Does the timing of the start of a 24‑hour urinary free cortisol collection affect the results, and is urinary cortisol always elevated in patients with Cushing’s disease?

Timing of 24-Hour Urine Cortisol Collection and Diagnostic Reliability in Cushing's Disease

Does Collection Start Time Matter?

The start time of a 24-hour urine collection does not matter as long as you collect a complete, consecutive 24-hour period. The test measures total cortisol excretion over the full day-night cycle, so whether you begin at 8 AM, noon, or midnight is irrelevant—what matters is capturing all urine produced during any continuous 24-hour window 1.

Key Collection Requirements

• Completeness is critical: The collection must span exactly 24 hours with no missed voids, as incomplete collections are the most common cause of false results 2, 3.
• Verify adequacy by measuring total creatinine excretion: This confirms the patient collected the full 24 hours of urine 1.
• At least 2-3 separate 24-hour collections are recommended before making diagnostic decisions, as urinary free cortisol can vary by up to 50% between collections even in the same patient 1, 4.

Practical Collection Guidance

The standard approach is to have patients discard the first morning void, then collect all subsequent urine until the same time the next morning (including that final void). However, an overnight collection (8 PM to 8 AM) has been validated as equally effective and may be more convenient, with 100% sensitivity and 97% specificity when using the cortisol-to-creatinine ratio 3.

---

Is Urinary Cortisol Always Elevated in Cushing's Disease?

No—urinary free cortisol is NOT always elevated in Cushing's disease, particularly in mild or cyclic cases. This is a critical pitfall that can lead to missed diagnoses if clinicians rely on a single normal result to exclude the disease 1, 4.

Why UFC Can Be Normal Despite True Cushing's Disease

• Mild Cushing's syndrome frequently shows normal or only marginally elevated UFC: In one series of 11 confirmed Cushing's cases, only 4 of 11 had any elevation in UFC, and none exceeded 2 times the upper limit of normal 4.
• Cyclic Cushing's disease produces weeks to months of normal cortisol secretion interspersed with hypercortisolemic episodes, so testing during a quiescent phase yields falsely reassuring results 1, 5.
• Renal impairment invalidates UFC measurements: Patients with chronic kidney disease may have undetectable urinary cortisol despite confirmed Cushing's disease, as cortisol clearance is reduced 6.
• The 24-hour UFC has the lowest sensitivity (>90%) among the three recommended screening tests (late-night salivary cortisol and overnight dexamethasone suppression test both have higher sensitivity) 1.

Diagnostic Algorithm When Cushing's Is Suspected

Use a multi-test approach rather than relying on UFC alone:

1. Order all three first-line screening tests simultaneously 1:

   • Late-night salivary cortisol (2-3 samples collected at 11 PM-midnight)
   • 24-hour urinary free cortisol (2-3 collections)
   • Overnight 1-mg dexamethasone suppression test (cortisol measured at 8 AM after 1 mg dexamethasone at 11 PM)

2. Interpret results in context:

   • If ≥2 screening tests are abnormal, proceed to measure 9 AM ACTH to determine if Cushing's is ACTH-dependent 1.
   • A single normal UFC does NOT exclude Cushing's disease—the other tests may still be abnormal 4.
   • Late-night salivary cortisol has the highest specificity (93-100%) and should be prioritized when results are discordant 1.

3. Account for test variability:

   • The 50% random variability in UFC necessitates multiple collections 1.
   • Patients with mild disease may have values just above the upper limit of normal 1.

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Never exclude Cushing's based on a single normal UFC, especially if clinical suspicion is moderate to high 4.
• Recognize that "normal" cortisol levels can represent relative adrenal insufficiency in acute illness, but in the outpatient screening context, normal UFC simply means that particular 24-hour period did not capture hypercortisolism 1.
• Ensure adequate renal function before interpreting UFC results—if creatinine clearance is significantly reduced, use late-night salivary cortisol instead 1, 6.
• Consider cyclic disease if initial screening is negative but clinical features are compelling—extended monitoring over 3-6 months during symptomatic periods may be necessary 1, 5.