What are the indications, contraindications, procedure, and potential side effects of epidural anesthesia?

Epidural Anesthesia: Comprehensive Clinical Guide

Indications

Epidural anesthesia is primarily indicated for major open abdominal surgery (particularly upper abdominal procedures), thoracic surgery, and cesarean section, where it provides superior pain relief and reduces specific complications compared to systemic opioids. 1

Specific Surgical Indications:

• Major open abdominal surgery including pancreaticoduodenectomy (Whipple procedure), colorectal resection, and abdominal aortic aneurysm repair 1
• Elective cesarean section under neuraxial anesthesia 1
• Traumatic rib fractures for pain management 1
• Thoracic surgery requiring thoracotomy 2
• High-risk patients with defined comorbidities undergoing major surgery 3, 4

Clinical Benefits Supporting Use:

• Reduces postoperative pneumonia by approximately 40% 4
• Decreases cardiac morbidity by approximately 30% 4
• Reduces pulmonary embolism by approximately 50% 4
• Shortens duration of postoperative ileus by approximately 2 days 5, 4
• Provides superior analgesia compared to systemic opioids for 72 hours postoperatively 1, 3

---

Contraindications

Absolute Contraindications:

• Patient refusal 6
• Coagulopathy or therapeutic anticoagulation (risk of epidural hematoma 0.02%) 7
• Infection at insertion site 6
• Severe hypovolemia or hemodynamic instability 6, 8
• Increased intracranial pressure 9

Relative Contraindications:

• Sepsis (risk of epidural abscess) 6
• Pre-existing neurological disease 7
• Spinal deformity making placement technically difficult 6
• Planned laparoscopic surgery (epidural may not be necessary) 1

Important Caveats:

• Elderly patients (>60 years) should not receive long-acting benzodiazepines for anxiolysis before epidural insertion due to risk of postoperative delirium 1
• Short-acting benzodiazepines may be used in younger patients to facilitate positioning 1

---

Procedure and Technical Considerations

Catheter Placement:

For upper abdominal incisions, the epidural catheter must be inserted between T5-T8 vertebral levels to adequately cover surgical dermatomes. 1, 6, 10

• Mid-thoracic placement (T7-T10) is optimal for open abdominal surgery including pancreaticoduodenectomy 10
• Lumbar placement is associated with higher risk of neurologic deficits 7
• Insertion level must match the surgical incision site; failure to do so is a common cause of inadequate analgesia 6, 10

Pre-Procedure Verification:

• Test sensory block with cold and pinprick before induction of general anesthesia 1, 6, 10
• Verify catheter placement is in epidural space 1
• Confirm adequate dermatomal coverage 6, 10

Medication Regimen:

• Local anesthetic: Long-acting agents (bupivacaine or ropivacaine) administered as bolus or continuous infusion 1, 10, 8
• Opioid adjunct: Low-dose fentanyl or morphine combined with local anesthetic provides optimal analgesia 10
• Typical concentrations: 0.125% to 1% for ropivacaine; 0.25% to 0.75% for bupivacaine 8

Postoperative Management:

• Check sensory block daily (or more frequently) and adjust infusion to provide sufficient analgesia for mobilization 1, 6, 10
• Continue epidural for 48-72 hours postoperatively 1, 6, 10
• After successful discontinuation, transition to oral multimodal analgesia with paracetamol, NSAIDs/COX-2 inhibitors, and oral opioids as needed 1, 10

---

Side Effects and Complications

Common Side Effects (Incidence ≥5%):

• Hypotension (32-55%) - most common, dose and level dependent 8, 9, 7
• Nausea (17-29%) 8, 3
• Vomiting (7-15%) 8
• Bradycardia (6-19%) 8
• Urinary retention 8, 9
• Pruritus (4-5%) 8
• Back pain (4-16%) 8

Serious Complications (Rare):

• Epidural hematoma (0.02%) - potentially devastating but extremely rare 7
• Post-operative neurologic deficits (1.12%) - most resolve spontaneously within 3 months 7
• Permanent neurologic sequelae (0.02%) - unilateral lower limb paresthesia 7
• Post-dural puncture headache (0.14%) 7
• Systemic local anesthetic toxicity (0.08%) - can cause seizures, cardiovascular collapse 8, 9, 7
• High or total spinal block - respiratory paralysis, loss of consciousness 9
• Meningitis, epidural abscess - rare infectious complications 9

Cardiovascular Effects:

High dermatomal levels can cause significant hypotension through sympathetic blockade and may compromise cardiac output. 6, 8, 9

• Treat hypotension with vasopressors rather than excessive fluid administration to avoid fluid overload that could compromise anastomotic healing 10
• Risk of bradycardia and cardiac arrhythmias with high plasma levels 9
• Ventricular tachycardia and fibrillation possible with unintentional intravascular injection 9

Central Nervous System Effects:

• Drowsiness, confusion, tremor 9
• Seizures with high plasma levels or intravascular injection 9
• Respiratory depression progressing to apnea 9

Risk Factors for Neurologic Deficits:

• ASA status II-III 7
• Lumbar (vs. thoracic) insertion 7
• Orthopedic and urologic surgery 7
• Multiple insertion attempts 7
• Paresthesia during insertion 7
• History of previous neuraxial anesthesia 7
• Use of patient-controlled epidural analgesia 7

---

Technical Failure Rates and Management

Up to one-third of epidurals may fail to function satisfactorily in some centers. 1, 6, 10

Common Causes of Failure:

• Catheter not located in epidural space 1
• Insertion level does not cover surgical incision 1, 6
• Inadequate dosage of local anesthetic and opioid 1
• Pump failure 1, 6

Prevention Strategies:

• Test sensory block before surgery 1, 6, 10
• Regular assessment of block effectiveness 1, 6, 10
• Adjust infusion rates based on pain scores and ability to mobilize 1, 10
• Have backup analgesic plan ready 6

---

Alternative Techniques When Epidural Not Feasible

When epidural is contraindicated or not feasible, intravenous lidocaine infusion can be administered for open abdominal surgery. 1

• Dosing: 1.5 mg/kg at induction followed by 2 mg/kg/h continuous infusion during surgery 1
• Provides anti-inflammatory and opioid-sparing properties 1
• Do not use simultaneously with regional anesthesia techniques 1

Other Alternatives:

• Spinal anesthesia with local anesthetics and opioids for colorectal resection 1
• Transversus abdominis plane (TAP) blocks for cesarean section when intrathecal morphine not used 1
• Quadratus lumborum blocks for cesarean section 1
• Patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) with opioids 1

---

Evidence Quality and Changing Perspectives

Recent evidence suggests epidural analgesia may no longer be the universal "gold standard" for all postoperative pain management. 2

Benefits Are Limited To:

• High-risk patients undergoing major abdominal or thoracic surgery 2
• Thoracic epidural with local anesthetic drugs only (not opioids) 2
• Open (not laparoscopic) procedures 1, 2

Key Research Findings:

• Large RCT (n=915) showed epidural reduced only respiratory failure (23% vs 30%), not overall morbidity or mortality 3
• Less invasive regional techniques (paravertebral blocks, femoral blocks, wound catheters) may be equally effective for specific procedures 2
• Decision to use epidural should be guided by institutional audits and careful risk-benefit assessment 2

Not Recommended For:

• Laparoscopic pancreatic resections 1
• Medical ICU patients (insufficient evidence) 1
• Routine postoperative analgesia without specific high-risk indications 2

---

Monitoring Requirements

• Continuous vital sign monitoring during epidural placement and initial dosing 6
• Regular pain score assessment using validated scales 1
• Daily sensory block testing with cold/pinprick 1, 6, 10
• Respiratory rate monitoring especially when opioids added to local anesthetic 1
• Blood glucose monitoring during surgery (keep <10 mmol/L) 1
• Neurologic examination for early detection of complications 7