What is the recommended evaluation and management for an adult inguinal hernia, including when to operate versus observe?

Adult Inguinal Hernia: Evaluation and Management

Immediate Assessment for Emergent Complications

All adult inguinal hernias require immediate assessment for signs of incarceration or strangulation, which mandate emergency surgical intervention within 24 hours to prevent mortality. 1, 2

Red Flag Signs Requiring Emergency Surgery

• Irreducibility of the hernia with resistance to gentle manual reduction 1, 3
• Tenderness, erythema, or warmth over the hernia site 1, 3
• Systemic symptoms including fever, tachycardia, or signs of SIRS 1, 3
• Abdominal wall rigidity 1
• Overlying skin changes 1

Laboratory Markers Predictive of Strangulation

When strangulation is suspected, obtain: 1

• Arterial lactate ≥2.0 mmol/L (moderate predictive value for non-viable bowel)
• Elevated white blood cell count (moderately predictive)
• Serum creatinine phosphokinase and D-dimer levels
• Fibrinogen levels (can predict morbidity)

Emergency Imaging

• CT with contrast is the preferred modality in emergency settings, with 56% sensitivity and 94% specificity for predicting bowel strangulation based on reduced wall enhancement 1, 3

---

Diagnostic Evaluation for Non-Emergent Cases

Clinical Examination

Examine both groins bilaterally in all patients, as contralateral hernias occur in 11-50% of cases and femoral hernias carry higher strangulation risk 1, 3

Key examination findings: 4

• Palpable bulge or impulse with coughing/straining
• Groin pain, burning, gurgling, or aching sensation
• Heavy or dragging sensation worsening with activity
• Bulge that disappears when prone

Imaging Indications

Imaging is not routinely required for diagnosis but is indicated in specific scenarios: 1, 4

• Ultrasonography: When diagnosis is uncertain, for recurrent hernias, suspected hydrocele, or surgical complications
• CT scanning: Preferred in obese patients or those with prior groin surgery where physical examination is unreliable
• MRI: For occult hernias when clinical suspicion is high despite negative ultrasound

---

Management Decision: Operate vs. Observe

Surgical Repair is Recommended for All Symptomatic Inguinal Hernias 1, 4

The traditional approach of universal repair has been challenged by recent evidence, but symptomatic hernias should undergo surgical correction due to unpredictable incarceration risk. 1, 3

Watchful Waiting May Be Considered in Highly Selected Cases

Based on research evidence, watchful waiting is a safe option only for patients meeting ALL of the following criteria: 5

• Age under 50 years
• ASA class 1 or 2
• Inguinal hernia (NOT femoral)
• Asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic
• Duration of signs >3 months

Critical caveat: The incarceration rate is approximately 4 per 1,000 patients per year, and physical features of the hernia (size, ease of reduction) do not predict incarceration risk. 1, 3

High-Risk Features Mandating Expedited Surgery

• Age >60 years (increased incarceration risk) 1
• Femoral hernia (highest strangulation risk) 1, 3
• Duration of signs <3 months 1
• Symptomatic periods >8 hours 1, 3
• High ASA scores or significant comorbidities 1, 3

---

Surgical Approach Selection

Prosthetic (mesh) repair is the preferred treatment for most uncomplicated inguinal hernias in adults, with both open and laparoscopic approaches considered based on patient factors and surgeon expertise. 1

Laparoscopic Techniques (TEP or TAPP)

Advantages: 1, 6, 7

• Faster return to normal activities
• Better visualization of inguinal anatomy
• Ability to identify and repair contralateral hernias (detected intraoperatively in 3.2% of cases)
• Low recurrence rates (comparable to open repair)

Disadvantages: 6

• Requires general anesthesia
• Higher cost than open procedures
• Longer-term recurrence data still emerging

Open Repair

Remains appropriate based on: 1, 6

• Patient comorbidities precluding general anesthesia
• Cost considerations
• Surgeon expertise

---

Management While Awaiting Surgery

Activity Restrictions

Avoid activities that increase intra-abdominal pressure: 3

• Restrict heavy lifting and straining
• Avoid vigorous physical activity
• Gentle manual reduction is acceptable if hernia is easily reducible and non-tender
• Never force reduction if there is resistance, pain, or signs of incarceration

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not assume safety based on hernia size or ease of reduction—incarceration risk is unpredictable 1, 3
• Do not delay evaluation if any signs of strangulation develop 3
• Do not use abdominal binders or trusses in cirrhotic patients with ascites (paradoxical incarceration risk) 3
• Do not miss femoral hernias during bilateral examination 1, 3

Timing Considerations

• Symptomatic patients: Repair within 1-2 weeks of diagnosis 3
• Delayed treatment >24 hours for complicated hernias significantly increases mortality 1, 2
• Time from symptom onset to surgery is the most important prognostic factor for morbidity 1, 3

---

Postoperative Considerations

Expected Outcomes

• Complication rates: Generally low with modern techniques 6, 4
• Recurrence rates: Approximately 1% with tension-free mesh repair 1
• Testicular complications: Potential risk in males (1% testicular atrophy rate) 1
• Infection: Potential complication requiring monitoring 1

Recurrent Hernias

Patients with recurrent hernias should be referred back to the original surgeon if possible, as they have a 23% chance of presenting with contralateral or recurrent hernias. 1, 4