How to Order a Hip X-ray for Suspected Fracture
Order an anteroposterior (AP) view of the pelvis with approximately 15 degrees of internal hip rotation plus a cross-table lateral view of the symptomatic hip as your initial imaging study. 1, 2
Standard Initial Imaging Protocol
The two-view combination is the established standard:
- AP pelvis view with 15 degrees of internal rotation 1, 2
- Cross-table lateral view of the affected hip 1
Some institutions add a third view (separate AP of the symptomatic hip), though there is no specific literature comparing the two-view versus three-view approach 1
Why This Specific Combination Matters
The AP pelvis view is essential because:
- Patients with suspected proximal femur fractures often have concomitant pelvic fractures (sacrum, pubic rami) that occur in isolation or with femoral fractures 1
- It allows comparison with the contralateral asymptomatic side, which is crucial for accurate diagnosis 1, 2
- It may reveal pathology beyond the symptomatic hip that changes management 2, 3
The cross-table lateral view is critical because:
- It improves overall sensitivity for fracture detection beyond the AP view alone 1
- It changes treatment decisions in a subset of patients even when the AP view appears positive 1
- It is preferred over frog-leg lateral views in trauma cases due to lower risk of fracture displacement 2
Ordering Instructions
Write the order as: "X-ray hip, 2 views: AP pelvis and cross-table lateral of [left/right] hip" or "X-ray pelvis and hip: AP pelvis with cross-table lateral of symptomatic hip" 1, 2
Request portable imaging if the patient:
- Cannot safely be moved due to pain or instability 1, 3
- Has suspected fracture requiring immobilization 3
Critical Pitfall to Avoid
Never order only hip views without the pelvis view – this misses associated pelvic fractures in a substantial proportion of patients and may lead to incomplete diagnosis and inappropriate treatment planning 1, 2
When Initial Radiographs Are Negative But Suspicion Remains High
If radiographs are negative or equivocal but clinical suspicion for fracture persists:
- Order MRI hip without IV contrast as the next study, which has near 100% sensitivity for proximal femoral fractures 1, 2, 3
- Alternatively, order CT hip without IV contrast if MRI is contraindicated or unavailable, though CT is less sensitive (79-94% sensitivity) 1
The rationale for advanced imaging:
- At least 10% of proximal femoral fractures are radiographically occult 1
- In patients with negative radiographs but persistent clinical concern, 24-39% will have occult fractures on advanced imaging 1
- Delays in diagnosis increase mortality, complication rates, hospital length-of-stay, and costs 1, 2, 3
Special Considerations for Your Patient
Given the history of osteoporosis and prior hip surgery:
- Radiographs remain the appropriate first-line study 1, 2
- Hardware from prior surgery may complicate interpretation but does not change the initial imaging approach 2
- The threshold for proceeding to MRI should be low if radiographs are negative, given the high-risk profile 1, 3
Given the acute presentation with inability to bear weight: