Determining With-the-Rule vs Against-the-Rule Astigmatism from Biometry
To determine astigmatism type from biometry readings, look at the steep axis (meridian of maximum power): if the steep axis is between 75-105 degrees (vertical), it's with-the-rule (WTR); if between 0-15 degrees or 165-180 degrees (horizontal), it's against-the-rule (ATR); if between 16-74 degrees or 106-164 degrees, it's oblique.
The Classification System
The classification is straightforward and based on where the steepest corneal meridian is located 1, 2:
- With-the-rule (WTR): Steep axis at 75-105 degrees (essentially vertical)
- Against-the-rule (ATR): Steep axis at 0-15 degrees and 165-180 degrees (essentially horizontal)
- Oblique: Steep axis at 16-74 degrees and 106-164 degrees
Reading Your Biometry Report
When you obtain keratometry values from optical biometry devices (IOLMaster, Lenstar, Pentacam, etc.), you'll typically see two principal meridians with their powers and axes. The steeper meridian (higher diopter value) determines the classification 3, 2.
For example:
- K1: 43.0 D @ 180° and K2: 44.5 D @ 90° → The steep meridian is at 90° (vertical) → WTR astigmatism
- K1: 43.0 D @ 90° and K2: 44.5 D @ 180° → The steep meridian is at 180° (horizontal) → ATR astigmatism
Important Clinical Context
Age-Related Patterns
Astigmatism orientation shifts with age 3. Children commonly have WTR astigmatism, while older adults tend toward ATR astigmatism. In cataract surgery candidates, approximately 47% have WTR, 34% have ATR, and 19% have oblique astigmatism 2.
Measurement Zone Considerations
The diameter zone measured matters for accuracy 4. The 3.3-mm measurement zone provides more accurate corneal astigmatism estimation than the 2.4-mm zone, particularly for ATR astigmatism. This is clinically relevant when planning toric IOL implantation.
Device-Specific Nuances
Different biometry devices measure different aspects of corneal astigmatism 5:
- Standard keratometry (anterior corneal surface only)
- Total keratometry/total corneal refractive power (includes posterior corneal contribution)
Results from different modalities are not interchangeable, so consistency in device selection for pre- and post-operative measurements is essential 5.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Don't confuse the axis notation: The axis reported is the meridian of the steep cornea (maximum power), not the correcting cylinder axis used in spectacle prescriptions
- Ensure ocular surface integrity: Dry eye or poor tear film significantly affects measurement accuracy 6. Optimize the ocular surface before critical measurements
- Obtain multiple measurements: At least 2-3 measurements should be taken to ensure reliability 6
- Don't ignore posterior corneal astigmatism: For toric IOL planning, total corneal astigmatism (including posterior surface) provides better outcomes than anterior keratometry alone 4, 5