Is a left knee open osteochondral allograft (Bio-Uni) to the lateral femoral condyle medically necessary for a patient with a focal, full-thickness cartilage lesion and disabling knee pain?

Medical Necessity Determination for Left Knee Osteochondral Allograft

Direct Answer

The osteochondral allograft is NOT medically necessary at this time because three critical mandatory prerequisites have not been met, despite the patient meeting several important anatomic and demographic criteria. 1

---

Critical Missing Requirements

1. Inadequate Documentation of Supervised Physical Therapy

• The patient must complete and document at least 6 weeks of supervised, in-person physical therapy with objective documentation of compliance and failure to achieve adequate symptom relief before osteochondral allograft can be considered medically necessary. 1
• The current documentation only mentions "Home exercises for Range of Motion and Conditioning" starting in January 2025, which does not meet the requirement for supervised, in-person physical therapy as opposed to home or virtual therapy. 1
• This is a non-negotiable prerequisite that must be satisfied before proceeding with this surgery. 1

2. Meniscal Deficiency Without Documented Plan for Concurrent Treatment

• The MRI shows "very little lateral meniscal tissue remaining" from the previous partial lateral meniscectomy, which creates a contraindication for isolated osteochondral allograft. 1
• A stable knee with intact meniscus is required to ensure normal weight distribution within the joint and prevent graft failure due to abnormal load distribution. 1
• The patient likely requires concurrent meniscal allograft transplantation at the time of osteochondral allograft to address this deficiency. 1, 2
• Concomitant procedures are commonly performed with osteochondral allografts when meniscal deficiency exists, as symptomatic full-thickness chondral defects are often associated with meniscal deficiencies. 2

3. Insufficient Documentation of Tibial Plateau Status

• Definitive imaging assessment of the tibial plateau is necessary to confirm the opposing articular surface is free of significant disease or injury. 1
• The opposing articular surface (tibial plateau) should be generally free of disease or injury, including no arthritis on the corresponding tibial surface. 1
• Current documentation does not clearly establish that the tibial plateau is healthy and free of arthritis, which is essential for graft success. 1

---

Criteria That ARE Met

Favorable Patient and Lesion Characteristics

• The patient is 34 years old, which falls within the acceptable age range (≤50 years) for osteochondral allograft. 1, 3
• The defect size of 8 cm² (2 x 4 cm) is appropriate for osteochondral allograft, as lesions ≥2 cm² are indicated for this procedure. 1, 4
• The lesion is full-thickness (grade III or IV) on the weight-bearing surface of the lateral femoral condyle, which is the correct anatomic location. 1
• The knee is stable with negative Lachman, anterior drawer, posterior drawer, and pivot shift tests, indicating successful prior ACL reconstruction. 1
• Knee alignment appears normal based on X-ray findings, with no acute bony abnormalities. 1

---

Treatment Algorithm for This Patient

Step 1: Complete Mandatory Conservative Treatment

• Refer the patient for 6 weeks of supervised, in-person physical therapy with a licensed physical therapist. 1
• Document objective measures of compliance, attendance, and symptom response throughout the therapy course. 1
• If symptoms remain disabling after documented completion of this therapy, proceed to Step 2. 1

Step 2: Obtain Definitive Imaging Assessment

• Order dedicated MRI sequences or obtain radiologist interpretation specifically addressing the tibial plateau cartilage status. 1
• Confirm the opposing tibial surface is free of significant arthritis or cartilage damage. 1
• If bipolar lesions (both femoral and tibial involvement) are present, isolated osteochondral allograft is contraindicated. 1

Step 3: Address Meniscal Deficiency

• Given the "very little lateral meniscal tissue remaining," plan for concurrent lateral meniscal allograft transplantation at the time of osteochondral allograft. 1, 2
• This combined procedure is well-established for patients with both meniscal deficiency and chondral defects. 2
• The bone slot technique for meniscal allograft can be performed through the same surgical approach. 2

Step 4: Proceed with Combined Procedure

• Once all three prerequisites are met and documented, the patient would be an excellent candidate for combined osteochondral allograft and meniscal allograft transplantation. 1, 2

---

Clinical Pearls and Common Pitfalls

Why These Prerequisites Matter

• Patients younger than 30 years with traumatic lesions treated within 12 months of symptom onset have the best outcomes, but this patient's chronic symptoms (since 2018) make proper patient selection even more critical. 3
• Survivorship of osteochondral allografts is 95.6% at 5 years and 91.2% at 10 years when proper selection criteria are followed. 5
• Without adequate meniscal tissue, abnormal load distribution will likely lead to premature graft failure. 1

Avoiding Common Errors

• Do not proceed with isolated osteochondral allograft in the setting of meniscal deficiency—this is a setup for failure. 1
• Home exercises do not substitute for supervised physical therapy in meeting medical necessity criteria. 1
• Failure to document tibial plateau status leaves uncertainty about whether this is a unipolar versus bipolar lesion, which fundamentally changes the treatment approach. 1

Expected Outcomes When Criteria Are Met

• When proper selection criteria are followed, 89% of patients report satisfaction, with clinically meaningful improvement in pain, function, and quality of life. 5
• Return to sport rates are as high as 88% with an average time of 9.6 months. 4
• Overall failure rate is approximately 25% at 12 years, with 72% of failures being conversion to total knee arthroplasty or unicompartmental knee arthroplasty. 3