From the Guidelines
The ice pack test improves ptosis in patients with myasthenia gravis because it slows the breakdown of acetylcholine at the neuromuscular junction, temporarily increasing available acetylcholine and improving muscle function. This is based on the most recent and highest quality study available, which suggests that the ice pack test is highly specific to myasthenia gravis and can demonstrate a reduction of ptosis of about 2 mm 1.
Mechanism of Action
The mechanism behind the ice pack test's effectiveness in improving ptosis is thought to relate to diminished anticholinesterase activity, which is the breakdown of acetylcholine by the enzyme acetylcholinesterase 1. By inhibiting this enzyme, the cold temperature from the ice pack increases the availability of acetylcholine at the neuromuscular junction, allowing for improved muscle stimulation and function.
Diagnostic Utility
The ice pack test is a simple, non-invasive diagnostic tool that can help differentiate myasthenia gravis from other causes of ptosis. A positive test, defined as at least a 2mm improvement in eyelid position after ice application, is highly suggestive of myasthenia gravis 1. Other conditions, such as oculomotor nerve palsy or mechanical ptosis, typically do not respond to the ice pack test, making it a useful diagnostic aid.
Clinical Application
In clinical practice, the ice pack test can be easily performed by applying an ice pack over the closed eyes for 2 minutes in the case of ptosis 1. The test's temporary effect, lasting only while the tissue remains cooled, does not provide a long-term solution but serves as a valuable diagnostic tool to guide further management and treatment of myasthenia gravis.
From the Research
Ptosis Improvement with Ice Pack Test
- The ice pack test is a simple and effective method to diagnose myasthenic ptosis, as shown in a study published in 1999 2.
- The test involves applying an ice pack to the ptotic eyelid for a few minutes, and if the ptosis improves by 2 mm or more, the result is considered positive.
- A study from 2000 found that the improvement in ptosis after the ice pack test is not due to the cold temperature itself, but rather the rest provided to the eye muscles 3.
- The ice pack test has been compared to other diagnostic methods, such as single-fiber EMG, and has shown similar diagnostic accuracy in patients with ocular myasthenia 4.
- However, a case report from 2021 suggests that the ice pack test can also be positive in non-myasthenic ptosis, such as neurogenic ptosis caused by a possible oculomotor nerve schwannoma 5.
Mechanism of Ptosis Improvement
- The exact mechanism of ptosis improvement with the ice pack test is not fully understood, but it is thought to be related to the rest provided to the eye muscles, rather than the cold temperature itself 3.
- The test may help to differentiate myasthenic ptosis from other types of ptosis, but its usefulness in other disorders associated with muscle weakness and fatigability is still questionable 5.
Diagnostic Accuracy
- The ice pack test has been shown to have a sensitivity of 86% and a specificity of 79% in diagnosing ocular myasthenia 4.
- The combination of the ice pack test and single-fiber EMG can increase the sensitivity to 98%, but may reduce the specificity to 66% 4.
- The negativity of both tests can strongly suggest another diagnosis, with a negative predictive value of 94% 4.