Diagnostic Formulation for This Patient
This adult female patient meets DSM-5 criteria for three distinct diagnoses: ADHD Combined Presentation, Generalized Anxiety Disorder, and Alcohol Use Disorder—Moderate to Severe, currently in early remission on maintenance therapy. 1
Primary Diagnoses
1. Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Combined Presentation
The patient clearly meets DSM-5 criteria for ADHD Combined Presentation based on convergent self-report and collateral informant data. 1
Current Symptomatology (Last 6 Months):
- Inattention domain: Self-report shows 6 symptoms rated 3-4 (96-98th percentile, moderately symptomatic); partner corroborates with 6 symptoms rated 3-4 (96-98th percentile) 1
- Hyperactivity-Impulsivity domain: Self-report shows 5 combined symptoms rated 3-4 (1 hyperactivity + 4 impulsivity); partner corroborates with 4 impulsivity symptoms rated 3-4 1
- Total ADHD symptom count: 11 symptoms rated 3-4 on self-report (96-98th percentile), 10 symptoms on partner report (96-98th percentile) 1
Childhood Onset Verification:
- Patient reports symptom onset at age 10, meeting the DSM-5 requirement for manifestations before age 12 1
- Childhood self-report (ages 5-12) shows 7 symptoms rated 3-4 (84-92nd percentile, borderline/somewhat symptomatic) 1
- Critical caveat: Mother's retrospective report shows no elevated symptoms in childhood (all scores <75th percentile, 0 symptoms rated 3-4). This discrepancy is common in adult ADHD diagnosis when parents underreport or fail to recall childhood symptoms, particularly in females who may have presented with less disruptive inattentive symptoms 1
Impairment Across Multiple Settings:
- Home: Impulsivity causing relationship conflict with partner, difficulty with household task completion and prioritization 1
- Work: Excessive phone scrolling (2-3 hours during workday, "all day" when off work), difficulty with task initiation and procrastination 1
- Social: Interrupting friends in conversation, forgetting plans/details, overwhelmed in social settings 1
- Childhood settings: School (talking during class, difficulty focusing), home (parental frustration with listening/applying self) 1
Diagnostic Justification:
The convergence of self-report and partner report at the 96-98th percentile for total ADHD symptoms, combined with documented childhood onset and clear functional impairment across multiple domains, establishes a robust ADHD diagnosis despite the mother's non-corroborating childhood report 1. The Combined Presentation is appropriate given that both inattentive (6 symptoms) and hyperactive-impulsive (5 symptoms) domains exceed the DSM-5 threshold of 5 symptoms in each domain for adults 1.
2. Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD)
The patient meets full DSM-5 criteria for Generalized Anxiety Disorder with prominent somatic manifestations. 1
Core GAD Criteria Met:
- Excessive anxiety and worry for at least 6 months with difficulty controlling the worry 1, 2
- Restlessness and trouble calming down 1
- Mind racing, cannot slow down: Constant thinking about tasks (tomorrow's obligations, household chores), difficulty with task management 1
Somatic/Panic Symptoms:
- Episodes of trembling/shaking, choking sensations, chest discomfort, GI distress, lightheadedness, numbness/tingling, fear of losing control 1
- Important distinction: Patient explicitly denies persistent anxiety about additional panic attacks or maladaptive avoidance behaviors for at least one month, which rules out current Panic Disorder 1, 2
Historical Context:
- Past panic attacks in college before tests, last episode in [YEAR]—this represents Panic Disorder in remission, not an active diagnosis 2
Functional Impairment:
- Difficulty starting tasks, procrastination, mind wandering during conversations 1
Treatment Response:
3. Alcohol Use Disorder, Moderate to Severe, in Early Remission, On Maintenance Therapy
The patient meets DSM-5 criteria for Alcohol Use Disorder with at least 6-7 criteria, placing her in the moderate-to-severe range, currently in early remission on naltrexone maintenance therapy. 1, 4
DSM-5 Criteria Met (Minimum 6-7 of 11):
- Larger amounts/longer periods: Drinking until blackout, couple "drinks of vodka every 2-3 hours," consuming a fifth per week 1
- Difficulty cutting down/controlling use: "Always been hard to stop drinking when started" 1
- Great deal of time spent: Pattern of binge drinking, drinking alone to cope with IVF stress 1
- Craving: Implied by pattern of use and need for naltrexone 1
- Failure to fulfill major role obligations: Hiding drinking from partner, relationship conflict 1
- Continued use despite social/interpersonal problems: Drinking despite partner awareness of problem 1
- Hazardous use: Two DUIs ([YEAR] and [YEAR]) 1
- Tolerance: Likely present given escalating pattern and quantity consumed 1
- Withdrawal: Not explicitly documented but implied by severity of use 1
Severity Determination:
With 6-7+ criteria met, this qualifies as moderate (4-5 criteria) to severe (6+ criteria) Alcohol Use Disorder 1. Given the two DUIs, binge-to-blackout pattern, daily use of a fifth per week, and multiple treatment episodes, severe is most appropriate 1.
Remission Status:
- Early remission (≥3 to <12 months without meeting criteria except craving): Patient had last relapse on [recent date] after argument with mother, currently sober for approximately 2 months on naltrexone 1
- On maintenance therapy: Currently taking naltrexone for 2 months, enrolled in intensive outpatient program, seeing counselor every 2 weeks 1, 4
Treatment History:
- Past recovery program and outpatient treatment after [YEAR] DUI 4
- Vivitrol (injectable naltrexone) for 2 years with good response 4
- Two relapses since starting naltrexone: one on a holiday after 1 month sobriety, one on [recent date] 1
Diagnostic Hierarchy and Comorbidity Considerations
Why These Are Independent Diagnoses, Not Substance-Induced:
The ADHD and GAD are independent primary disorders, not substance-induced, based on temporal relationships and persistence during abstinence. 1, 4
- ADHD: Childhood onset at age 10, predating problematic alcohol use (which began in college) 1
- GAD: Excessive worry and anxiety symptoms persist currently despite 2 months of sobriety on naltrexone, exceeding the DSM-5 4-week threshold for ruling out substance-induced disorders 1, 4
- Panic Disorder (past): College panic attacks preceded the most severe alcohol use period, suggesting independent etiology; now in remission 1, 2
Comorbidity Patterns:
This triad of ADHD, anxiety disorders, and alcohol use disorder is well-documented and clinically significant. 1, 5, 6
- ADHD commonly co-occurs with anxiety disorders and substance use disorders 1, 5
- The patient's impulsivity (markedly elevated at 99th percentile) likely contributed to both the development of alcohol use disorder and difficulty maintaining abstinence 5
- Anxiety and depression mediate the relationship between ADHD symptoms and substance use behaviors 5
- Comorbid anxiety and alcohol use disorders are associated with poorer outcomes and require integrated treatment 4, 6
Additional Clinical Observations
Sluggish Cognitive Tempo (SCT):
- Self-report shows elevated SCT symptoms (23 total score, 93-95th percentile, 5 symptoms rated 3-4) 1
- Partner report shows normal range SCT (13 total score, <75th percentile) 1
- SCT is not a formal DSM-5 diagnosis but represents a dimensional construct that may inform treatment planning for attentional difficulties 1
Current Medications:
- Fluoxetine 80 mg: Started recently, on 80 mg for a few weeks, providing partial anxiety relief 2, 3
- Naltrexone: Started 2 months ago, helpful for maintaining sobriety 1, 4
Differential Diagnosis Exclusions:
- Substance-Induced Anxiety Disorder: Ruled out because anxiety symptoms persist beyond 4 weeks of abstinence and predate severe alcohol use 1, 4
- Current Panic Disorder: Ruled out because patient denies persistent anxiety about panic attacks or avoidance behaviors for at least one month 1, 2
- Oppositional Defiant Disorder/Conduct Disorder: Childhood history of "not liking being told what to do" but insufficient criteria for formal diagnosis 1
Final Diagnostic Summary
DSM-5 Diagnoses (in order of clinical priority):
Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder, Combined Presentation (childhood onset, currently symptomatic) 1
Generalized Anxiety Disorder (current, with somatic features) 1, 2
Alcohol Use Disorder, Severe, in Early Remission, On Maintenance Therapy (naltrexone) 1, 4
Panic Disorder, in Sustained Remission (last episode [YEAR], no current symptoms) 1, 2
Clinical Implications:
All three active diagnoses require concurrent integrated treatment, as sequential treatment of comorbid conditions yields inferior outcomes. 4, 6 The patient's current regimen of fluoxetine (addressing GAD), naltrexone (addressing AUD), and intensive outpatient programming represents an appropriate integrated approach, though ADHD-specific pharmacotherapy has not yet been initiated and should be considered once alcohol abstinence is more firmly established 1, 4.