protocol

• Start scheduled acetaminophen every 6 hours as first-line analgesia 1, 2
• Add NSAIDs for severe pain, but use cautiously in elderly patients due to cardiovascular, renal, and gastrointestinal risks 1, 2
• Reserve short-term opioids for breakthrough pain only at the lowest effective dose to minimize sedation, fall risk, nausea, and deconditioning 1, 2

Calcitonin for Acute Pain

• Consider calcitonin 200 IU nasally or suppository for up to 4 weeks to achieve clinically important pain reduction during the acute phase (weeks 1-4) 1, 2

Activity Modification

• Prevent prolonged bed rest beyond the acute pain phase to avoid deconditioning, bone loss, and increased mortality 1
• Bracing may be considered but is not mandatory based on patient comfort and functional needs 2

Follow-Up Timeline

• Reassess at 4-6 weeks to evaluate response to conservative therapy and confirm osteoporosis treatment has been initiated 1, 2
• If pain persists at 8 weeks, obtain repeat imaging to assess for fracture progression or new fractures 2
• At 3 months, make definitive decision regarding vertebral augmentation if conservative management has failed 3, 1, 2

---

Indications for Vertebral Augmentation (Kyphoplasty Preferred)

Proceed to vertebral augmentation if any of the following develop during the 3-month conservative trial: 3, 1, 2

• Persistent severe pain despite appropriate conservative treatment for 3 weeks to 3 months 3, 1
• Vertebral body height loss greater than 20% (significant kyphotic deformity) 1
• Progressive spinal deformity or increasing kyphosis observed during treatment 1, 2
• Development of pulmonary dysfunction attributable to kyphotic deformity (restrictive lung disease) 1, 2
• Pain refractory to oral medications requiring parenteral narcotics or hospitalization 2

Evidence Supporting Vertebral Augmentation

Vertebral augmentation provides superior pain relief and functional improvement compared with prolonged conservative therapy, with benefits evident even for fractures older than 12 weeks. 3, 1 The threshold for performing vertebral augmentation has declined given evidence that it is more effective than prolonged medical treatment in achieving analgesia, improving function, and avoiding complications of narcotic use. 3

Kyphoplasty is preferred over vertebroplasty because it achieves greater restoration of vertebral body height, better correction of spinal deformity, and lower cement-leakage rates. 1 Vertebroplasty is strongly NOT recommended based on Level I evidence showing no benefit over sham procedure. 5

---

Immediate Surgical Consultation Criteria (Do Not Delay)

Transfer immediately for orthopedic surgery or neurosurgery evaluation if any of the following are present: 1, 2

• Any neurologic deficit (motor weakness, sensory loss, radicular symptoms, or bowel/bladder dysfunction) 1, 2
• Frank spinal instability (inability to bear weight or rapidly progressive deformity) 1, 2
• Imaging evidence of spinal cord compression, especially from osseous retropulsion 1, 2
• Posterior column involvement on imaging (indicates instability requiring surgical stabilization) 2, 6
• Significant vertebral body collapse >50% 2

The classic burst fracture with anterior and middle column compromise but intact posterior column is considered stable and can be managed nonoperatively in the absence of neurologic deficit. 6 However, the condition of the posterior column, not the middle column, is the better indicator of burst fracture stability. 6

---

Osteoporosis Management (Mandatory)

All patients with osteoporotic compression fractures require systematic evaluation for osteoporosis: 2

• Obtain DXA scan 2
• Assess for secondary causes of osteoporosis 2
• Initiate appropriate pharmacologic therapy immediately (approximately 20% of patients develop chronic back pain and have high risk of subsequent fractures) 1, 2
• Refer to endocrinology or rheumatology within 4-6 weeks for long-term osteoporosis management 2

---

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not postpone vertebral augmentation in patients with progressive deformity >20% height loss or pulmonary compromise; earlier intervention improves outcomes 1
• Do not miss pathologic fractures in individuals with malignancy risk factors; obtain contrast-enhanced spine MRI when red-flag symptoms are present 1, 2
• Do not delay osteoporosis treatment; this fracture is often the first presentation of severe osteoporosis requiring immediate therapy 2
• Do not miss neurological deficits on initial examination; perform thorough neurological assessment including rectal tone if indicated 2
• Do not assume all fractures are osteoporotic; approximately 40% of conservatively treated patients have no significant pain relief after 1 year despite higher-class prescription medication 3
• Do not routinely obtain MRI with contrast unless malignancy or infection is suspected, as it adds no diagnostic value for osteoporotic fractures 2, 5