What Does IVIG Do in PANS/PANDAS?
IVIG modulates inflammation by reducing pro-inflammatory immune cells and may improve neuropsychiatric symptoms in PANS/PANDAS, but the evidence remains mixed and it should be reserved for moderate-to-severe cases that have failed standard anti-inflammatory therapy.
Mechanism of Action
IVIG functions as an immunomodulatory agent through multiple pathways 1:
- Reduces pro-inflammatory monocytes and dendritic cells in the circulation, which correlates with improvement in obsessive-compulsive and tic symptoms 2
- Modulates autoimmune responses by interfering with cross-reactive antibodies that target brain nuclei through molecular mimicry following streptococcal or other infections 3
- Suppresses neuroinflammation in basal ganglia and other brain regions implicated in PANS/PANDAS pathophysiology 3
- Provides anti-inflammatory effects through both IgG variable and constant fragment mechanisms 1
Evidence for Efficacy in PANS/PANDAS
Mixed Trial Results
The evidence base shows conflicting outcomes:
- The 2016 randomized controlled trial failed to demonstrate superiority over placebo in the double-blind phase, with only 35% response rate in IVIG group versus 22% in placebo group (not statistically significant) 4
- However, open-label follow-up showed 55% improvement at 12 weeks and 62% at 24 weeks, suggesting delayed or cumulative effects 4
- A 2022 open-label trial of 10 children showed marked improvement, with 9 of 10 children achieving >30% reduction in PANS scale scores after three monthly treatments 5
- A 2024 study demonstrated statistically significant improvements in CY-BOCS, YGTSS tic scales, and parent PANS ratings (all p<0.001) following six IVIG infusions 2
Biological Correlates
- Pro-inflammatory monocyte reduction correlates with clinical improvement, both as a proportion of CD14+ cells and in absolute numbers 2
- Improvements occur across multiple domains: obsessive-compulsive symptoms, tics, behavioral regression, and school attendance 5
When to Initiate IVIG
IVIG should be considered for children with moderate-to-severe PANS/PANDAS who meet ALL of the following criteria:
Documented acute-onset neuropsychiatric symptoms including OCD or eating restriction plus at least two co-occurring symptoms (tics, behavioral regression, anxiety, etc.) 2, 3
Inadequate response to first-line anti-inflammatory therapy (NSAIDs, corticosteroids, or antibiotics if streptococcal trigger identified) 3
Significant functional impairment affecting school attendance, family functioning, or quality of life 5
Evidence of inflammatory flares temporally associated with viral upper respiratory infections or other infectious triggers 2, 3
Moderate-to-severe OCD symptoms as measured by standardized scales (CY-BOCS score typically >16) 4, 5
Dosing Protocol
Based on the strongest evidence from recent trials:
- Initial course: 1-2 g/kg divided over 1-2 consecutive days 4, 5
- Repeat monthly for 3-6 months to achieve sustained benefit 2, 5
- Assess response at 4 weeks after each infusion using standardized measures (CY-BOCS, PANS scale, CGI-I) 2, 4
The 2022 trial used 2 g/kg monthly for three months with good results 5, while the 2024 study used six infusions every 3 weeks 2. The monthly dosing schedule appears more practical and equally effective.
Important Caveats and Pitfalls
Side Effects
- Moderate-to-severe transient side effects occur in approximately 30% after first infusion but diminish substantially with subsequent treatments 5
- Monitor for hemolytic anemia and volume overload, particularly in patients with cardiac dysfunction 6
- Assess cardiac function and fluid status before infusion; slow infusion rate or divide over 2 days if abnormal 6
Clinical Pitfalls
- Do not expect immediate response: Improvements may be delayed, with maximal benefit at 12-24 weeks 4
- Single-dose trials underestimate efficacy: The failed RCT used only one course, while successful open-label studies used 3-6 monthly infusions 2, 4, 5
- Placebo response is substantial (22% in RCT), so objective measurement with validated scales is essential 4
- IVIG is NOT indicated for mild PANS/PANDAS or as first-line therapy 3, 4
Lack of Guideline Support
Critically, IVIG is not mentioned in major immunology or rheumatology guidelines for PANS/PANDAS 7. The evidence provided focuses on MIS-C (multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children related to COVID-19), which is a distinct entity [6-6]. PANS/PANDAS lacks the established guideline support that exists for conditions like Guillain-Barré syndrome, myasthenia gravis, or immune thrombocytopenia 7.
Practical Algorithm
For your 7-year-old patient with motor/vocal tics and OCD that flares with infections:
- Document baseline severity using CY-BOCS and YGTSS tic scales
- Optimize anti-inflammatory therapy (consider corticosteroid burst during acute flares)
- If symptoms remain moderate-to-severe despite 2-3 months of anti-inflammatory therapy, consider IVIG trial
- Administer 2 g/kg monthly for 3 months with pre-treatment cardiac assessment
- Reassess at 4 weeks after each infusion using standardized scales
- Define response as ≥30% reduction in CY-BOCS and "much improved" on CGI-I 4
- If no response after 3 monthly treatments, discontinue and consider alternative immunomodulatory approaches (high-dose corticosteroids, rituximab) 3
The decision to use IVIG should involve subspecialty consultation with pediatric rheumatology, immunology, or psychiatry given the lack of established guidelines and mixed evidence 7, 3.