Are Lens Subluxation and Lens Displacement the Same Condition?
Lens subluxation and lens displacement are overlapping but not identical terms—subluxation specifically refers to partial dislocation where the lens remains partially supported by intact zonular fibers, while displacement is a broader term encompassing any abnormal lens position, including both subluxation (partial) and complete dislocation (total loss of zonular support).
Terminology and Clinical Distinctions
Subluxation (Partial Dislocation)
- Subluxation describes a lens that has moved from its normal position but retains some zonular fiber attachments, allowing it to remain partially in place behind the pupil 1.
- The lens typically exhibits visible edge or equator through the dilated pupil, with phacodonesis (lens tremulousness) on eye movement 1.
- Zonular defects are present but incomplete, maintaining some structural support 2, 3.
Complete Dislocation
- Complete dislocation (also called luxation) occurs when all zonular attachments rupture, causing the lens to drop into the vitreous cavity or displace anteriorly into the anterior chamber 4, 5.
- This represents the most severe form of lens displacement with total loss of normal anatomic position 5.
Displacement as an Umbrella Term
- "Displacement" functions as a general descriptor for any abnormal lens position, whether partial (subluxation) or complete (dislocation) 1.
- The term encompasses anterior displacement (forward shift of the lens-iris diaphragm), posterior displacement (into vitreous), and lateral/decentered positions 1.
Etiologic Categories
Congenital/Hereditary Causes
- Marfan syndrome produces lens subluxation (ectopia lentis) as a cardinal feature, with the lens typically displaced superiorly and temporally due to FBN1 gene mutations affecting fibrillin-1 in zonular fibers 1, 4.
- Homocystinuria causes lens subluxation with greater mobility and earlier visual compromise than Marfan syndrome 4.
- Weill-Marchesani syndrome presents with lens subluxation and high risk of pupillary-block glaucoma requiring prophylactic peripheral iridectomy 4.
Acquired Causes
- Trauma accounts for the majority of surgical cases (76 eyes out of 102 surgical cases in one series), causing zonular dialysis and subsequent lens displacement 2.
- Acute angle-closure glaucoma can lead to zonular weakness and delayed spontaneous lens subluxation months to years after the initial attack 6.
- Iatrogenic causes include intraocular lens (IOL) decentration or subluxation following cataract surgery, particularly with asymmetric capsular shrinkage, posterior synechiae, or zonular defects 3.
Clinical Implications and Management Differences
Conservative Management Indications
- The presence of a subluxated lens alone is not an absolute indication for surgical removal—conservative management with spectacle or contact lens correction is appropriate when visual function is adequate 2, 4.
- Patients with Marfan syndrome generally function well with spectacle correction and should be managed conservatively to avoid surgical complications 4.
Surgical Indications
- Surgery is indicated for reduction in visual acuity, uncorrectable refractive error, or secondary glaucoma 2.
- Lens removal should be performed when significant optical defocus from subluxation cannot be corrected with eyeglasses or contact lenses 1.
- In Weill-Marchesani syndrome, lens surgery is undertaken if glaucoma cannot be controlled medically or with peripheral iridectomy 4.
Surgical Approach Considerations
- Avoid open-sky techniques for lens removal in subluxation cases—use aspiration or pars plana vitrectomy approaches instead to minimize immediate surgical complications 4, 5.
- The vitrophage technique provides good results for uncomplicated subluxated or dislocated lenses into the vitreous, with best outcomes when not associated with glaucoma, perforating injuries, or retinal detachment 5.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Do not assume all lens displacement requires immediate surgery—visual outcomes can be similar between surgical and conservative management groups when appropriately selected 2.
- Recognize that lens status (degree of subluxation) has no significant influence on surgical outcome—the decision should be based on visual function and complications rather than anatomic position alone 2.
- In homocystinuria, delay lens surgery until the patient can tolerate local anesthesia due to high risk of vascular thrombosis with general anesthesia 4.
- Monitor for major postoperative complications including glaucoma (10.8%), retinal detachment (8.8%), and IOL dislocation (2.9%) following surgical management of subluxated lenses 2.