Skin Examination Frequency Based on Risk Stratification
For average-risk adults ages 20-40, undergo professional skin examinations every 3 years and perform monthly self-skin checks; for those 40 and older, increase professional examinations to annually while continuing monthly self-checks. 1
Average-Risk Population
Ages 20-40
- Professional skin examination every 3 years as part of cancer-related checkup 1
- Monthly self-skin examinations 1
- Complete skin examinations (not partial) detect melanoma 6.4 times more frequently 1
Ages 40 and Older
High-Risk Patients Requiring Dermatology Referral
High-risk patients should be referred to a dermatologist for specialized monitoring at any age, with more intensive surveillance schedules. 1
High-Risk Criteria Requiring Dermatology Referral:
- Familial melanoma syndrome 1
- First-degree relative with melanoma 1
- Multiple atypical nevi 1
- Personal history of melanoma 2
Surveillance Schedule for Melanoma Survivors:
Stage IA melanoma:
- History and physical examination (emphasizing nodes and skin) every 3-12 months for 5 years, then annually 2
- At least annual professional skin exam for life 2
- Monthly self-skin and lymph node examination 2
Stage IB-IIA melanoma:
- History and physical examination every 6-12 months 2
- At least annual professional skin exam for life 2
- Monthly self-skin and lymph node examination 2
Stage IIB and higher:
- Every 3-6 months for the first 2 years 2
- At least every 6 months for years 3-5 2
- At least annually thereafter 2
- Monthly self-skin and lymph node examination 2
Special High-Risk Populations:
Patients with prior basal cell carcinoma:
- Nearly 50% risk of developing a second basal cell carcinoma within 3-5 years 3
- Regular screening at frequent intervals is warranted 3
Organ transplant recipients:
- At least annual dermatological examination due to marked immunosuppression and elevated skin malignancy risk 3
Patients with classic atypical mole syndrome (CAMS):
- Annual total cutaneous examination with total cutaneous photography and dermoscopy 4
- 10-year cumulative melanoma risk of 14% 4
Moderately Increased Risk Patients
- Annual skin examinations by primary care physician 1
- Monthly self-examinations 1
- Discuss individualized screening frequency with physician 1
Self-Examination Technique
Use ABCDE Criteria to Identify Suspicious Lesions:
- Asymmetry: irregular shapes or halves that don't match 1
- Border irregularity: jagged, notched, or blurred edges 1
- Color variation: multiple colors or uneven distribution 1
- Diameter: lesions larger than 6mm 1
- Evolution: changes in size, shape, color, or symptoms over time 1
Additional Assessment Tool:
- "Ugly duckling" sign: moles that look different from surrounding moles 1
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
Melanomas can occur in non-sun-exposed areas, particularly in people with darker skin, who are often diagnosed at later stages when treatment is more difficult. 1 This means complete body examination is essential, not just sun-exposed areas.
Partial skin examinations are inadequate – complete skin examinations are 6.4 times more likely to detect melanoma compared to partial examinations 2
Don't assume younger patients are low-risk – an estimated 4-8% of patients with melanoma develop new primary melanomas, typically within the first 3-5 years following diagnosis 2
Evidence Quality Note
While the USPSTF and Canadian Task Force concluded there is insufficient evidence to recommend for or against routine screening in average-risk asymptomatic individuals 1, the American Cancer Society provides clear age-based recommendations that balance detection benefits with practical implementation 1. The more recent 2019 American Academy of Dermatology guidelines provide the most detailed risk-stratified surveillance schedules for melanoma survivors 2.