In a smoker with hypertension who presents with abdominal pain that worsens with movement, soft stools, increased flatulence, chills, and cramping without recent travel, fever, or heartburn, what other differential diagnoses should be considered besides diverticulitis?

Differential Diagnoses Beyond Diverticulitis

In this smoker with hypertension presenting with abdominal pain worsened by movement, soft stools, increased gas, chills, and cramping, you must urgently exclude mesenteric ischemia, followed by inflammatory bowel disease, irritable bowel syndrome, and infectious colitis.

Critical Life-Threatening Diagnosis: Mesenteric Ischemia

Mesenteric ischemia must be ruled out immediately given this patient's smoking history and hypertension—both are major risk factors for atherosclerotic disease affecting the splanchnic vasculature 1.

Key Clinical Features Supporting This Diagnosis:

• "Pain out of proportion to examination" is the hallmark presentation, though this patient's pain worsening with movement could represent peritoneal irritation from bowel ischemia 1
• Smoking and hypertension are specifically identified as major risk factors for chronic mesenteric ischemia due to atherosclerotic disease 1
• Chills without documented fever may represent early systemic response to bowel ischemia 1
• Soft stools and increased gas could reflect early mucosal injury 1

Immediate Diagnostic Approach:

• CT angiography (CTA) of abdomen and pelvis is the diagnostic test of choice for mesenteric ischemia, as it can visualize arterial occlusion, venous thrombosis, and secondary bowel changes 1
• Laboratory findings are nonspecific early but may show metabolic acidosis, elevated lactate, elevated D-dimer, and leukocytosis 1
• Do not rely on plain radiographs—25% of patients with acute mesenteric ischemia have normal films, and abnormal findings appear only after bowel infarction has occurred 1

Critical Pitfall:

The mortality rate for mesenteric ischemia ranges from 30-90% despite treatment advances, making early diagnosis essential 1. The elderly population with cardiovascular risk factors has the highest prevalence 1.

---

Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD)

IBD, particularly Crohn's disease, should be strongly considered given the constellation of abdominal pain, altered bowel habits, and systemic symptoms in a smoker 1.

Supporting Features:

• Smoking is a significant risk factor for Crohn's disease and is associated with more severe disease, increased pain, and higher medication requirements 1
• Pain worsening with movement suggests peritoneal irritation, which can occur with transmural inflammation, abscess formation, or microperforation 1
• Soft stools with increased gas are consistent with inflammatory diarrhea 1
• Chills without fever may represent low-grade inflammation 1

Diagnostic Workup:

• CT abdomen/pelvis with IV and oral contrast can identify bowel wall thickening, strictures, abscesses, or fistulas 1
• Laboratory testing should include CBC (anemia, leukocytosis), CRP (elevated in active inflammation), and metabolic panel 1
• Colonoscopy should be deferred until acute inflammation is excluded, as it increases perforation risk during active disease 1

Key Distinction from Diverticulitis:

IBD typically affects younger patients but can present at any age, involves skip lesions in Crohn's disease, and may show extraintestinal manifestations 1.

---

Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS)

IBS is a plausible diagnosis but should only be considered after excluding organic pathology, particularly given the patient's risk factors 1.

Clinical Features:

• Abdominal pain with altered bowel habits (soft stools) fits IBS criteria 1
• Increased flatulence and bloating are cardinal IBS symptoms related to visceral hypersensitivity and altered gut motility 1
• Smoking is associated with functional abdominal pain, functional bloating, and functional constipation in population studies 2

Important Caveats:

• Chills are NOT typical of IBS and should raise concern for organic disease 1
• Pain worsening with movement is atypical for IBS, which usually improves with defecation 1
• IBS is a diagnosis of exclusion requiring normal inflammatory markers and imaging 1

Pathophysiology Relevant to This Case:

• Only 10-20% of IBS patients have abnormal colonic transit 1
• Visceral hypersensitivity and mast cell activation may explain pain and gas symptoms 1
• Stress and psychological comorbidity can exacerbate symptoms 1

---

Infectious/Inflammatory Colitis

Gastroenterocolitis or infectious colitis should be considered despite no recent travel history 1.

Supporting Features:

• Soft stools with cramping and systemic symptoms (chills) suggest infectious etiology 1
• Community-acquired infections (C. difficile, Campylobacter, Salmonella) do not require travel 1
• Increased gas production can occur with bacterial overgrowth or colonic inflammation 1

Diagnostic Approach:

• Stool studies including culture, ova and parasites, C. difficile toxin, and fecal leukocytes 1
• CT imaging is preferred over plain films for evaluating colitis, showing bowel wall thickening and pericolonic inflammation 1

---

Additional Considerations in This Smoker with Hypertension

Metabolic Syndrome Impact:

• The combination of hypertension and smoking (likely with obesity given the risk profile) exponentially increases surgical risk if operative intervention becomes necessary 3
• Patients with metabolic syndrome have 8-fold higher odds of adverse events with operative diverticulitis 3

Smoking-Specific Gastrointestinal Effects:

• Smoking is independently associated with functional abdominal pain (OR 1.30), functional bloating (OR 1.18), and functional constipation (OR 1.28) 2
• These functional symptoms may coexist with or mimic organic pathology 2

---

Recommended Diagnostic Algorithm

1. Immediate CT angiography of abdomen/pelvis with IV contrast to exclude mesenteric ischemia and evaluate for diverticulitis, IBD, abscess, or perforation 1

2. Laboratory panel: CBC with differential, CRP, lactate, metabolic panel, lipase, liver enzymes 1, 4

3. Stool studies if diarrhea predominates: culture, C. difficile, fecal leukocytes 1

4. Colonoscopy deferred 6-8 weeks if acute inflammation is present, but performed earlier if alarm symptoms develop (rectal bleeding, weight loss, anemia) 1

5. Reassess smoking cessation as therapeutic intervention for both cardiovascular risk and gastrointestinal symptoms 1, 2