Concussion Assessment
Use the SCAT5 (or Child SCAT5 for children) as your primary multimodal assessment tool for suspected concussion, as this is the standardized evaluation recommended by the Concussion in Sport Group and incorporates the most critical domains of function. 1
Core Assessment Framework
The SCAT5 provides a comprehensive, no-cost standardized approach that integrates multiple functional domains into a single tool:
- Symptom checklist (the most sensitive indicator of concussion) 1
- Brief neurological examination
- Cognitive assessment using the Standardized Assessment of Concussion (SAC) with immediate/delayed memory and digit sequencing
- Balance assessment via modified Balance Error Scoring System
- Cervical spine examination
Critical principle: Symptoms are the most sensitive indicator of concussion—any athlete experiencing symptom increase after suspected concussion must be removed from play immediately. 1
Age-Specific Tool Selection
- Athletes >13 years: SCAT5
- Children ages 8-12: Child SCAT5
- Children ages 5-9: Consider VOMS-Child (VOMS-C) with binary symptom reporting 2
The multimodal approach significantly increases diagnostic sensitivity and specificity compared to single-domain testing. 1
Office/Follow-up Assessment
When evaluating beyond the acute sideline setting (3+ days post-injury), expand your assessment to include:
Vestibular-Ocular Motor Screening (VOMS)
Use this tool for athletes >10 years old to assess:
- Smooth pursuits
- Saccades
- Vestibular ocular reflex
- Vestibular motion sensitivity
- Convergence distance
Rationale: 67-77% of concussions involve vestibular symptoms and 45% have ocular impairment. 1 The VOMS provides standardized, no-cost evaluation of these frequently affected domains.
Additional Office Assessments
- Cervical spine evaluation (complete range of motion, Spurling maneuver, palpation for tenderness)
- Mental health screening for anxiety/mood disorders
- Computerized neurocognitive testing (if baseline available)
- Sleep disturbance assessment
Important Caveats
Timing matters: Neurocognitive and balance assessments lose diagnostic utility as early as 3 days post-injury, while symptom checklists remain useful for tracking trajectory. 1
Learning effects: Many concussion tests have practice effects that must be factored into interpretation with repeated administration. Baseline testing improves accuracy but isn't always available. 1
Test limitations: Individual sideline assessment tools have suboptimal test-retest reliability (below 0.75-0.90 threshold) and imperfect sensitivity/specificity. This is why combining multiple domains is essential. 1
Serial reassessment: Concussion is an evolving injury—repeat evaluation is necessary when diagnosis is uncertain or symptoms change. 1
Diagnostic Confirmation
To confirm concussion diagnosis, you need:
- Clear mechanism consistent with concussion
- Characteristic signs, symptoms, and time course
- No alternative explanation for clinical findings
Common pitfall: Symptoms may normalize by the time of office visit. When this occurs, focus on return-to-school and return-to-sport guidance rather than attempting to "prove" the diagnosis retrospectively. 1
Exclude Alternative Pathologies
Always consider and evaluate for:
- Cervicogenic pain
- Primary headache/migraine disorder
- Mood disorders
- Peripheral vestibular conditions
These may either cause symptoms mimicking concussion or represent pre-existing conditions unmasked by the injury. 1