Japanese Encephalitis Vaccine Does Not Provide Cross-Protection Against Severe Dengue
The Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV) vaccine does not provide reliable cross-protection against severe dengue and should not be used for this purpose. While both JEV and dengue virus belong to the same flavivirus family, current evidence does not support using JEV vaccination as a strategy to prevent severe dengue disease.
Evidence on Cross-Protection
Antibody Cross-Reactivity Without Protection
- Studies examining cross-protection between related flaviviruses show that JEV vaccination does not induce sufficient protective neutralizing antibodies against dengue virus 1.
- Despite successful immunization against JEV, protective neutralizing antibody titers to related flaviviruses like West Nile virus were not detected in vaccinated individuals 1.
Potential Risks of Cross-Reactivity
- JEV vaccines can actually induce cross-reactive antibodies against dengue virus that may contribute to antibody-dependent enhancement (ADE) of dengue infection 2.
- Research indicates that JEV vaccination might potentially increase the risk of symptomatic dengue through these cross-reactive ADE-prone antibodies 2.
Immunological Considerations
T-Cell Responses
- T-cell responses to JEV in healthy JEV-exposed individuals differ significantly from those in recovered JE patients, with different targeting patterns and degrees of cross-reactivity to dengue virus 3.
- While some T-cell cross-reactivity exists between JEV and dengue virus, the clinical significance for protection against severe dengue remains unproven 3.
Experimental Evidence
- Although some laboratory studies in mice have shown that JEV prM-E antigen immunization might confer some protection against dengue virus challenge 4, these findings have not translated to demonstrated clinical protection in humans.
- Recent research has focused on modifying JEV vaccines to reduce cross-reactive antibodies that could potentially enhance dengue infection 2.
Clinical Recommendations
For protection against dengue:
- Use dengue-specific vaccines when indicated
- Employ mosquito bite prevention strategies as recommended by the CDC 5
- Consider appropriate personal protective measures including:
- Using DEET-based repellents on exposed skin
- Wearing long-sleeved clothing
- Using bed nets in accommodations without screens or air conditioning
For protection against JEV:
Conclusion
While both JEV and dengue are flaviviruses with some antigenic similarities, the JEV vaccine has not been demonstrated to provide clinically meaningful protection against severe dengue. Current evidence suggests that cross-reactive antibodies induced by JEV vaccination might potentially increase dengue risk through antibody-dependent enhancement. For protection against dengue, dengue-specific vaccines and mosquito prevention measures remain the appropriate strategies.