What is the recommended management for a reproductive‑age male with a palpable varicocele, including criteria for observation versus surgical repair and the preferred treatment options?

Varicocele Management in Reproductive-Age Males

Direct Recommendation

Treat infertile men with a palpable (clinical) varicocele and abnormal semen parameters when the female partner has good ovarian reserve; do not treat men with normal semen analysis or subclinical (non-palpable) varicoceles. 1

---

Diagnostic Evaluation

Physical Examination

• Physical examination is the primary diagnostic tool for identifying clinical varicoceles 2
• A clinical varicocele must be palpable on physical examination to warrant treatment consideration 1
• Do not routinely use ultrasound to identify non-palpable (subclinical) varicoceles, as treatment of these does not improve semen parameters or fertility rates 3, 4

Laboratory Assessment

• Obtain two semen analyses at least one month apart with 2-3 days of abstinence before collection 3
• Perform endocrine evaluation including serum testosterone and FSH if sperm concentration is less than 10 million/mL 3
• For men with sperm concentration <5 million/mL, obtain karyotype testing and Y-chromosome microdeletion analysis (AZFa, AZFb, AZFc regions), as chromosomal abnormalities occur in approximately 4% of these men 3

---

Treatment Indications: When to Operate

Strong Indications for Surgery

Primary indication: Infertile men with all three criteria present 1:

• Clinical (palpable) varicocele on physical examination
• Abnormal semen parameters on at least two analyses
• Otherwise unexplained infertility with female partner having good ovarian reserve

Adolescent indication: Surgery is strongly recommended for varicocele associated with persistent testicular size difference >2 mL or 20%, confirmed on two separate visits 6 months apart 1, 3

Weak/Conditional Indications

Varicocelectomy may be considered in 1:

• Men with elevated sperm DNA fragmentation and otherwise unexplained infertility
• Men with failure of assisted reproductive techniques, including recurrent pregnancy loss
• Men with failure of embryogenesis and implantation

Absolute Contraindications to Surgery

Do not treat varicocele in the following situations 1:

• Men with normal semen analysis (regardless of varicocele grade)
• Men with subclinical (non-palpable) varicoceles detected only by ultrasound
• When IVF/ICSI is required primarily for female factor infertility 3

---

Special Populations

Non-Obstructive Azoospermia (NOA)

• Varicocelectomy may lead to sperm appearance in ejaculate for men with NOA, especially those with hypospermatogenesis on histology 3
• Fully discuss risks and benefits before proceeding, as evidence quality is low 3
• Critical consideration: If the female partner has limited ovarian reserve, time spent waiting for sperm recovery (3-6 months) may negatively impact overall fertility outcomes 3, 5
• Complete AZFa or AZFb deletions predict poor surgical outcomes and contraindicate varicocele repair 3

Men with Elevated FSH

• FSH levels >7.6 IU/L suggest underlying spermatogenic impairment, though men with FSH <11.7 mIU/mL have favorable prognosis for surgical success 3
• Elevated FSH in varicocele patients should prompt evaluation for testicular dysfunction or spermatogenic failure 3

---

Surgical Approach

Preferred Technique

• Microsurgical inguinal or subinguinal varicocelectomy is the optimal treatment in most cases, offering superior outcomes with low complication rates 6, 2, 7
• Use of operating microscope and micro-Doppler probe affords easier identification of vessels and lymphatics 7
• Laparoscopic varicocelectomy is more commonly used in adolescents 8

Alternative Approaches

• Laparoscopic varicocelectomy and radiological percutaneous embolization are useful only in specific cases 6
• Subinguinal technique is preferred when there is history of previous inguinal surgery 7

---

Expected Outcomes and Timeline

Semen Parameter Improvement

• Improvements in semen parameters typically take 3-6 months (two spermatogenic cycles) after surgery 3, 4, 6
• Spontaneous pregnancy typically occurs between 6 and 12 months after varicocelectomy 3, 4

Hormonal Changes

• Hormonal improvements parallel semen parameter improvements, taking approximately 3-6 months 3
• Significant decrease in SHBG levels occurs post-surgery (mean decrease of 32.72 nmol/L) 3

Fertility Outcomes

• Varicocele repair improves semen parameters and fertility outcomes in men with clinical varicoceles and abnormal semen analysis 4
• Meta-analysis shows improved outcomes following ART in oligozoospermic men (OR 1.69,95% CI 0.95-3.02) 4

---

Critical Pitfalls and Caveats

Common Errors to Avoid

• Do not use ultrasound routinely to identify subclinical varicoceles, as this leads to overtreatment without benefit 3, 4
• Do not treat varicoceles in men with normal semen parameters, regardless of varicocele grade or ultrasound findings 1
• Do not delay evaluation of the female partner, as her ovarian reserve significantly impacts treatment decisions 1, 3

Genetic Testing Considerations

• Complete AZFa or AZFb deletions contraindicate varicocele repair due to poor surgical outcomes 3
• AZFc deletions still allow for potential benefit from surgery 3

When to Consider Alternative Therapies

• If infertility persists 3-6 months after varicocelectomy, consider assisted reproductive technology, especially in older couples 6
• For couples with limited female ovarian reserve, direct sperm retrieval (micro-TESE) may be more appropriate than waiting for post-surgical sperm recovery 3, 5