Sensorineural Hearing Loss of the Left Ear
The most likely diagnosis is sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) of the left ear. 1
Interpretation of Tuning Fork Tests
The key to this diagnosis lies in correctly interpreting the Weber and Rinne test results:
- Positive Rinne bilaterally means air conduction is better than bone conduction in both ears, which is normal and rules out conductive hearing loss (CHL) in either ear 1
- Weber lateralizing to the right ear indicates either:
- CHL in the right ear, OR
- SNHL in the opposite (left) ear 1
Since the Rinne test is positive bilaterally (ruling out CHL), the Weber lateralization to the right must indicate SNHL in the left ear 1.
Clinical Reasoning
This 34-year-old man presents with:
- Acute onset (3 days) of muffled hearing
- No pain, tinnitus, or vertigo
- Intact tympanic membranes with no effusion or inflammation
- Normal vital signs
The physical examination excludes common causes of CHL such as cerumen impaction, tympanic membrane perforation, or middle ear effusion 1. The tuning fork examination is critical here—it distinguishes between CHL and SNHL before formal audiometry is available 1.
Critical Next Steps
This patient requires urgent audiometry within 14 days of symptom onset to confirm sudden sensorineural hearing loss (SSNHL) and determine if he meets criteria (≥30 dB hearing loss at 3 consecutive frequencies) 1. The 3-day history places him well within the treatment window.
Do not delay referral. If SSNHL is confirmed, corticosteroid intervention should be initiated within 2 weeks of symptom onset 1. Delayed treatment may result in permanent hearing loss and reduced quality of life 1.
Important Caveats
While idiopathic SSNHL accounts for 90% of cases 1, this patient should be evaluated for:
- Retrocochlear pathology via MRI or auditory brainstem response to exclude acoustic neuroma or other central causes 1
- Vascular events such as AICA infarction, which can present as isolated sudden deafness without brainstem signs 2
The absence of neurologic findings does not exclude serious pathology—AICA territory infarction can manifest solely as sudden hearing loss 2.