Evaluation and Management of Referred Diaphragmatic Left Shoulder Pain (Kehr's Sign)
When a patient presents with referred diaphragmatic left shoulder pain (Kehr's sign), you must immediately rule out life-threatening intra-abdominal hemorrhage—particularly splenic injury or rupture—through urgent imaging with CT scan, which is the gold standard for diagnosis. 1, 2
Immediate Clinical Assessment
Kehr's sign indicates diaphragmatic irritation from blood or other intraperitoneal contents and demands urgent evaluation for:
- Splenic injury/rupture (most critical)
- Diaphragmatic hernia (can present with isolated shoulder pain)
- Hemoperitoneum from any source
- Ectopic pregnancy (in women of reproductive age)
Key Clinical Features to Assess
- Hemodynamic status: Even with maintained blood pressure and normal hemoglobin, tachycardia >100 bpm suggests early compensated bleeding 3
- Pain characteristics: Sudden onset left upper quadrant pain radiating to left shoulder is classic 3, 4
- Syncopal episodes: Indicate significant blood loss 4
- Pain with surfeit/eating: May suggest diaphragmatic hernia 5
- Trauma history: Though absence doesn't exclude injury—spontaneous splenic rupture can occur with EBV or other causes 6
Critical pitfall: Patients can present with isolated shoulder pain without abdominal symptoms, and the shoulder pain may even be contralateral (right-sided hernia causing left shoulder pain) 7. Don't be falsely reassured by normal vital signs or lack of abdominal tenderness.
Diagnostic Imaging Algorithm
First-Line Imaging
Contrast-enhanced CT scan of chest and abdomen is the gold standard with sensitivity 14-82% and specificity 87% for diaphragmatic pathology 2. CT provides:
- Detection of hemoperitoneum and active bleeding (arterial phase contrast blush)
- Identification of splenic injury/rupture
- Visualization of diaphragmatic defects and herniated contents
- Assessment of associated injuries
Chest X-ray has limited utility—sensitivity only 2-60% for left-sided diaphragmatic hernia and can miss 11-62% of diaphragmatic injuries 2. However, it may show:
- Abnormal bowel gas pattern in chest
- Hemidiaphragm elevation
- Nasogastric tube in thorax (if herniated stomach present)
Point-of-Care Ultrasound (POCUS)
E-FAST can rapidly detect free intraperitoneal fluid with 98% sensitivity and 100% specificity 8, useful for:
- Bedside assessment in unstable patients
- Detecting hemoperitoneum before CT
- Guiding need for emergent surgery
However, ultrasound has limitations in obese patients and with subcutaneous emphysema 8.
Advanced Imaging
For diaphragmatic dysfunction evaluation (non-acute setting):
- Fluoroscopy provides accurate assessment of diaphragm motion 9, 10
- Ultrasound can evaluate diaphragmatic excursion, thickness, and paradoxical movement with high sensitivity/specificity 10
Management Approach
Hemodynamically Unstable Patients
Immediate laparotomy is indicated 2. Don't delay for imaging if patient is decompensating.
Hemodynamically Stable Patients
- Urgent CT scan to identify source
- For splenic injury: Consider angiography with embolization if no active extravasation 6
- For diaphragmatic hernia:
Surgical Considerations
- Complete abdominal survey mandatory: During laparoscopy, systematically examine entire abdomen including diaphragm surface—incomplete surveys miss the diagnosis 11
- Mesh repair for large diaphragmatic defects that cannot be primarily closed 2
- Damage control surgery if patient develops intraoperative instability, hypothermia, or coagulopathy 2
Special Populations
Women of reproductive age: Always obtain β-hCG to exclude ectopic pregnancy, which can implant on the diaphragm and present with Kehr's sign 11
Post-procedural patients: Consider iatrogenic splenic injury after colonoscopy or other abdominal procedures, even days later 4
Infectious mononucleosis: EBV can cause spontaneous splenic rupture in <0.5% of cases, presenting with non-specific symptoms including neck/shoulder pain 6
Key Takeaway
The presence of Kehr's sign is a red flag requiring urgent imaging—do not be reassured by normal vital signs, lack of abdominal tenderness, or atypical pain location. CT scan is essential for diagnosis, and surgical consultation should be obtained immediately while imaging is being arranged. 1, 2, 3, 4