Synovial Osteochondromatosis
Overview
Synovial osteochondromatosis is a benign proliferative disorder of the synovium characterized by cartilaginous metaplasia that produces multiple intra-articular loose bodies, most commonly affecting the knee (70% of cases), and requires surgical removal of loose bodies with synovectomy for symptomatic relief and prevention of degenerative arthritis. 1, 2, 3
Clinical Presentation
Primary Symptoms
- Joint pain is the predominant presenting complaint, often accompanied by mechanical symptoms 1, 3
- Locking episodes and decreased range of motion occur when loose bodies interfere with joint mechanics 2
- Joint swelling from effusion or synovial proliferation 1
- Symptoms may be initially misdiagnosed as osteoarthritis on clinical examination and plain radiographs alone 1
Joint Distribution
- Knee joint involvement occurs in 70% of cases, typically affecting the anterior compartment (infrapatellar fat pad, suprapatellar pouch, anterior interval) 2
- Hip joint is the second most common site 4
- Hand and wrist involvement is less common but well-documented 5
- Larger joints are preferentially affected 1, 3
Diagnostic Work-Up
Initial Imaging Approach
Plain radiographs are frequently normal or show only nonspecific soft-tissue swelling in early disease, making them inadequate for diagnosis despite being commonly obtained first. 1
- Calcified loose bodies appear as rounded, amorphous opacities when mineralization has occurred 6
- X-rays miss non-calcified cartilaginous bodies entirely, which are present in early-stage disease 6, 7
Advanced Imaging (Essential for Diagnosis)
Ultrasound with high-frequency transducers (≥10 MHz) should be the first-line advanced imaging modality for detecting loose bodies, synovial proliferation, and joint effusion 4, 8
- Ultrasound can identify (osteo-)chondromatosis as a specific pathologic finding in the hip and knee 4
- Suprapatellar pouch scanning in 30° flexion with longitudinal and transverse views is optimal for knee evaluation 8
- Critical limitation: Ultrasound cannot rule out loose bodies if not visualized; absence of findings does not exclude their presence 4, 8
MRI is indicated when ultrasound findings are equivocal or for preoperative planning 1, 7, 5
- MRI demonstrates cartilaginous nodules in all stages of disease, including non-calcified bodies 7
- Contrast-enhanced MRI can reveal high-grade areas if malignant transformation is suspected 4
- Computed arthrotomography and MRI should be performed preoperatively to ensure complete excision, particularly in hand and wrist cases 5
Confirmatory Diagnosis
Histopathological evaluation is confirmatory and mandatory to establish the diagnosis definitively 1
- Tissue specimens show synovial metaplasia into chondrocytes with cartilaginous nodule formation 2, 3
- Pathology distinguishes primary synovial osteochondromatosis from secondary forms related to degenerative joint disease 5
Management Algorithm
Asymptomatic or Minimal Symptoms
- Monitoring alone may be appropriate for truly asymptomatic cases discovered incidentally 1
- Non-surgical management with pain medications and physical therapy can be attempted initially 1
Symptomatic Disease (Most Cases)
Surgical intervention is the only effective treatment for symptomatic synovial osteochondromatosis and should include both removal of loose bodies and synovectomy of the affected synovium. 1, 2, 3
Surgical Approach Selection
Arthroscopic synovectomy with loose body removal is the preferred technique due to low morbidity, minimal postoperative pain, better cosmetic results, early range-of-motion recovery, short rehabilitation, and early return to function 2
- Arthroscopy can address disease in both anterior and posterior compartments of the knee when proper technique is used 2
- Open synovectomy may be required for extensive disease or when arthroscopic access is inadequate 2, 3
Extent of Surgery
Complete removal of loose bodies AND adjacent synovial membrane is essential to minimize recurrence risk 3, 5
- Synovectomy alone without loose body removal is inadequate 3
- Detailed preoperative imaging (CT arthrotomography and MRI) increases the likelihood of complete excision, particularly in hand and wrist cases 5
Prognosis and Follow-Up
Recurrence Risk
Recurrence occurs in approximately 20% of cases (4 of 21 in one series), typically within 5-10 years after surgery 5
- Intra-articular disease carries higher recurrence risk than tenosynovial disease 5
- Multiple recurrences can occur in the same patient 5
- Incomplete initial excision is the primary risk factor for recurrence 5
Long-Term Complications
Degenerative arthritis develops within several years if the disease is left untreated 3
- Early intervention prevents joint damage and improves long-term outcomes 1
- Malignant transformation to chondrosarcoma is extremely rare but has been reported 1
- Differentiation from secondary chondrosarcoma arising in pre-existing osteochondroma requires careful pathologic evaluation 4
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
- Do not rely on plain radiographs alone to diagnose or exclude synovial osteochondromatosis, as they are normal in most early cases 6, 1
- Do not assume absence of loose bodies based on negative ultrasound, as ultrasound cannot definitively rule out their presence 4, 8
- Do not perform loose body removal without synovectomy, as this leads to recurrence 3
- Do not mistake the condition for simple osteoarthritis based on clinical examination and X-rays alone; maintain high suspicion and proceed to advanced imaging 1
- Do not overlook posterior compartment involvement in the knee, which requires specific arthroscopic techniques for complete treatment 2