Physical Examination for Atraumatic Shoulder Pain
A comprehensive physical examination for atraumatic shoulder pain should include inspection, palpation, range of motion assessment, strength testing, and specific provocative tests to identify the underlying pathology.
Initial Assessment
Inspection
- Observe for:
- Shoulder asymmetry
- Muscle atrophy (particularly deltoid, supraspinatus, infraspinatus)
- Scapular winging
- Abnormal posture or positioning
- Skin changes or discoloration
Palpation
- Systematically palpate:
- Acromioclavicular (AC) joint
- Sternoclavicular joint
- Bicipital groove
- Greater and lesser tuberosities
- Subacromial space
- Posterior capsule
- Note areas of tenderness, swelling, or crepitus
Range of Motion Assessment
Active Range of Motion
- Forward flexion (0-180°)
- Abduction (0-180°)
- External rotation with arm at side (0-90°)
- Internal rotation (measured by highest vertebral level reached by thumb)
- Cross-body adduction
- Extension
Passive Range of Motion
- Compare to active ROM to identify pain limitations versus mechanical restrictions
- Note any painful arcs of motion (typically 60-120° in impingement)
Strength Testing
- Test the following muscle groups:
- Supraspinatus (empty can test)
- Infraspinatus/teres minor (external rotation)
- Subscapularis (lift-off test, belly press)
- Deltoid
- Biceps
- Trapezius and rhomboids
Special Tests
Rotator Cuff Tests
- Neer Impingement Test: Forward flexion of the arm with scapula stabilized
- Hawkins-Kennedy Test: Forward flexion to 90° and internal rotation
- Empty Can Test (Jobe Test): Arm at 90° abduction, 30° forward flexion, and internal rotation
- Full Can Test: Similar to empty can but with thumb up
- External Rotation Lag Sign: Test for infraspinatus tear
- Lift-off Test and Belly Press: Tests for subscapularis function
- Drop Arm Test: Test for rotator cuff integrity
Instability Tests
- Apprehension Test: Abduction and external rotation to test anterior instability
- Relocation Test: Posterior pressure on humeral head during apprehension test
- Sulcus Sign: Downward traction on arm to assess inferior instability
- Load and Shift Test: Assessment of anterior/posterior translation
- Posterior Stress Test: Forward flexion, adduction, and internal rotation
Labral Tests
- O'Brien's Active Compression Test: Arm forward flexed to 90°, adducted 10-15°, and internally rotated
- Crank Test: Arm in 90° abduction with axial load and rotation
- Clunk Test: Circumduction of the arm with compression
- Biceps Load Test: Elbow flexion against resistance with shoulder in apprehension position
Biceps Tests
- Speed's Test: Forward flexion against resistance with supinated forearm
- Yergason's Test: Supination against resistance with elbow flexed at 90°
Neurovascular Assessment
- Test sensation in all dermatomes (C5-T1)
- Test reflexes (biceps, triceps)
- Assess distal pulses and capillary refill
- Perform Spurling's test to rule out cervical pathology
Scapular Assessment
- Observe scapular motion during arm elevation
- Scapular assistance test
- Scapular retraction test
Documentation and Interpretation
After completing these tests, document:
- Which tests were positive
- Pattern of pain and limitations
- Most likely diagnosis based on constellation of findings
The American College of Radiology recommends that the physical examination should guide subsequent imaging decisions, with radiography as the initial imaging modality for most shoulder complaints 1.
Common Diagnostic Patterns
- Rotator cuff pathology: Positive impingement signs, weakness in specific muscle testing, painful arc
- Instability: Positive apprehension, relocation, and load-shift tests
- Labral tears: Positive O'Brien's, clunk, or crank tests
- Biceps pathology: Positive Speed's and Yergason's tests with bicipital groove tenderness
- AC joint pathology: Pain with cross-body adduction, point tenderness at AC joint
Remember that no single test is perfectly sensitive or specific, so clinical diagnosis should be based on a combination of history, physical examination findings, and appropriate imaging when necessary.