When is skin stapling preferred over suturing for surgical wound closure?

Skin Closure Method Selection

Primary Recommendation

Sutures should be your first-line method for most surgical wound closures, as they provide superior wound integrity and significantly lower dehiscence rates compared to both staples and tissue adhesives. 1

Evidence-Based Decision Algorithm

For Most Surgical Wounds: Use Continuous Subcuticular Sutures

• Continuous subcuticular sutures with slowly absorbable monofilament material (4-0 poliglecaprone or polyglactin) are the optimal choice, reducing superficial wound dehiscence by 92% (RR 0.08; 95% CI 0.02-0.35) compared to interrupted techniques. 1

• These sutures retain 50-75% tensile strength after 1 week and eliminate the need for painful removal at 7-9 days postoperatively. 1

• Maintain a suture-to-wound length ratio of at least 4:1 using the "small bite" technique (5mm from wound edge, 5mm between stitches) to minimize incisional hernia risk. 1

When Staples May Be Considered

Staples offer only one clinical advantage—speed of closure (22.5 cm/minute vs 4.2 cm/minute for sutures)—but this comes at the cost of increased complications. 2

• Staples cause significantly higher rates of inflammation, discomfort on removal, and spreading of healing scars compared to sutures. 3

• In cardiovascular surgery specifically, three out of five randomized trials found lower complication rates with sutures, and two studies demonstrated superior cosmesis with sutures. 4

• The time savings with staples (average 3 minutes per wound) does not justify the increased patient morbidity and inferior cosmetic outcomes. 2, 3

Tissue Adhesives: Avoid for Most Closures

• Tissue adhesives carry a 3.35-fold higher risk of wound breakdown compared to sutures (RR 3.35; 95% CI 1.53-7.33), requiring treatment of 43 patients with sutures instead of glue to prevent one additional dehiscence. 1

• Never use tissue adhesives alone in high-tension wounds, emergency laparotomy, abdominal wall closures, or any wound where mechanical forces are significant. 1

• Adhesives may only be considered for very superficial lacerations <0.5 cm in low-tension areas where hemostasis is already achieved. 1

Special Circumstances Requiring Specific Suture Selection

Contaminated or Infection-Prone Wounds

• Use triclosan-coated antimicrobial sutures (such as triclosan-coated Vicryl), which reduce surgical site infection risk by 28% (OR 0.72; 95% CI 0.59-0.88). 1

• This is mandatory for abdominal and colorectal surgery where contamination risk is elevated. 1

High-Tension Wounds

• High-tension wounds absolutely require sutures, as both tissue adhesives and staples fail where mechanical forces are significant. 1

• Use slowly absorbable monofilament material with proper 4:1 ratio technique. 1

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Never use rapidly absorbable sutures for fascial closure, as they increase incisional hernia rates due to quick loss of tensile strength. 1

• Avoid removing non-absorbable sutures or staples before 7-9 days, as premature removal causes dehiscence. 1

• Don't pull continuous sutures too tightly, as this strangulates wound edges and causes ischemia. 1

• Never include adipose tissue in abdominal sutures, as this significantly increases dehiscence, infection, and incisional hernia risk. 1

Practical Implementation

Optimal Suture Technique

• Place stitches in the subcuticular layer using continuous technique with slowly absorbable monofilament. 1

• Include only the aponeurosis (not fat or muscle) to reduce complication risk. 1

• Ensure adequate wound support by maintaining the 4:1 suture-to-wound length ratio throughout closure. 1

Post-Closure Monitoring

• Monitor for signs of infection (increasing pain, redness, swelling, discharge) regardless of closure method chosen. 1

• Watch specifically for wound dehiscence in the first 7-10 days postoperatively. 1

• Pain disproportionate to injury severity may suggest deeper complications requiring immediate evaluation. 5