Laryngeal Nerve Injury During Thyroidectomy: Patient-Reported Symptoms
Patients with laryngeal nerve damage during thyroidectomy will report distinctly different symptoms depending on which nerve is injured: recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) injury causes breathy voice, hoarseness, and vocal fatigue from incomplete vocal fold closure, while external branch of superior laryngeal nerve (EBSLN) injury causes vocal fatigue, inability to raise pitch, and difficulty projecting the voice. 1
Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve (RLN) Injury Symptoms
Unilateral RLN Injury
- Breathy voice quality due to inadequate vocal fold closure during phonation 1
- Hoarseness from the immobile and laterally displaced vocal fold 1
- Vocal fatigue as the patient compensates for incomplete glottic closure 1
- Mild dysphagia from inadequate closure during swallowing 1
- Loss of vocal fold bulk and tone with visible bowing of the affected fold 1
Bilateral RLN Injury
- Stridor and acute airway obstruction representing a potentially catastrophic complication 1
- Severe dyspnea requiring possible emergency tracheotomy 1
- Serious effects on social interaction and occupational status, particularly devastating for professional voice users 1
Superior Laryngeal Nerve (EBSLN) Injury Symptoms
The external branch of the superior laryngeal nerve injury produces more subtle but functionally significant voice changes 1:
- Vocal fatigue that worsens with prolonged speaking 1
- Decreased ability to raise pitch affecting vocal range 1
- Inability to project voice making it difficult to speak loudly 1
- Decreased pitch flexibility and range causing monotone speech 1
- Physical findings may include posterior laryngeal rotation toward the paretic side, bowing of the vocal fold on the weak side, or inferior displacement of the affected fold, though these are not reliable predictors 1
Incidence and Clinical Context
About 1 in 10 patients (10%) experience temporary laryngeal nerve injury after thyroid surgery, with longer lasting voice problems occurring in up to 1 in 25 patients (4%). 1 The definitive RLN paralysis rate is generally lower than 3%, with transient forms occurring in 6-8% of cases 1. Recent large multi-institutional data shows RLN injury occurs in approximately 6% of thyroid surgeries 2.
Important Clinical Pitfalls
Timing of Symptom Recognition
- Early temporary vocal fold motion abnormalities may last up to 4 weeks postoperatively, so voice changes persisting beyond 2 weeks warrant formal evaluation 1
- Patients should be instructed to notify providers if voice changes (breathiness, hoarseness, decreased exercise tolerance, or increased vocal effort) last more than 2 weeks 1
Superior Laryngeal Nerve Injury Often Missed
- EBSLN injury is less documented and more difficult to recognize than RLN injury, perhaps explaining why it receives less attention 3
- The risk of EBSLN injury during thyroidectomy is significant (documented at 5% in one study) and may be devastating to professional voice users 3
- Laryngeal videostroboscopy and electromyography may be necessary to diagnose EBSLN injury 3
Non-Neural Causes of Voice Changes
Voice changes after thyroidectomy are not always due to nerve injury 1, 4:
- Direct cricothyroid muscle injury (transient myositis or direct trauma) produces symptoms similar to EBSLN injury 1
- Regional soft tissue injury including laryngotracheal scar with fixation, strap muscle denervation/trauma, or local hematoma/edema causes voice fatigue, decreased vocal range, and monotone speech 1
- Intubation-related injuries including vocal fold trauma (edema, hematoma, laceration), granuloma formation, or arytenoid dislocation 1
- Postthyroidectomy syndrome describes various pharyngolaryngeal symptoms occurring after thyroidectomy in the absence of laryngeal nerve injury, including globus symptoms and voice changes 5
Pre-existing Voice Problems
More than one-third of patients have preoperative voice modifications or swallowing impairment before thyroidectomy 4. Preoperatively, patients may have hoarseness or dysphagia from vocal cord monoplegia (2%), hypomobility (6%), cord hypotonia (3%), or other causes (14%) 4. This underscores the importance of documenting baseline voice assessment before surgery 1.
Management Recommendations
When abnormal vocal fold mobility is identified after thyroid surgery, patients should be referred to an otolaryngologist for comprehensive evaluation and access to voice rehabilitation options. 1 Early evaluation and therapy within the window of opportunity (between 2 weeks and 2 months postoperatively) ensures greater likelihood of improving long-term voice outcomes 1.