Urgent Excisional Biopsy Required
This expanding black lesion with peripheral scaling requires immediate complete excisional biopsy with 2mm margins to rule out melanoma, which is the most critical diagnosis to exclude given the recent growth and black discoloration. 1
Why This Lesion is Concerning
Your lesion demonstrates multiple high-risk features for melanoma:
- Evolution (recent change): Expanding over one week is a major red flag 1, 2
- Black discoloration: Heterogeneous dark pigmentation is a key melanoma criterion 1
- Peripheral scaling: Suggests irregular borders, another melanoma warning sign 1
The ABCDE criteria for melanoma include:
- Asymmetry
- Border irregularities (your peripheral scaling)
- Color heterogeneity (black discoloration)
- Diameter >6mm
- Evolution/recent change (expanding since one week) 1, 2
The absence of pain or itch is NOT reassuring - melanomas frequently present without symptoms 3.
Immediate Action Required
Complete excisional biopsy is mandatory, not punch or shave biopsy 1. Here's why:
- Partial biopsies risk missing the diagnosis - melanoma thickness varies across the lesion 1, 4
- Breslow thickness determines prognosis and treatment - only measurable with complete excision 1
- Excise with 2mm margins using a scalpel (never laser or electrocautery which destroy tissue) 1
- Orient the elliptical incision along skin tension lines to allow re-excision if needed 1
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
- Do not observe or monitor this lesion - any expanding black lesion requires tissue diagnosis 2, 5
- Do not treat empirically (e.g., for fungal infection or eczema) - this delays melanoma diagnosis 1
- Do not perform dermoscopy alone - while helpful, it cannot replace histologic diagnosis and should only be used by experienced practitioners 1
- Do not do a shave biopsy - this prevents accurate Breslow depth measurement 1, 4
What the Pathologist Needs
The specimen must be sent with:
- Patient age and sex
- Exact anatomic location
- Duration of lesion and recent changes 1
The pathology report must include:
Alternative Diagnoses (Still Require Biopsy)
While melanoma is the primary concern, other possibilities include:
- Seborrheic keratosis (but these rarely expand rapidly) 1, 6
- Pigmented basal cell carcinoma 1
- Dysplastic nevus 1
However, given the rapid expansion and black color, melanoma must be excluded first 2, 5.
Timeline
This should be excised within days, not weeks 2, 5. If you cannot perform the excision yourself, refer urgently to dermatology or surgical oncology. Document the lesion size and appearance now for comparison.
The 5-year survival for melanoma <1mm thick is ~90%, but drops significantly with increasing thickness 3. Early complete excision is the only way to achieve cure 1, 2.