Guidelines for Pre and Perioperative Evaluation of Geriatric Patients
Core Recommendation
All geriatric patients aged 65 years and older undergoing surgery must receive a validated, multidimensional frailty assessment during preoperative evaluation, followed by comprehensive geriatric assessment (CGA) for those who screen positive, with early multidisciplinary team involvement throughout the perioperative period. 1
Preoperative Assessment Framework
Mandatory Frailty Screening
- Perform frailty screening on all patients ≥65 years as part of routine preoperative functional status evaluation 1
- Use validated multidimensional frailty instruments (not single-domain tools) for assessment 1
- Frailty assessment provides unique prognostic information beyond traditional risk stratification and is feasible in clinical practice 1
Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (CGA)
Trigger CGA for any positive frailty screen 1
The CGA must evaluate these specific domains 1, 2:
- Cognitive function: Screen for baseline impairment and delirium risk using validated tools (Montreal Cognitive Assessment recommended) 1, 3
- Functional status: Assess activities of daily living (ADLs) and instrumental ADLs using standardized scales (Nottingham Extended Activities of Daily Living) 1, 3
- Nutritional status: Evaluate for malnutrition, provide supplementation at least 28 days before elective surgery for nutritional deficiencies (iron, vitamin B12, folate) 1
- Polypharmacy: Optimize medications using the START/STOPP tool 1
- Comorbidity burden: Assess and optimize organ-specific conditions (diabetes, cardiorespiratory disease, anemia) 1
- Sarcopenia: Evaluate muscle mass, strength, and function as precursor to frailty 2
- Social support: Identify caregivers and establish decision-making capacity 1, 2
Risk Stratification Beyond ASA Classification
- Do not rely solely on ASA Physical Status classification for geriatric patients, as it does not predict 6-month mortality in older adults 4
- CGA deficit scores are strongly associated with postoperative mortality, while ASA classification is not 4
- Emergency surgery carries significantly higher risk than elective procedures in older adults 1, 2
Specific Assessment Tools
Validated Instruments to Use
- Frailty assessment: Multidimensional validated scales (specific tool selection based on institutional capacity) 1
- Cognitive screening: Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) 3
- Functional assessment: Nottingham Extended Activities of Daily Living scale 3
- Frailty quantification: Edmonton Frail Scale 3
- Hip fracture patients: Nottingham Hip Fracture Score 1
- Medication optimization: START/STOPP criteria 1
Delirium Risk Assessment
Begin delirium risk stratification preoperatively 1
High-risk features include:
- Advanced age (very old)
- Frailty
- Cognitive impairment
- Cerebrovascular disease
- Multimorbidity/polypharmacy 1
Communicate identified risk throughout the multidisciplinary team for multimodal preventive interventions 1
Preoperative Optimization
Critical Optimization Targets
Balance optimization against surgical delay - for hip fractures and emergency laparotomy, optimize simultaneously with surgery rather than consecutively 1
Focus on these specific interventions 1, 3:
Ischemia prevention:
- Reduce oxygen uptake: analgesia, thermoregulation, antibiotics
- Improve oxygen delivery: supplemental oxygen, fluid optimization, medication review
- Avoid hypotension and severe anemia 1
Medication management:
Nutritional optimization:
Functional optimization:
Diabetes management:
- Create individualized diabetic plan
- Consider pre-admission support
- Document plan on admission 1
Multidisciplinary Team Involvement
Engage multidisciplinary teams early in assessment and maintain daily communication throughout perioperative care 1
Team Composition and Roles
- Senior geriatrician and senior anesthetist with geriatric subspecialty training should assess higher-risk elderly patients 1
- Include physical therapists, occupational therapists, nurses, speech-language pathologists, dietitians, pharmacists as needed 5
- Involve family members/caregivers, especially for cognitive or mood concerns 5
Shared Decision-Making
Initiate shared decision-making upon contemplation of surgery 1
Discuss:
- Short- and long-term risks and benefits of the specific procedure
- Alternative procedures
- Conservative therapy (no surgery)
- Impact on remaining quantity and quality of life 2
- Postoperative support intensity and end-of-life care preferences 2
Establish early who will be involved in medical decision-making and provide support 1
Decision-Making Capacity and Legal Considerations
Capacity Assessment
- All personnel must be aware of duties under mental capacity laws 2
- Use the standard: "what a reasonable patient in the patient's circumstances might want to know" 2
- For patients without capacity, make decisions considering patient's known expectations, wishes, and family/caregiver input 2
Critical Illness Decisions
For critically ill patients, involve experienced surgeons, anesthetists, intensivists, geriatricians, and family members/caregivers in decisions about intervention degree and suitability 2
Mandatory Commitments
- Do not perform high-risk surgery without preoperative commitment to adequate postoperative care 2
- Ensure experienced personnel available at all times for anesthesia, surgery, and postoperative care organization 2
Intraoperative Management
Temperature Control
Maintain normothermia aggressively - perioperative hypothermia is common in older adults and associated with delirium, cardiac dysfunction, prolonged hospital stay, and poor wound healing 1, 2
Ensure mean arterial pressure (MAP) within 20% of preoperative baseline 1
Urinary Catheter Management
Limit urinary catheter use in patients with frailty (strong evidence) 1
Patient Dignity and Preparation
- Allow additional time for older adults to prepare for surgery 2
- Keep functional aids (glasses, hearing aids, dentures) in place until just before anesthesia induction 2
- Use strategies when moving/positioning to protect musculoskeletal and integumentary systems 1
Surgical Communication
Senior multidisciplinary communication about the surgical intervention is mandatory before and during surgery 2
Anesthetists should confirm:
- Exact proposed procedure
- Appropriateness for patient's pathophysiological state 2
Perioperative Analgesia
Individualize perioperative analgesia using validated pain assessment tools 1
- Involve multidisciplinary team in pain management
- Attempt to limit opioid and NSAID use 1
Postoperative Care
Enhanced Recovery Programs
Adhere to Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) protocols 1
Specific Monitoring Targets
- Hemoglobin levels: Maintain above approximately 90 g/L in older surgical patients with frailty 1
- Blood glucose: Target 7.8-10 mmol/L in diabetic patients with frailty, monitor associated complications 1
Sensory and Cognitive Support
Ensure appropriate aids and strategies throughout all perioperative phases for patients with physical, sensory, or cognitive impairments 1
Admission and Discharge Planning
Begin admission and discharge planning in the preoperative period through collaboration with various services involved in patient care 1
Emergency Surgery Considerations
Specific Actions
- Obtain collateral history from family/caregivers 1
- Be aware of atypical presentations in frail older adults 1
- Assess and manage hypothermia during ambulance transit 1
- Recognize that optimization and surgery must occur simultaneously, not consecutively 1
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Do not delay emergency surgery for optimization - this worsens outcomes in hip fractures and emergency laparotomy 1
- Do not rely on ASA classification alone - it fails to predict mortality in geriatric patients 4
- Do not over-investigate or extend polypharmacy unnecessarily when managing comorbidities 1
- Do not proceed with high-risk surgery without secured postoperative care commitment 2
- Do not use single-domain frailty tools - multidimensional validated instruments are required 1
Expected Intervention Burden
Based on CGA implementation data, expect 3:
- Median of 9 interventions per patient (range 0-28)
- Long-term medication changes in 75% of patients
- Lifestyle advice in 54% of patients
- Therapy interventions in 23% of patients
- Shared decision-making documentation in 99% of patients
- Individualized admission plans in 96% of patients
- 15% of patients may not proceed to surgery after CGA