What are the best numbing drops for corneal abrasions?

Topical Anesthetics for Corneal Abrasions: Recommendations and Management

For corneal abrasions, topical anesthetics should not be prescribed for outpatient use due to risks of delayed healing, potential toxicity, and increased risk of complications. 1

Appropriate Use of Topical Anesthetics

Topical anesthetics like proparacaine 0.5% or tetracaine 0.5% are valuable for diagnostic purposes in the clinical setting but should be limited to in-office use only. These medications provide immediate pain relief but have several important limitations:

In-Office Use Only

• Tetracaine 0.5%: One drop topically in the affected eye as needed for examination 2
• Proparacaine 0.5%: One or two drops prior to examination or foreign body removal 3

Risks of Outpatient Use

• Delayed corneal healing when used repeatedly 4
• Potential for epithelial toxicity
• Risk of masking worsening symptoms
• Possibility of patient overuse leading to corneal injury 1

Recommended Management for Corneal Abrasions

First-Line Treatment

1. Topical antibiotics to prevent secondary infection

   • Broad-spectrum fluoroquinolones (e.g., moxifloxacin 0.5% or gatifloxacin 0.3%) 5
   • Should be started within 24 hours of injury for best outcomes 6

2. Pain management

   • Oral analgesics (NSAIDs or acetaminophen)
   • Consider topical NSAIDs if appropriate

Adjunctive Measures

• Cycloplegic agents to reduce pain from ciliary spasm and prevent synechiae formation when anterior chamber inflammation is present 6, 5
• Ocular lubricants (preservative-free) every 2 hours to promote comfort 5

Special Considerations

• Avoid patching in contact lens wearers due to increased risk of bacterial keratitis 6
• Bandage contact lenses may be considered for large abrasions but remain controversial due to infection risk 6
• Daily follow-up is necessary during the acute phase to assess healing 5

Evidence-Based Rationale

While a 2014 study suggested that controlled use of tetracaine for 24 hours might be safe 7, more recent evidence and guidelines consistently advise against outpatient use of topical anesthetics. The American Academy of Ophthalmology's Preferred Practice Patterns emphasize the risks of delayed healing and potential complications 6.

A 2022 study demonstrated that both regular (0.5%) and diluted (0.05%) proparacaine impede corneal wound healing, with effects worsened when combined with antibiotics 4. Additionally, a 2024 case series documented complications from proparacaine overuse in patients discharged from emergency departments 1.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• Prescribing topical anesthetics for home use
• Failing to provide appropriate antibiotic coverage
• Patching contact lens wearers
• Not addressing pain adequately through alternative methods
• Neglecting to schedule appropriate follow-up

By following these evidence-based recommendations, clinicians can effectively manage corneal abrasions while minimizing risks of complications and promoting optimal healing.