Management and Prognosis of Moderately Differentiated Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Right Vocal Cord
For early-stage (T1-T2N0) moderately differentiated squamous cell carcinoma of the vocal cord, either radiotherapy or conservative surgery (transoral laser microsurgery or open partial laryngectomy) should be used as single-modality treatment, with both approaches achieving similar excellent local control rates of 96-98% and overall survival. 1
Treatment Selection Algorithm
For T1 Glottic Cancer (Tumor Limited to Vocal Cord)
Primary treatment options with equivalent oncologic outcomes: 1
Radiotherapy (RT): Standard fractionation 66-70 Gy over 6-7 weeks achieves 98% local control for T1 lesions 2
Transoral laser microsurgery (TLM): Preferred for well-defined, accessible lesions 1, 5
Open partial laryngectomy: Reserved for salvage after treatment failure 5
For T2 Glottic Cancer (Tumor Extends to Both Cords or Impaired Mobility)
Treatment selection depends on tumor characteristics: 1
Favorable T2 (Superficial, Normal Cord Mobility):
- RT alone: 66-70 Gy with standard or moderately accelerated fractionation 1
- Alternative: Open organ-preservation surgery if patient accepts permanent voice changes for potentially higher local control 1
Unfavorable T2 (Deep Invasion, Impaired Cord Mobility):
- Open organ-preservation surgery (supracricoid partial laryngectomy): Highest local control rates 1
- Alternative for node-positive disease (T2N+): Concurrent chemoradiotherapy 1
- Emerging data suggest concurrent platinum-based chemotherapy with hypofractionated RT may improve local control (88% vs 61%) for impaired cord mobility, though not yet statistically proven 6
Critical Treatment Principles
Single-modality treatment is mandatory for early-stage disease to minimize morbidity while maintaining cure rates. 1
- Avoid treatment delays: Timing significantly influences local control 1
- No role for induction chemotherapy in T1-T2N0 disease 1
- No prophylactic neck treatment needed for T1-T2N0 glottic cancer (unlike supraglottic or other head/neck sites) 1
Prognosis
Excellent prognosis with appropriate treatment: 2, 5, 3
- T1 disease: 96-98% local control, >95% 5-year survival 2, 5, 3
- T2 disease: 85-90% local control with appropriate treatment selection 6, 5
- Laryngeal preservation rate: >90% with primary treatment 1, 5
- Salvage surgery success: High salvage rates (>80%) if local recurrence occurs after RT 5
Functional Outcomes and Quality of Life
Voice quality considerations guide treatment selection: 1, 5
- RT: Preserves near-normal voice quality for most patients 5, 3
- TLM for limited lesions: Voice quality comparable to RT 5
- Open partial laryngectomy: Permanent hoarseness but maintains laryngeal function 1
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Do not overtreat T1-T2N0 glottic cancer with combined modality therapy (surgery + RT or chemoRT) as this increases morbidity without survival benefit 1
- Do not perform elective neck dissection or neck RT for T1-T2N0 glottic cancer—this is a unique feature of glottic cancer due to minimal lymphatic drainage 1
- Do not use 6-MV photons with inadequate dose/fractionation—underdosing at air-tissue interfaces can compromise local control; use appropriate total doses (66-70 Gy) and consider altered fractionation 2
- Do not delay salvage surgery if recurrence occurs after RT—prompt surgical salvage maintains high cure rates 5
Radiation Technique Considerations
For patients selecting RT: 1, 2, 4, 3
- Standard fractionation (2 Gy/fraction to 66-70 Gy) is appropriate for T1 disease 1, 2
- Moderately accelerated or hyperfractionated RT may improve outcomes for T2 disease 1
- Single vocal cord irradiation reduces toxicity while maintaining excellent control for T1a disease 4, 3
- Proton therapy shows dosimetric advantages but lacks randomized data to recommend routine use 1, 4