What is the recommended approach for evaluating and treating a fistula?

Evaluating for a Fistula

Recommended Diagnostic Approach by Fistula Type

The evaluation strategy depends critically on the anatomic location and clinical context of the suspected fistula, as different fistula types require distinct imaging modalities and examination techniques.

---

Arteriovenous (Hemodialysis) Fistula Evaluation

Physical examination is the primary monitoring tool for AV fistula assessment and should be performed systematically at every dialysis session. 1

Physical Examination Technique

• Inspection: Assess vein diameter (must be ≥6 mm), depth (<6 mm from skin surface), and visible margins with tourniquet application 1
• Palpation: Confirm continuous thrill along the entire venous outflow tract; absence or significant decrease indicates stenosis requiring immediate referral 1
• Auscultation: Listen for continuous bruit; high-pitched sounds suggest stenosis 1
• Flow assessment: Mature fistulae require blood flow >600 mL/min for adequate dialysis 1

Timing of Evaluation

• Examine all newly created fistulae 4-6 weeks post-operatively by knowledgeable professionals to assess maturation 1
• Pre-dialysis examination is optimal as hypotension post-fluid removal confounds findings 1
• Apply the "Rule of 6s": evaluate for non-maturation if after 6 weeks the fistula fails to meet diameter, depth, and flow criteria 1

When to Escalate Beyond Physical Exam

• Immediate referral indications: Significant decrease in thrill, absent bruit, difficulty cannulating, or elevated venous pressures during dialysis 1
• Diagnostic testing: Reserved for cases with abnormal physical findings; includes duplex ultrasound for flow measurement and angiography for anatomic stenosis identification 1

Common Pitfall

Trained dialysis nurses demonstrate excellent accuracy in predicting fistula maturity through physical examination alone—do not over-rely on imaging for routine surveillance 1

---

Perianal/Crohn's Disease Fistula Evaluation

Contrast-enhanced pelvic MRI is the initial imaging procedure of choice for perianal fistula assessment, with examination under anesthesia (EUA) considered the gold standard when performed by experienced surgeons. 1

Initial Diagnostic Pathway

• MRI pelvis with IV contrast: Diagnostic accuracy 80-100% for fistula identification and classification 1
• Alternative if MRI unavailable: Endoscopic anorectal ultrasound (EUS) achieves 87% sensitivity, but only if rectal stenosis is excluded 1
• Mandatory proctosigmoidoscopy: Assess for concomitant rectosigmoid inflammation, which has prognostic and therapeutic implications 1

Classification Requirements

• Classify as "simple" (low, single tract, no abscess) versus "complex" (high, multiple tracts, abscess present, or rectal involvement) 1
• MRI and EUS are superior to clinical examination alone for accurate classification 1

When EUA is Required

• Mandatory for complex fistulae: Allows simultaneous drainage of associated abscesses (present in >66% of cases) and loose seton placement 1
• Timing consideration: Two prospective studies demonstrate that preoperative MRI reveals clinically relevant information that improves surgical outcomes and reduces recurrence rates—MRI should precede diagnostic EUA unless immediate sepsis drainage is needed 1

Monitoring Treatment Response

• Clinical assessment (decreased drainage) is usually sufficient for routine practice 1
• MRI or EUS combined with clinical assessment: Recommended to evaluate deep fistula tract healing, as fistulae may show external closure while retaining internal tracts 1
• Studies demonstrate imaging is superior to clinical evaluation alone for detecting residual abscesses before therapy cessation 1

Critical Caveat

Fistulography is not recommended and has a diminishing role 1

---

Vesicovaginal Fistula Evaluation

CT cystography is superior to conventional fluoroscopic cystography for confirming fistula healing after repair, and should be the primary imaging modality. 2

Diagnostic Imaging Hierarchy

• CT with IV contrast: Preferred initial modality with 76.5% sensitivity for fistula detection and 94.1% for defining etiology 2
• Technical enhancement: Place water-soluble contrast in the bladder retrograde (CT cystogram) or use delayed imaging after IV contrast for antegrade opacification 2
• MRI pelvis with IV contrast: Equally sensitive to CT with superior soft tissue resolution; particularly useful for complex anatomy, multiple tracts, or assessing active inflammation 2

When to Use Alternative Modalities

• Conventional fluoroscopic cystography: Only if CT unavailable or contraindicated; ACR guidelines state it is "generally not useful" and has been supplanted by CT at most institutions 2
• Vaginography: Consider if CT findings equivocal; demonstrates 79% sensitivity and 100% positive predictive value 2

Essential Pre-Imaging Preparation

• Obtain renal function tests (BUN, creatinine) before contrast-enhanced studies 3
• Use only water-soluble contrast agents; barium is contraindicated 2

Critical Pitfall

Do not rely on clinical examination alone to confirm healing—imaging is superior for detecting residual fistulous tracts 2

---

Enterocutaneous/Gastrointestinal Fistula Evaluation

Thorough physical examination identifying the external opening combined with endoscopy to visualize internal openings forms the diagnostic foundation, supplemented by cross-sectional imaging for complex cases. 4

Clinical Examination

• Inspection: Identify external skin opening location and drainage characteristics 4
• Anoscopy/endoscopy: Visualize internal openings and assess surrounding mucosa 4

Imaging Considerations

• CT with IV contrast: Useful for defining fistula anatomy and detecting associated abscesses 5
• Contrast studies: Have diminishing role but may help delineate tract anatomy in select cases 1

Special Monitoring for IBD-Related Fistulae

• Therapeutic drug monitoring: Recommended for patients on immunosuppressive or biologic therapies 3
• Anti-TNF trough levels and antidrug antibodies: Monitor in Crohn's disease patients with secondary loss of response 3

---

Key Principles Across All Fistula Types

• Physical examination remains foundational but should be supplemented with imaging when pathology is suspected or for treatment planning 1
• Imaging modality selection depends on anatomic location: MRI for perianal/pelvic, CT for vesicovaginal/intra-abdominal, physical exam for AV fistulae 1, 2
• Abscess detection is critical as presence mandates drainage before definitive fistula repair 1
• Experienced operator assessment significantly improves diagnostic accuracy across all modalities 1