Dorsal Approach to the Distal Radius
The dorsal approach to the distal radius is specifically indicated for dorsally displaced, comminuted intra-articular fractures with dorsal impaction or die-punch fragments where direct visualization of the articular surface is essential for anatomic reduction. While volar plating has become the predominant technique for most distal radius fractures, the dorsal approach remains a valuable option for select fracture patterns that cannot be adequately visualized or reduced from a volar approach 1, 2.
Indications for Dorsal Approach
The dorsal approach should be considered in the following specific scenarios:
- Dorsally displaced articular fragments with impaction requiring direct visualization for anatomic reduction 2
- Dorsal die-punch fragments that cannot be adequately reduced or buttressed from a volar approach 3
- Dorsally comminuted intra-articular fractures (AO Type 23C3) where the fracture line extends distal to the watershed line 4
- Dorsal shear fractures requiring direct buttress support 1
Surgical Technique
Patient Positioning and Incision
- Position the patient supine with the arm on a hand table
- Make a longitudinal dorsal incision centered over Lister's tubercle
- Identify and protect the extensor pollicis longus (EPL) tendon, retracting it radially
Exposure and Reduction
- Elevate the extensor retinaculum as a radially-based flap to preserve soft tissue coverage
- Perform a dorsal mini-arthrotomy through the third extensor compartment for direct visualization of the articular surface 5
- The arthrotomy allows direct assessment of articular congruency and reduction quality
- Elevate impacted dorsal fragments under direct vision
- Use bone graft or substitute to support elevated articular fragments
Fixation Strategy
Two main fixation patterns exist based on fracture morphology 3:
Type 1 (H-framed technique): For fractures with a volar fracture line distal to the watershed line in the dorsally displaced fragment, use dual dorsal locking plates in an H-frame configuration
Type 2 (Combined technique): For dorsal die-punch fragments with minimally displaced styloid shearing or transverse volar fractures, stabilize the volar segment first with cannulated screws from the radial styloid, then apply a small L-shaped dorsal locking plate for buttress effect on the die-punch fragment
Modern Low-Profile Plating
- Use 2.4mm low-profile locking plates to minimize extensor tendon irritation 4
- Ensure meticulous soft tissue coverage over hardware
- The extensor retinaculum should be carefully repaired over the plate
Outcomes and Complications
Expected Functional Results
Studies demonstrate good to excellent outcomes with the dorsal approach 3, 4:
- Range of motion typically achieves 80-85% of the contralateral side
- Palmar flexion: 50-65°, dorsiflexion: 70-75°
- Grip strength averages 30kg
- Near-full, painless range of motion at 1 year 1
Complication Profile
Critical caveat: The dorsal approach has a higher rate of hardware removal compared to volar plating, though this has decreased with modern low-profile implants 1, 4:
- Plate removal due to discomfort: Occurs in approximately 50% of cases (13/26 patients in one series) 4
- Tendon irritation: Common but no tendon ruptures reported with low-profile plates 4
- Early symptomatic osteoarthritis: Reported in approximately 15% of cases 4
- Neuropathic complications: Low rate compared to other approaches 1
Radiographic Outcomes
- Mean radial sagittal tilt: +6° postoperatively 4
- No plate movement or intra-articular screw penetration when technique performed correctly 4
Comparison to Volar Plating
Important consideration: The 2022 AAOS/ASSH guidelines provide strong evidence that no difference exists in long-term outcomes between fixation techniques for complete articular or unstable distal radius fractures, though volar locked plating leads to earlier functional recovery in the short term (3 months) 6. However, these guidelines do not specifically address dorsally impacted fracture patterns where direct visualization is critical.
The dorsal approach offers specific advantages for complex dorsal fractures 5, 2:
- Direct visualization prevents incongruent joint reconstruction
- All cases of insufficient joint surface restoration in one study occurred in the non-arthrotomy group 5
- Provides reliable buttress support for dorsally unstable fragments
Postoperative Management
- Early mobilization is possible with stable plate fixation
- Short-term splinting (1 week) for pain relief
- Active finger range of motion should begin immediately
- Weightbearing restrictions until fracture healing confirmed
- Close monitoring for hardware irritation requiring removal
Key Clinical Pitfall
The most common pitfall is attempting to reduce dorsally impacted articular fragments through a volar approach alone. This frequently results in inadequate articular congruency that may not be apparent on fluoroscopy. When dorsal comminution or impaction is present, direct visualization through a dorsal approach with arthrotomy provides superior control of reduction quality 5, 2.