What is the recommended treatment plan for a patient with a chronic T12 compression fracture, lumbar dextroscoliosis, and degenerative changes, including foraminal stenosis at L4-L5?

Treatment Plan for Chronic T12 Compression Fracture with Lumbar Degenerative Changes and Foraminal Stenosis

Conservative management is the primary treatment for this chronic T12 compression fracture without neurological compromise, while selective surgical decompression without fusion is recommended for the symptomatic foraminal stenosis at L4-L5, provided there is no documented spinal instability on flexion-extension radiographs. 1, 2

T12 Compression Fracture Management

Conservative Treatment Protocol

• Analgesic therapy with calcitonin (200 IU nasal spray or subcutaneous) provides clinically important pain reduction at 1-4 weeks for symptomatic osteoporotic compression fractures 3
• Bisphosphonate therapy (ibandronate) or strontium ranelate to prevent additional symptomatic fractures in patients with existing osteoporotic compression fractures 3
• Physical therapy focusing on paraspinal and abdominal muscle strengthening once acute pain subsides 4
• Bracing may be considered, though evidence is inconclusive for specific benefit 3

When to Consider Vertebral Augmentation

• Vertebroplasty may be considered if conservative management fails to provide adequate pain relief after 4-6 weeks, as it demonstrates faster improvement in pain scores and functional ability compared to conservative management alone 5, 6
• The 50% height loss is chronic and stable without significant edema or retropulsion, making urgent intervention unnecessary 6, 7

Critical Monitoring

• Assess for new neurological deficits, particularly delayed-onset radiculopathy from foraminal stenosis, which can occur after vertebral fractures 8
• Serial imaging is not routinely needed unless symptoms worsen or new neurological findings develop 6, 7

Lumbar Degenerative Changes and Foraminal Stenosis Management

L3 Retrolisthesis

• Conservative management first: supervised exercise programs focusing on core strengthening for at least 3-6 months 4
• The mild retrolisthesis without significant instability or neurological symptoms does not require surgical intervention 4
• Surgery should only be considered if conservative management fails and there are progressive neurological symptoms or documented instability on flexion-extension films 4

L3-L4 Foraminal Stenosis (Mild to Moderate Right-Sided)

• Conservative management with physical therapy, NSAIDs, and potentially epidural steroid injections if radicular symptoms are present 9, 7
• Decompression alone (foraminotomy) is appropriate if symptoms persist after 3-6 months of conservative treatment, as there is no documented instability or spondylolisthesis at this level 1, 2
• Fusion is NOT indicated at L3-L4 in the absence of deformity or instability, as it does not improve outcomes and increases surgical risk 1, 2

L4-L5 Foraminal Stenosis (Severe Left-Sided, Moderate Right-Sided)

This is the most clinically significant pathology requiring intervention if conservative management fails.

Conservative Management Requirements (3-6 months minimum)

• Formal supervised physical therapy for at least 6 weeks 2
• Trial of neuropathic pain medications (gabapentin or pregabalin) 2
• Epidural steroid injections targeting L4-L5 foraminal stenosis 9, 7
• NSAIDs and activity modification 9

Surgical Decision Algorithm

If conservative management fails:

1. Obtain flexion-extension radiographs to assess for dynamic instability 1, 2

2. If NO instability is documented:

   • Perform decompression alone (bilateral foraminotomy) 1, 2
   • Decompression alone provides 70% success rates in patients without instability 1
   • Fusion is NOT recommended as it increases operative time, blood loss, and complications without proven benefit 1, 2

3. If instability IS documented (>3-4mm translation or >10° angulation):

   • Perform decompression with instrumented fusion at L4-L5 only 1, 2
   • Pedicle screw fixation improves fusion success rates from 45% to 83% when instability is present 1
   • Class II evidence shows 96% good/excellent outcomes with decompression plus fusion versus 44% with decompression alone in patients with stenosis AND instability 1, 2

4. If extensive facetectomy (>50%) is required for adequate decompression:

   • Fusion is indicated to prevent iatrogenic instability, which occurs in approximately 38% of cases after extensive decompression 1

L5-S1 Foraminal Stenosis (Mild to Moderate Left-Sided)

• Conservative management as outlined above 9
• Surgical intervention at this level is unlikely to be necessary given the mild-moderate severity 1, 2
• If surgery is needed, decompression alone is appropriate unless instability is documented 1, 2

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do NOT perform fusion for isolated stenosis without documented instability on flexion-extension films, as this increases surgical risk without improving outcomes 1, 2
• Do NOT perform multi-level fusion unless each level independently meets criteria for instability or extensive decompression will create iatrogenic instability 1, 2
• Do NOT skip formal supervised physical therapy for at least 6 weeks before considering surgery, as this is a mandatory criterion for surgical candidacy 2
• Do NOT assume retrolisthesis equals instability - dynamic imaging is required to document true instability 4
• Only 9% of patients without preoperative instability develop delayed slippage after decompression alone, making prophylactic fusion inappropriate 1

Recommended Treatment Sequence

1. Immediate (0-6 weeks):

   • Calcitonin for T12 fracture pain 3
   • Bisphosphonate therapy initiation 3
   • Pain management with NSAIDs and neuropathic pain medications 2, 9

2. Short-term (6 weeks - 3 months):

   • Formal supervised physical therapy focusing on core strengthening 2, 4
   • Epidural steroid injections for L4-L5 radicular symptoms if present 9, 7
   • Activity modification and ergonomic counseling 9

3. If conservative management fails (after 3-6 months):

   • Obtain flexion-extension radiographs of lumbar spine 1, 2
   • If instability documented: decompression with fusion at unstable level(s) only 1, 2
   • If no instability: decompression alone at symptomatic level(s) 1, 2

4. Long-term:

   • Continue osteoporosis management indefinitely 3
   • Maintenance exercise program for spinal stability 4
   • Monitor for progression of degenerative changes 9