From the Guidelines
Using both a condom and the withdrawal method together can significantly reduce the risk of pregnancy, with a combined failure rate of less than 2% when used perfectly, as the condom has a 2% failure rate with perfect use and withdrawal has a 4% failure rate with perfect use 1. When considering the use of both a condom and the withdrawal method, it's essential to understand the effectiveness of each method individually. According to the data, condoms have a 2% failure rate with perfect use and an 18% failure rate with typical use, while withdrawal has a 4% failure rate with perfect use and a 27% failure rate with typical use 1.
Key Points to Consider
- The failure rates of condoms and withdrawal methods can be significantly reduced when used together, providing a backup protection if one fails.
- To maximize effectiveness, ensure the condom is put on correctly before any genital contact, check for damage, leave space at the tip, and withdraw before ejaculation even with the condom on.
- Neither method provides perfect protection against STIs, though condoms offer good protection.
- For even greater pregnancy prevention, consider adding a hormonal method like the pill, patch, or IUD in consultation with a healthcare provider.
Effectiveness Comparison
- The combined failure rate of less than 2% when using both methods perfectly is significantly lower than the individual failure rates of condoms (2% with perfect use) and withdrawal (4% with perfect use) 1.
- The data suggests that using both methods together can provide a higher level of protection against pregnancy compared to using either method alone.
From the FDA Drug Label
Condoms, sponge, withdrawal, spermicides, diaphragm: Use correctly every time you have sex Tier 3 Less Effective More than 13 pregnancies per 100 women in one year
The chance of pregnancy with a condom and pull-out method is more than 13 pregnancies per 100 women in one year if used correctly every time. However, the effectiveness of these methods can vary depending on proper use. 2