Incisions of Septoplasty
The two primary incisions used in septoplasty are the hemitransfixion incision and the Killian incision, with the choice depending on the extent of septal exposure needed—severe dorsal and caudal septal deformities require a hemitransfixion or even open transcolumellar approach with complete bilateral mucoperichondrial elevation, while isolated or less severe deviations can be addressed through a Killian incision. 1
Primary Incision Types
Hemitransfixion Incision
- Location: Made at the caudal septum, extending from the membranous septum through the columella
- Exposure: Provides extensive access to the entire septum including dorsal and caudal regions
- Indications: Severe deformities or deviations of the dorsal and caudal septum that determine nasal shape and position 1
- Advantage: Allows complete bilateral mucoperichondrial elevation for extensive septal manipulation
- Consideration: More invasive but necessary when comprehensive septal realignment is required
Killian Incision
- Location: Placed more posteriorly within the nasal vestibule, typically 1-2 cm posterior to the caudal edge
- Exposure: Provides access to the posterior septum while preserving the anterior septal support
- Indications: Isolated posterior septal deviations or when anterior L-strut preservation is critical
- Advantage: More conservative approach with less risk to structural support 2
Open Transcolumellar Approach
- Location: External incision across the columella combined with marginal incisions
- Exposure: Maximum visualization of the entire nasal framework
- Indications: Severe complex deviations requiring extensive reconstruction, revision cases, or when concurrent tip work is needed 1
- Advantage: Superior visualization and ability to perform complex grafting procedures
Endoscopic Modifications
Modern septoplasty increasingly utilizes endoscopic visualization, which can be combined with traditional incisions 2:
- Endoscopic-assisted approach: Uses Killian or hemitransfixion incision with endoscope placed under the flaps for enhanced visualization of broad-based convexities
- Focal spur technique: Incision placed directly over the spur apex for targeted resection under endoscopic guidance
- Advantage: Improved precision and ability to address specific anatomical abnormalities
Revision Septoplasty Considerations
For revision cases, specialized incision techniques may be necessary 3:
- Semi-penetrating straight incisions: Made in front of the caudal septum
- Circular incisions: Placed at the margin of nasal septal cartilage-bone defects
- Purpose: Allow exposure of osteocartilaginous framework while protecting mucous membranes and enabling correction of residual deviations
Critical Surgical Principles
The incision choice must be individualized based on the anatomical location and severity of deviation 1:
- Caudal septal deflection alone: Hemitransfixion provides optimal access for mobilization, trimming, and suturing techniques
- Posterior deviations: Killian incision may suffice with less disruption to anterior support structures
- Complex or revision cases: Open approach provides comprehensive exposure for grafting and reconstruction
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Over-aggressive cartilage incisions: Cross-hatching incisions on cartilage may be overemphasized—75% of septal deviations can be corrected by manipulating only bony components without cartilaginous incisions 4
- Inadequate exposure: Choosing too conservative an incision for severe deviations leads to incomplete correction
- Compromising L-strut integrity: Regardless of incision type, preserve at least 1 cm of dorsal and caudal strut to prevent saddle nose deformity 5
The evidence consistently emphasizes that severe septal deformities require extensive exposure facilitated by hemitransfixion or open approaches, while less severe deviations can be managed with more conservative Killian incisions 1. The key is matching the incision to the anatomical complexity rather than defaulting to a single technique for all cases.