What is the differential diagnosis for an elderly patient with sudden onset right testicle pain, mild swelling, and posterior tenderness, who has a history of prostate cancer and is currently experiencing shakiness and weakness?

Differential Diagnosis for Elderly Patient with Acute Testicular Pain

Most Critical Diagnosis to Exclude First

Testicular torsion must be ruled out immediately, as testicular viability is compromised if not treated within 6-8 hours of symptom onset, even though this diagnosis is rare in patients over 35 years of age. 1

Primary Differential Diagnoses

1. Epididymitis/Epididymo-orchitis (Most Likely)

• This is overwhelmingly the most common cause of testicular pain in adults, representing approximately 600,000 cases annually in the United States. 1
• Characterized by gradual onset of pain (though can present acutely), posterior tenderness on palpation, and mild swelling—all matching this patient's presentation 1
• The posterior location of tenderness is particularly suggestive, as the epididymis lies posteriorly to the testis 1
• In elderly men, epididymitis is typically caused by enteric organisms (E. coli, Pseudomonas) rather than sexually transmitted infections 2

2. Testicular Torsion (Surgical Emergency—Must Exclude)

• While testicular torsion is rare in patients over 35 years of age, it remains a surgical emergency that cannot be missed 1
• Typically presents with abrupt onset of severe scrotal pain, often with nausea and vomiting 1, 2
• A negative Prehn sign (pain NOT relieved when elevating the testicle) distinguishes torsion from epididymitis 1, 2
• The patient's shakiness and weakness could represent systemic response to severe pain 1

3. Metastatic Prostate Cancer to Testis (Critical Given History)

• Given this patient's history of prostate cancer, metastatic disease to the testis must be included in the differential diagnosis until tissue evaluation can be performed. 3
• Testicular metastasis from prostate cancer is rare but well-documented, and can present with testicular swelling and pain 3, 4, 5
• One case report describes an 83-year-old patient with previously treated prostate adenocarcinoma presenting with symptomatic testicular metastases 3
• Another case demonstrated solitary testicular recurrence in a 74-year-old man 4 years after prostate cancer treatment 5
• Bilateral testicular metastases have been reported, though unilateral presentation is more common 4

4. Primary Testicular Malignancy

• Testicular germ cell tumors can rarely present with sudden onset testicular pain mimicking torsion 6
• While typically presenting as painless masses, approximately 10% of testicular cancers present with acute pain 7
• The patient's history of prostate cancer does not exclude a new primary testicular malignancy 7

5. Torsion of Testicular Appendage

• Most common in prepubertal boys but can occur in adults 1
• Presents with localized tenderness, typically at the upper pole of the testis 1
• Less likely given the patient's age and presentation 1

6. Segmental Testicular Infarction

• Can present with acute testicular pain and swelling 1
• Median age of presentation is 37-38 years, making it possible in an elderly patient 1
• Ultrasound shows characteristic wedge-shaped avascular area 1

Systemic Symptoms (Shakiness and Weakness)

The patient's shakiness and weakness warrant additional consideration:

• If associated with fever, chills, or signs of sepsis, this suggests severe epididymo-orchitis with potential systemic infection requiring urgent treatment. 2
• Could represent vasovagal response to severe acute pain from any cause 1
• May indicate metastatic disease burden if related to prostate cancer recurrence 4, 5
• Consider Fournier's gangrene if there is rapidly progressive swelling, skin changes, or systemic toxicity—this is a surgical emergency requiring immediate debridement 2

Immediate Diagnostic Approach

Clinical Assessment

• Assess onset timing: abrupt (torsion) vs. gradual (epididymitis) 1, 2
• Perform Prehn sign: pain relief with elevation suggests epididymitis; no relief suggests torsion 1, 2
• Examine for cremasteric reflex: absent in torsion, present in epididymitis 8
• Check for systemic signs: fever, tachycardia, hypotension suggesting infection or sepsis 2
• Palpate for discrete masses suggesting malignancy 7, 3

Urgent Imaging

• Duplex Doppler ultrasound is the first-line imaging study, with sensitivity of 69-96.8% and specificity of 87-100% for testicular torsion. 1
• Grayscale examination should assess for the "whirlpool sign" of twisted spermatic cord, testicular homogeneity, and masses 1
• Color Doppler assessment comparing blood flow to the contralateral testis is essential 1
• Power Doppler is more sensitive for detecting low-flow states 1

Key ultrasound findings by diagnosis:

• Epididymitis: Enlarged epididymis with increased blood flow on color Doppler, scrotal wall thickening 1, 2
• Torsion: Decreased or absent blood flow, whirlpool sign, enlarged heterogeneous testis 1
• Malignancy: Hypoechoic or heterogeneous mass, may have increased vascularity 7, 6

Laboratory Studies

• Urinalysis and urine culture to evaluate for infection 1
• Complete blood count to assess for leukocytosis 7
• Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) level given history of prostate cancer 5
• Serum tumor markers (AFP, β-HCG, LDH) if malignancy suspected 7

Critical Clinical Pitfalls

• Normal urinalysis does not exclude either testicular torsion or epididymitis. 1
• Color Doppler has a 30% false-negative rate for partial torsion—if clinical suspicion is high, proceed directly to surgical exploration. 1, 2
• In patients with history of prostate cancer, always include metastatic disease in the differential until tissue evaluation is performed. 3
• There is significant overlap in clinical presentation between different causes of acute scrotal pain, making diagnosis challenging. 1
• When clinical suspicion for torsion remains high despite normal Doppler, immediate urological consultation and surgical exploration should proceed. 1

Management Algorithm

1. If high clinical suspicion for torsion: Proceed directly to surgical exploration without imaging 1, 2
2. If intermediate suspicion: Obtain urgent Duplex Doppler ultrasound 1, 2
3. If torsion confirmed or highly suspected: Immediate urological consultation for surgical exploration within 6-8 hours 1, 2
4. If epididymitis diagnosed: Treat with fluoroquinolones or cephalosporins for enteric organisms in elderly men, bed rest, scrotal elevation, and analgesics 2
5. If mass or concerning features identified: Obtain serum tumor markers and PSA, consider inguinal orchiectomy for definitive diagnosis 7, 3, 5
6. If systemic toxicity present: Consider Fournier's gangrene and initiate urgent surgical consultation with broad-spectrum antibiotics 2